Elsevier

Information Systems

Volume 21, Issue 7, November 1996, Pages 551-575
Information Systems

Analyzing information systems development: A comparison and analysis of eight is development approaches

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0306-4379(96)00028-2Get rights and content

Abstract

This paper analyses two fundamental assumptions associated with the analysis and design of information systems:: (1) the assumed organizational role of information systems, and (2) the view of information requirements. In the case of the first assumption, it distinguishes three alternatives: a technical view, a sociotechnical view, and a social view. In the case of the second assumption, again three alternatives are explored: an objective view, a subjective view, and an intersubjective view. The paper points out the importance of these assumptions from the viewpoint of IS development through the analysis of eight IS development approaches: Information Modelling, Decision Support Systems, the Socio-Technical Approach, the Infological Approach, the Interactionist approach, the Speech Act-based approach, Soft Systems Methodology and the Scandinavian Trade Unionist approach. The first four are established traditions and the last four, newer and more emerging as IS development approaches. The analysis shows that the first two established traditions have a technical-mechanistic view of the organizational role of information systems, the view of the socio-technical tradition being socio-technical and the infological approach reflecting all three views. Most of the emerging approaches emphasize the social nature of information systems. In the case of information requirements, the differences between the established and emerging approaches are not as striking. While the objective and subjective views dominate the established traditions, only the Speech Act-based approach and Soft Systems Methodology among the emerging approaches seem to emphasize the intersubjective nature of information requirements.

References (134)

  • R.J. Anderson

    Representations and requirements: the value of ethnography in system design

    Human-Computer Interaction

    (1994)
  • ANSI/X3/SPARC

    Interim report from the study group on data base management systems

    FDT Bulletin of the ACM

    (1975)
  • C. Argyris et al.
  • E. Auramäki et al.

    Modelling offices through discourse analysis: The SAMPO approach

    The Computer Journal

    (1992)
  • E. Auramäki et al.

    Modelling offices through discourse analysis: A comparison and evaluation of SAMPO with OSSAD and ICN

    The Computer Journal

    (1992)
  • E. Auramäki et al.

    A speech-act-based office modeling approach

    ACM Transactions on Office Information Systems

    (1988)
  • D.E. Avisen et al.
  • D.E Avison et al.
  • C. Banville et al.

    Can the field of MIS be disciplined?

    Communications of the ACM

    (1989)
  • R. Baskerville

    Practitioner autonomy and the bias of methods and tools

  • C. Batini et al.

    A comparative analysis of methodologies for database schema integration

    ACM Computing Surveys

    (1986)
  • R. Bentley et al.

    Ethnographically-informed system design for air-traffic control

  • H.R. Beyer et al.

    Apprenticing with the customer

    Communications of the ACM

    (1995)
  • R.B. Bostrom et al.

    MIS problems and failures. A socio-technical perspective: Part I: The causes

    MIS Quartely

    (1977)
  • R.B. Bostrom et al.

    MIS problems and failures. A socio-technical perspective: Part II: The application of socio-technical theory

    MIS Quartely

    (1977)
  • F. Brooks

    No silver-bullet, essence and accidents in software engineering

    Computer

    (1987)
  • F. Brun-Cottan et al.

    Using video to represent the user

    Communications of the ACM,

    (1995)
  • T. Burns et al.
  • G. Burrell et al.
  • G. Button et al.

    The relevance of ‘work-practice’ for design

    Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW)

    (1996)
  • S. Bødker et al.

    A Utopian experience, on design of powerful computer-based tools for skilled graphic workers

  • S. Bødker et al.

    Setting the stage for design as action

  • S. Bødker et al.

    Design in action: From prototyping by demonstration to cooperative prototyping

  • S. Bødker et al.

    Cooperative prototyping studies — users and designers envision a dental case record system

  • R. Chin et al.

    General strategies for effecting changes in human systems

  • P. Checkland
  • P. Checkland et al.
  • G.B. Davis

    Strategies for information requirements determination

    IBM Systems Journal

    (1982)
  • G.B. Davis et al.

    Management Information Systems: Conceptual Foundations, Structure and Development

    (1985)
  • S.K. Dewitz et al.

    Legal procedures as formal conversations: Contracting on a performative network

  • J.L.G. Dietz

    Subject-oriented modelling of open active systems

  • J.L.G. Dietz et al.

    Speech acts or communication action

  • J.E. Dobson et al.

    Determining requirements for CSCW: the ORDIT approach

  • S.Donaldson Dewitz

    Contracting on a performative network: Using information technology as a legal intermediary

  • S. Easterbrook

    Resolving requirements conflicts with computer-supported negotiation

  • P. Ehn
  • P. Ehn et al.

    The collective resource approach to systems design

  • P. Ehn et al.

    Cardboard computers: Mocking-it-up and hands-on the future

  • P. Ehn et al.

    The Utopia Project

  • P. Ehn et al.

    Local union influence on technology and work organization

  • Cited by (70)

    • Modeling e-Livestock Indonesia

      2021, Heliyon
      Citation Excerpt :

      Based on those considerations we choose SSM than the Speech Act-based approach. In contrast to SSM, which has a balanced orientation to technical and social aspects, the Trade Unionist approach has a more strong orientation to the technical aspect and a weak orientation to social aspects (Iivari and Hirschheim 1996). In the epistemology view, the Trade Unionist approach is primarily positivistic, while SSM has dualistic epistemology and accommodates interpretive views (Iivari et al., 1998).

    • The stickiness intention of group-buying websites: The integration of the commitment–trust theory and e-commerce success model

      2016, Information and Management
      Citation Excerpt :

      While electronic commerce (e-commerce) professionals find it increasingly difficult to motivate online consumers to stick to a specific website, significant efforts have been made to evaluate the success of e-commerce websites from technical/IS and/or transactional perspectives [80,109,117]. The technical/IS view, which is also referred to as the socio-technical view, presumes that issues related to the user adoption of IS/websites are to be investigated by primarily considering how the design and use of IS/websites can fit with organizational objectives by being an integral part of organizational communication, cooperation, and operational arrangement mechanisms (i.e., the social/organizational role of IS) [50]. In addition, Petter et al. [94] indicate that considerations related to consumer benefits (i.e., the transactional view) and consumer use of e-commerce systems (i.e., the technical view) are essential in assessing the success of IS in various contexts.

    • Does the smartest designer design better? Effect of intelligence quotient on students' design skills in architectural design studio

      2015, Frontiers of Architectural Research
      Citation Excerpt :

      Design is an open-ended problem-solving process, and the functions of design theories support designers’ cognitive abilities (Verma, 1997). Hence, design studio helps in the free exchange of ideas (Tate, 1987)through an information process that may be assumed as a social and organizational method for both tutors and students (Iivari and Hirschheim, 1996). Regarding the significance of designers’ experiences compared with regulations and facts (Demirkan, 1998), a design studio in architectural education is the first environment where the initial experiences for future professions can be obtained (Demirbaş and Demirkan, 2003).

    • Contact Centers Management Models: Analysis and Recommendations

      2021, SIST 2021 - 2021 IEEE International Conference on Smart Information Systems and Technologies
    View all citing articles on Scopus

    Recommended by Peri Loucopoulos.

    View full text