Abstract
Increased attention paid to inter-group genetic variability following completion of the Human Genome Project has provoked debate about race as a category of classification in biomedicine and as a biological phenomenon at the level of the genome. Philosophers of science favor a metaphysical approach relying on natural kind theorizing, the underlying assumptions of which structure the questions asked. Limitations arise the more metaphysically invested and less attuned to scientific practice these questions are. Other questions—arguably, those that matter most socially and politically—remain unasked, not merely overlooked but systematically ignored and even foreclosed. Race fails as a postulated natural kind because it fails to meet expectations that as a category of classification it furnish an authoritative taxonomy that by depicting fundamental divisions in nature is conducive to fulfilling far-ranging explanatory aims. Racial, ethnic, and other group designations may nonetheless be projectible insofar as they support inductive inferences in biomedicine, but this does not render them any less social. Indeed, the statistical, contingent, accidental, localized, and interest-relative bases of such inferences serve to undercut the dichotomizing of race as either biological reality or social construct and favor the adoption of a pragmatic approach.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Appiah K. A. (1996) Race, culture, identity: Misunderstood connections. In: Appiah K. A., Gutman A. (eds) Color conscious: The political morality of race. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, pp 30–105
Appiah K. A. (2002) The state and the shaping of identity. In: Peterson G. B. (eds) The tanner lectures on human values. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City, pp 234–299
Appiah K. A. (2006) How to decide if races exist. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 106: 363–380
Andreasen R. O. (1998) A new perspective on the race debate. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 49: 199–225
Andreasen R. O. (2000) Race: Biological reality or social construct?. Philosophy of Science 67(Proceedings): S653–S666
Andreasen R. O. (2004) The cladistic race concept: A defense. Biology and Philosophy 19: 425–442
Andreasen R. O. (2005) The meaning of ‘race’: Folk conceptions and the new biology of race. Journal of Philosophy 102(2): 94–106
Beatty J. (1995) The evolutionary contingency thesis. In: Wolters G., Lennox J. G. (eds) Concepts, theories, and rationality in the biological sciences. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp 45–81
Blackless M., Charuvastra A., Derryck A., Fausto-Sterling A., Lauzanne K., Lee E. (2000) How sexually dimorphic are we? Review and synthesis. American Journal of Human Biology 12: 151–166
Boyd R. (1989) What realism implies and what it does not. Dialectica 43(1–2): 5–29
Carson P., Ziesche S., Johnson G., Cohn J. N. et al (1999) Racial differences in response to therapy for heart failure: Analysis of the vasodilator-heart failure trials. Journal of Cardiac Failure 5(3): 178–187
Dunn L. C. (1959) Heredity and evolution in human populations. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Gannett L. (2005) Group categories in pharmacogenetics research. Philosophy of Science 72: 1232–1247
Gannett L., Griesemer J. R. (2004) The ABO blood groups: Mapping the history and geography of genes in Homo sapiens. In: Rheinberger H.-J., Gaudillière J.-P. (eds) Classical genetic research and its legacy: The mapping cultures of twentieth-century genetics. Routledge, London & New York, pp 119–172
García-Obregón S., Alfonso-Sánchez M. A., Pérez-Miranda A. M., de Pancorbo M. M., Peña J. A. (2007) Polymorphic Alu insertions and the genetic structure of Iberian Basques. Journal of Human Genetics 52: 317–327
Gilroy P. (2000) Against race: Imagining political culture beyond the color line. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Glasgow J. (2003) On the new biology of race. Journal of Philosophy 100: 456–474
Goodman N. (1978) Ways of worldmaking. Hackett, Indianapolis, IN
Goodman N. (1983) Fact, fiction, and forecast (4th ed.). Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Griffiths P. E. (1999) Squaring the circle: Natural kinds with historical essences. In: Wilson R. A. (eds) Species: New interdisciplinary essays. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp 209–228
Hacking I. (1995) The looping effects of human kinds. In: Sperber D., Premack D., Premack A. J. (eds) Causal cognition: A multidisciplinary debate. Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp 351–383
Hacking I. (1999) The social construction of what?. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Hacking I. (2005) Why race still matters. Daedalus 134: 102–116
Hacking I. (2007) Natural kinds: Rosy dawn, scholastic twilight. Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement 82: 203–239
Häggqvist S. (2005) Kinds, projectibility and explanation. Croatian Journal of Philosophy 5(13): 71–87
Haslanger S. (2000) Gender and race: (What) are they? (What) do we want them to be?. Nous 34: 31–55
Hegele R. A., Harris S. B., Brunt J. H., Young T. K., Hanley A. J. G., Zinman B., Connelly P. W. (1999) Absence of association between genetic variation in the LIPC gene promoter and plasma lipoproteins in three Canadian populations. Atherosclerosis 146: 153–160
Henig, R. M. (2004, October 10). The genome in black and white (and gray). New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/10/magazine/10GENETIC.html. Retrieved January 10, 2009.
Hull D.L. (1965) The effect of essentialism on taxonomy: Two thousand years of stasis. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 15: 314–326 16, 1–18
Hull D. L. (1998) Species, subspecies, and races. Social Research 65(2): 351–367
Kahn J. (2004) How a drug becomes ‘ethnic’: Law, commerce, and the production of racial categories in medicine. Yale Journal of Health Policy, Law, and Ethics 4(1): 1–46
Kitcher P. (1984) Species. Philosophy of Science 51: 308–333
Kitcher, P. (1999 [2003]). Race, ethnicity, biology, culture. In L. Harris (Ed.), Racism (pp. 87–120). New York: Humanity Books (Originally published). (Reprinted in In Mendel’s mirror: Philosophical reflections on biology, pp. 230–257 by P. Kitcher. Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Kitcher P. (2007) Does ‘race’ have a future?. Philosophy & Public Affairs 35: 293–317
Kripke S. (1980) Naming and necessity. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Lewontin R. C. (1972) The apportionment of human diversity. Evolutionary Biology 6: 381–392
Longino H. E. (2002) The fate of knowledge. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Lorusso L., Boniolo G. (2008) Clustering humans: On biological boundaries. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 39: 163–170
Marjanovic D., Fornarino S., Montagna S., Primorac D., Hadziselimovic R., Vidovic S., Pojskic N., Battaglia V., Achilli A., Drobnic K., Andjelinovic S., Torroni A., Santachiara-Benerecetti A. S., Semino O. (2005) The peopling of modern Bosnia-Herzegovina: Y-chromosome haplogroups in the three main ethnic groups. Annals of Human Genetics 69: 757–763
Maugh, T. H. (2004, November 9). Drugs for only blacks stirs hope, concern. Los Angeles Times. http://articles.latimes.com/2004/nov/09/science/sci-blackdrug9. Retrieved January 10, 2009.
McOuat G. (2009) The origins of ‘natural kinds’: Keeping ‘essentialism’ at bay in the age of reform. Intellectual History Review 19: 211–230
Mill J. S. (1889) A system of logic, ratiocinative and inductive. Being a connected view of the principles of evidence and the methods of scientific investigation. Longmans Green, London
Needham P. (2002) The discovery that water is H 2 O. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 16(3): 205–226
Pigliucci M., Kaplan J. (2003) On the concept of biological race and its applicability to humans. Philosophy of Science 70: 1161–1172
Putnam H. (1975) Mind, language, and reality: Philosophical papers. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Root M. (2003) The use of race in medicine as a proxy for genetic differences. Philosophy of Science 70: 1173–1183
Sarich V., Miele F. (2004) Race: The reality of human differences. Westview Press, Boulder, CO
Smedley A. (2007) Race in North America: Origin and evolution of a worldview (3rd ed.). Westview Press, Boulder, CO
Sober E. (1980) Evolution, population thinking, and essentialism. Philosophy of Science 47: 350–383
Taylor A. L., Ziesche S., Yancy C., Carson P., D’Agostino R., Ferdinand K., Taylor M., Adams K., Sabolinski M., Worcel M., Cohn J. N. et al (2004) Combination of isosorbide dinitrate and hydralazine in blacks with heart failure. New England Journal of Medicine 351: 2049–2057
Wade, N. (2004, November 14). Race-based medicine continued... New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2004/11/14/weekinreview/14nick.html. Retrieved January 10, 2009.
Zack N. (1993) Race and mixed race. Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA
Zerjal T., Pandya A., Thangaraj K., Ling E. Y. S., Kearley J., Bertoneri S., Paracchini S., Singh L., Tyler-Smith C. (2007) Y-chromosomal insights into the genetic impact of the caste system in India. Human Genetics 121: 137–144
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gannett, L. Questions asked and unasked: how by worrying less about the ‘really real’ philosophers of science might better contribute to debates about genetics and race. Synthese 177, 363–385 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-010-9788-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-010-9788-1