Abstract
We propose an empirical, perception-based evaluation approach for assessing the effectiveness and efficiency of longstanding cartographic design principles applied to 2D map displays. The approach includes bottom-up visual saliency models that are compared with eye-movement data collected in human-subject experiments on map stimuli embedded in the so-called flicker paradigm. The proposed methods are applied to the assessment of four commonly used visual variables for designing 2D maps: size, color value, color hue, and orientation. The empirical results suggest that the visual variable size is the most efficient (fastest) and most effective (accurate) visual variable to detect change under flicker conditions. The visual variable orientation proved to be the least efficient and effective of the tested visual variables. These empirical results shed new light on the implied ranking of the visual variables that have been proposed over 40 years ago. With the presented approach we hope to provide cartographers, GIScientists and visualization designers a systematic assessment method to develop effective and efficient geovisualization displays.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Buying options
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Learn about institutional subscriptionsPreview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Bertin, J.: Semiology of Graphics: Diagrams, Networks, Maps. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison (1983) (French edn., 1967)
Buswell, G.T.: How People Look at Pictures. University of Chicago Press, Chicago (1935)
Mackinlay, J.D.: Automating the Design of Graphical Presentations of Relational Information. ACM Transactions on Graphics 5(2), 110–141 (1986)
Dent, B.D.: Cartography. Thematic Map Design, Wm. C. Brown, Dubuque, IA (1999)
Fabrikant, S.I., Goldsberry, K.: Thematic Relevance and Perceptual Salience of Dynamic Geovisualization Displays. In: Proceedings, 22th ICA/ACI International Cartographic Conference, A Coruña, Spain, July 9-16 (2005)
Fabrikant, S.I., Montello, D.R., Ruocco, M., Middleton, R.S.: The Distance-Similarity Metaphor in Network-Display Spatializations. Cartography and Geographic Information Science 31(4), 237–252 (2004)
Fabrikant, S.I., Montello, D.R., Mark, D.M.: The Distance-Similarity Metaphor in Region-Display Spatializations. IEEE Computer Graphics & Application, 34–44 (2006)
Fabrikant, S.I., Rebich-Hespanha, S., Hegarty, M.: Cognitively Adequate and Perceptually Salient Graphic Displays for Efficient Spatial Inference Making. Annals of the Association of American Geographers (in press)
Goldberg, J.H., Kotval, X.P.: Computer Interface Evaluation using Eye Movements: Methods and Constructs. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 24, 631–645 (1999)
Goldstein, E.B.: Sensation & Perception, 2nd edn., Wadsworth, Belmont, CA (1989)
Gregory, R.L. (ed.): The Oxford Companion to the Mind, pp. 491–493. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Griffin, A.L.: Visual Variables. In: Kemp, K. (ed.) Encyclopedia of Geographic Information Science, pp. 506–509. SAGE Publication, Thousand Oaks (2008)
Henderson, J.M., Ferreira, F.: Scene Perception for Psycholinguists. In: Henderson, J.M., Ferreira, F. (eds.) The Integration of Language, Vision, and Action: Eye Movements and the Visual World, pp. 1–58. Psychology Press, New York (2004)
Irwin, E.: Fixation Location and Fixation Duration as Indices of Cognitive Processing. In: Henderson, J.M., Ferreira, F. (eds.) The Integration of Language, Vision, and Action: Eye Movements and the Visual World, pp. 105–134. Psychology Press, New York (2004)
Itti, L., Koch, C.: Computational Modeling of Visual Attention. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2(3), 194–203 (2001)
Itti, L., Koch, C., Niebur, E.: A Model of Saliency-Based Visual Attention for Rapid Scene Analysis. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence 20(11), 1254–1259 (1998)
Jacob, R.J.K., Karn, K.S.: Eye Tracking in Human-computer Interaction and Usability Research: Ready to Deliver the Promises. In: Hyönä, J., Radach, R., Deubel, H. (eds.) The Mind’s Eye: Cognitive and Applied Aspects of Eye Movement Research, pp. 573–605. Elsevier, Amsterdam (2003)
Koch, C.: Selective Visual Attention and Computational Models (2004), http://www.klab.caltech.edu/cns186/PS/attention-koch.pdf
Lloyd, R.: Visual Search Processes Used in Map Reading. Cartographica 34(1), 11–12 (1997)
Lloyd, R., Hodgson, M.E.: Visual Search for Land Use Objects in Aerial Photographs. Cartography and Geographic Information Science 29(1), 3–15 (2002)
Lowe, R.K.: Animation and Learning: Selective Processing of Information in Dynamic Graphics. Learning and Instruction (13), 157–176 (2003)
MacEachren, A.M.: How Maps Work. Representation, Visualization, and Design. Guilford Press, New York (1995)
MacEachren, A.M., Kraak, M.-J.: Research Challenges in Geovisualization. Cartography and Geographic Information Science 28, 3–12 (2001)
Morrison, J.L.: A Theoretical Framework For Cartographic Generalization with the Emphasis on the Process of Symbolization. International Yearbook of Cartography 14, 115–127 (1974)
Muller, J.C.: Bertin’s Theory of Graphics/A Challenge to North American Thematic Cartography. Cartographica 18(3), 1–8 (1981)
Palsky, G.: The Debate on the Standardization of Statistical Maps and Diagrams (1857-1901). Elements for the history of graphical language. Cybergeo: European Journal of Geography (85) (1999) (March 16, 1999), http://www.cybergeo.eu/index148.html
Parkhurst, D., Law, K., Niebur, E.: Modeling the Role of Salience in the Allocation of Overt Visual Attention. Vision Research 42, 107–123 (2002)
Rensink, R.A., O’Regan, J.K., Clark, J.J.: To See or Not to See: The Need for Attention to Perceive Changes in Scenes. Psychological Science 8, 368–373 (1997)
Rensink, R.A.: Change Detection. Annual Review of Psychology 53, 245–277 (2002)
Rensink, R.A.: Change Blindness. In: Itti, L., Rees, G., Tsotsos, J.K. (eds.) Neurobiology of Attention, pp. 76–81. Elsevier, San Diego (2005)
Rosenholtz, R., Li, Y., Nakano, L.: Measuring Visual Clutter. Journal of Vision 7(2), 1–22 (2007)
Simons, D.J.: Current Approach to Change Blindness. Visual Cognition 7(1/2/3), 1–15 (2000)
Slocum, T.A., McMaster, R.B., Kessler, F.C., Howard, H.H.: Thematic Cartography & Geographic Visualization, 3rd edn. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River (2008)
Swienty, O., Kurz, F., Reichenbacher, T.: Attention Guiding Visualization in Remote Sensing IIM Systems. Photogrammetrie, Fernerkundung, Geoinformation 4, 239–251 (2007)
Treisman, A.M., Gelade, G.: Feature-Integration Theory of Attention. Cognitive Psychology 12, 97–136 (1980)
Wolfe, J.M., Horowitz, T.S.: What Attributes Guide the Deployment of Visual Attention and how do they do it? Nature Reviews Neuroscience 5(6), 1–7 (2004)
Wright, R.D., Ward, L.M.: Orienting of Attention. Oxford University Press, New York (2008)
Yarbus, A.L.: Eye Movements and Vision. Plenum, New York (1967)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2009 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this paper
Cite this paper
Garlandini, S., Fabrikant, S.I. (2009). Evaluating the Effectiveness and Efficiency of Visual Variables for Geographic Information Visualization. In: Hornsby, K.S., Claramunt, C., Denis, M., Ligozat, G. (eds) Spatial Information Theory. COSIT 2009. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol 5756. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-03832-7_12
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-03832-7_12
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-642-03831-0
Online ISBN: 978-3-642-03832-7
eBook Packages: Computer ScienceComputer Science (R0)