The Impact of Temporal Intent Variability on Diversity Evaluation

Abstract

To cope with the uncertainty involved with ambiguous or underspecified queries, search engines often diversify results to return documents that cover multiple interpretations, e.g. the car brand, animal or operating system for the query ‘jaguar’. Current diversity evaluation measures take the popularity of the subtopics into account and aim to favour systems that promote most popular subtopics earliest in the result ranking. However, this subtopic popularity is assumed to be static over time. In this paper, we hypothesise that temporal subtopic popularity change is common for many topics and argue this characteristic should be considered when evaluating diversity. Firstly, to support our hypothesis we analyse temporal subtopic popularity changes for ambiguous queries through historic Wikipedia article viewing statistics. Further, by simulation, we demonstrate the impact of this temporal intent variability on diversity evaluation.