The communication of factual information through various channels

https://doi.org/10.1016/0020-0271(73)90090-9Get rights and content

Abstract

The research reported here is aimed at discovering principles of human communication that may be useful in the design of conversational computers of the future. Two-man teams were asked to solve credible, real-world problems of the kind for which computers have been, or could be, of assistance. The teams communicated in different modes simulating various input-output channels between the computer and its human user. These modes were: Typewriting, handwriting, voice, and natural unrestricted communication.

The results of two experiments show that subjects can solve problems much faster when they communicate in either of the two oral modes (voice and natural communication) rather than in either of the two hard-copy modes (typewriting and handwriting). One comparison shows that typing skill per se apparently has only a small influence on communication time. Although solutions were reached much more quickly in the two oral modes, the number of messages and the number of words exchanged in these modes is very much greater than the corresponding numbers in the hard-copy modes, thus implying greatly different rates of information transmission.

Natural human communication is characterized by a great many small errors that would result in a complete failure of communication between man and computer. If they are to be truly conversational, computers of the future will have to be made much more forgiving of the many small errors that we so readily accept and overlook in our ordinary communications. The freedom to interrupt messages is an expensive option to provide in computer systems. One series of comparisons shows that the freedom to interrupt has only a negligible effect on the efficiency of human communication. p]The paper ends with a statement of some problems still to be solved if we are ever to have truly interactive conversational computers.

References (4)

  • A. Chapanis

    Prelude to 2001: Explorations in human communication

    Am. Psychol.

    (1971)
  • A.C. Clarke

    2001: A Space Odyssey

    (1968)
There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (15)

  • Social evaluations of teleconferencing

    1977, Telecommunications Policy
  • Limited vocabulary natural language dialogue

    1977, International Journal of Man-Machine Studies
  • Using computers in a natural language mode for elementary education

    1975, International Journal of Man-Machine Studies
  • The Social Psychology of Bargaining

    2015, The Social Psychology of Bargaining
  • Discourse analysis

    2015, Sublanguage: Studies of Language in Restricted Semantic Domains
View all citing articles on Scopus

This paper is condensed from a lecture delivered at various European universities and laboratories in November 1971 under the NATO Visiting Lectureship Programme of the Advisory Group on Human Factors.

The research reported here was started under Research Grant Number NGR 21-001-073 from the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and continued under Research Grant Number GN-890 from the National Science Foundation, Office of Science Information Service. The lecture and this paper were prepared under the latter grant.

The research reported here could not have been done without the enthusiastic and dedicated help of my graduate students: Messrs. Robert N. Parrish, Charles M. Overbey, Robert B. Ochsman and Gerald D. Weeks. Some of the data in the last sections of this paper are taken from Mr. Overbey's unpublished Ph.D. research conducted at The Johns Hopkins University under my direction.

View full text