Regular Articles
Evaluating the human–machine interface to vehicle navigation systems as an example of ubiquitous computing

https://doi.org/10.1006/ijhc.2001.0495Get rights and content

Abstract

In-vehicle navigation systems are an example of ubiquitous computing, where the computing facility is embedded in an everyday object (car) for an everyday task (driving). The maturing navigation systems market of the last 10 years has prompted academic and commercial research into the human–machine interface (HMI) for these systems. A significant body of research now exists in this specialized area and a contribution has been made towards guidelines for interface design. This paper presents an overview of evaluation methods used to date (in terms of context of use, techniques, measures and evaluators) and the pros and cons of the different approaches. It ends with a discussion of how the resulting knowledge can assist in the evaluation of other ubiquitous technologies.

References (36)

  • S.G. HART et al.

    Development of NASA-TLX (Task Load Index): results and theoretical research

  • M. SWEENEY et al.

    Evaluating user–computer interaction: a framework

    International Journal of Man–Machine Studies

    (1993)
  • N. BEVAN et al.

    Usability measurement in context

    Behaviour and Information Technology

    (1994)
  • BURNETT, G. E. 1998, “Turn right at the King's Head”: Drivers' requirements for route guidance information,...
  • BURNETT, G. E. 2000a, Usable vehicle navigation systems: are we there yet?, Proceedings of Vehicle Electronic Systems...
  • G.E. BURNETT

    “Turn right at the traffic lights”: the requirement for landmarks in vehicle navigation systems

    The Journal of Navigation

    (2000)
  • BURNETT, G. E. JOYNER, S. M. 1993, An evaluation of route guidance information displayed via a Head-Up Display, Ford...
  • BURNETT, G. E. JOYNER, S. M. 1994, Final Trials Report and CED 9 MMI Recommendations,...
  • G.E. BURNETT et al.

    An assessment of moving map and symbol-based route guidance systems

  • CAMPBELL, J. L. CARNEY, C. KANTOWITZ, B. H. 1998, Human factors guidelines for advanced traveller information systems...
  • EGGERDINGER, C. PETERS, H. 1991, The development and validation of the MMI Criteria List, CEC...
  • EVANS, J. L. KAPTEIN, N. A. MELCHIOR, E. M. BOSSER, T. STOVE, A. G. GUPTA, A. 1994, MMI applications matrix, Bristol,...
  • FAIRCLOUGH, S. H. 1991, Adapting the TLX to assess driver mental workload, 71, Loughborough, UK, HUSAT Research...
  • GREEN, P. LEVISON, W. PAELKE, G. SERAFIN, C. 1995, Preliminary Human Factors Design Guidelines for driver information...
  • ITO, T. MIKI, Y. 1997, Japan's safety guideline for in-vehicle display systems, Proceedings of 4th World Congress on...
  • JANSSEN, W. H. 1979, Routeplanning en geleiding, Een literatuurstudie, IZF 1979 C-13, Institute for Perception TNO,...
  • KING, G. F. 1986, Driver performance in highway navigation tasks, Transportation Research Board, 1093, 1,...
  • Cited by (0)

    View full text