Elsevier

Computer Networks

Volume 34, Issue 5, November 2000, Pages 781-797
Computer Networks

Hybrid satellite/terrestrial networks integration

https://doi.org/10.1016/S1389-1286(00)00128-6Get rights and content

Abstract

The satellite component is expected to operate alongside that of the terrestrial component and provide a complementary rather than a competitive service. In this paper, the requirements of inter-working and integration of these networks are discussed at different levels. There are currently several consortiums that are working on global voice communications via satellite (e.g., Ellipso, Odyssey, ICO, GlobalStar, OrbComm, and Iridium). Some consortiums are working on global broadband networks via satellite (e.g., Cyberstar, Astrolink, Teledesic, Spaceway, and Skybridge). Almost all of these architectures do not consider advanced capabilities for satellite and terrestrial integration with mobile and fixed networks. Special consideration of intelligent payload architectures and management aspects is required. For the long term architecture, intelligent on-board processing (OBP) capabilities would enable adequate distribution of control for an integrated satellite and terrestrial network. This paper presents some techniques to help the evolution toward this scenario.

Introduction

Convergence of satellite and terrestrial networks is now becoming a key factor in forming the foundation for an efficient global information infrastructure (GII) that is going to be supported by the wealth of information sources offered by content providers. The focal point of this integration is to enlarge and complete service coverage, and in so doing, provide the mobile user with the ability to roam globally and internetwork efficiently across all domains. This inter-operability requires dynamic and transparent connectivity to join local and wide area, public and private networks which are characterised by a diverse mix of topologies, physical media, transmission speeds, carrier services, geographical coverage, interfaces, etc. Several European (Acts SINUS, SUMO, VANTAGE) and American (ACTS) projects, and standardisation groups (ETSI, ITU) [2], [6] have been dealing with mobile and satellite networks. Because of the large number of issues to be dealt with, no uniform and unique solution is available yet.

To address different satellite and terrestrial integration issues, consider several degrees of mobility:

  • No mobility.

  • Service portability. Roaming users can seamlessly access and use network and terminal-independent services through a number of access networks and devices. They would be offered customised virtual home environments.

  • Movability. The moving entities (users, terminals and networks) can change their attachment points to the network between calls. They must log-in to the network for the registration of their location.

  • Mobility. Mobile entities (users, terminals, and networks) can change their attachment points to the network during a call. The management centre identifies the user, can locate the serving resource at that moment, and can hand the call over to another resource, when the user moves across resource boundaries.

The mobility and movability may be “embedded”, where the users, for example, employ a mobile terminal in a mobile customer premises network (CPN); or “interlinked”, where one user is connected to the system via satellite and the other via a mobile cellular link.

Satellite service types may be divided into subservices according to the following classification:

  • Fixed satellite services. Fixed satellite services concern all radio communication services between earth stations at given positions that can be at a specified fixed point or any fixed point within specified areas. This type of service provides analogue and digital transmission nationally or internationally on the basis of a network topology that can be of transit, distribution or contribution type. (Note: these types are related to the different levels of mobility described above: fixed satellite services are related to the case of no mobility, and mobile satellite services are related to portability, movability and mobility.) Broadcast services, i.e., video, television and sound transmission, are included in this case. The following basic types of users are identified:

    • Users fixed within local “broadband islands” access remote broadband islands through areas with “satellite coverage only”. They need terminals for broadband access only. Inter-operation of islands is achieved through satellites.

    • Users access services within satellite coverage only. They need terminals for satellite access only.

    • Users access a remote broadband island from areas with satellite coverage only (or vice versa). They need terminals for satellite access only. (Note: for the “vice versa” case, terminals should have broadband access only.)

  • Mobile satellite services. Mobile services include all radio communications between a mobile earth station and the space station, or between mobile stations via one or more intermediate space stations. They provide the means of uni- or bi-directional exchange of information between users or between users and hosts, where at least one user is mobile. That means either the user's equipment is moving during communication, or it is not moving during communication but is transportable to another location (for example: a reporter’s “suitcase”-terminal with an “umbrella”-antenna). In both cases, the mobility may be global (world-wide) or local (not world-wide). Interactive and distribution services are included in this case. The following basic types of users are identified:

    • Users travelling from one “cellular island” to another via areas with satellite coverage only (using trains, aircraft or ships). They need terminals with access to satellite services via dedicated interfaces (local radio link).

    • Users moving within satellite coverage only. They need terminals for satellite access only.

    • Users travelling from cellular islands to areas with satellite coverage only and vice versa. They need dual or multimode terminals. In this case, consider also that the remote users may be in cellular islands as well as fixed broadband islands.

For a mobile architecture supporting moving and portable end devices, support for location management (i.e., registration, paging, roaming, and routing), and handover of mobile connections between access points, should be provided. The gateway earth stations (GESs) should then support interaction with mobile enabled entities (switches, terminals) and are used for interconnection of various island networks. The associated air interface may require a media access control (MAC) protocol since multiple user terminals may be trying to access the satellite channel. While the topology of terrestrial routing can be considered quasi-static, this assumption does not hold with some mobile satellite constellations with inter-satellite links, where satellite movement leads to a dynamic, although deterministic, topology. Furthermore, taking into account pointing, acquirement and tracking requirements of antennas, some inter-satellite links are not permanent as are the links between stations and satellites. The dynamics of the constellation can then cause handover of a connection, which should be handled seamlessly from a user standpoint. Taking into account all these aspects, routing algorithms for mobile constellations must face two challenges: handling numerous route computations caused by handovers as well as numerous topology changes.

This paper discusses the satellite/terrestrial integration architectures at the service level in Section 2, satellite orbit choice in Section 3, space segment technology aspects in Section 4, and network level aspects in Section 5. Mobility typically infers entities for transport, control and management. Architecture evolution should lead to more intelligent, scalable capabilities. Agents could be exploited to improve the adaptiveness of on-board systems while decreasing the latency of control and management of satellite systems. A new technology-based on DPGA may be considered to support reconfigurable and programmable on-board systems.

Section snippets

Service integration aspects

A satellite-based system has inherent capabilities of providing multipoint and broadcast transmission, connectivity between any two distant nodes within a wide-area coverage, quick network configuration and reconfiguration, rapid allocation of space segment capacity, and distance-insensitive costs. With the increased communications requirements in business networks for multimedia (voice, data and video) services [9], three generic mobile multimedia service types (Table 1) may be considered.

The choice of orbit

Access to the satellite subnetwork is one of the most difficult problems to be solved. The choice of satellite constellation will be guided by the need for coverage, availability and the path delay and loss characteristics. A fixed or mobile user does not care about the fact he uses the satellite subnetwork, he just wants the lowest cost for a service with acceptable QoS. The service provider also does not care about the usage of the satellite subnetwork; he only wants to guarantee (with

Space segment technology aspects

Three classes of satellite systems for fixed/mobile users are considered:

  • 1.

    Transparent bent pipe satellite. A transparent (mainly GEO) satellite is obviously characterised by maximum flexibility in terms of transmission parameters of the signals it has to support. This means that it is able to match any future change of these parameters. It can handle any kind of service compatible with its intrinsic power and capacity limitations. This satellite does no switching, handover or bandwidth

Network aspects

We consider two main modes of using satellites within the broadband fixed network (or mobile network). The first is according to the user access mode, where satellites provide links to fixed or mobile end users through a user network interface (UNI) that may be mobile-enhanced. The second case is according to the transit mode, where satellite links are used to interconnect broadband fixed or mobile islands hence providing network node interfaces (NNI) that may be mobility enhanced [10], [15],

Conclusion

This paper has presented some of the challenging problems encountered for the inter-working and integration of a broadband multimedia satellite and terrestrial network. It has discussed service aspects, on-board satellite technology aspects and network aspects. This paper postulated that mobile agents are suitable to be exploited by on-board satellite systems. This would improve adaptiveness of on-board system while decreasing the latency of control and management of satellite system. A new

Fawzi Daoud got his Ph.D. in Computer Science from University of Paris 6. He held several research positions: at ALCATEL Telecom and within the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique labs in France, at the National Research Council of Canada (Institute for Information Technology) and at the University of Toronto (Knowledge Media Design Institute, Computer Systems Research Institute) in Canada and at GMD-German National Research Center for Information Technology (FIT-Institute for Applied

References (26)

  • F. Daoud, Universal broadband mobility target for post TINA infrastructure: toward the fourth generation, in: IEEE...
  • H. Bischl, A. Jahn, E. Lutz, Wideband model for UMTS satellite communications, ETSI SMG5, TD 006/96,...
  • A. Bottcher, M. Werner, Strategies for handover control in low earth orbit satellite systems, in: Proceedings of the...
  • C Caini

    A spectrum- and power-efficient EHF mobile satellite system to be integrated with terrestrial cellular systems

    IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications

    (1992)
  • P Carter et al.

    Evaluation of handover mechanisms in shadowed low earth orbit land mobile satellite systems

    International Journal of Satellite Communications

    (1995)
  • J.F. Huber, Integration of satellite PCNs into terrestrial networks and the way towards UMTS, in: Proceedings of the...
  • J. Hutcheson, M. Laurin, Network flexibility of the IRIDIUM global mobile satellite system, in: Proceedings of the...
  • A. Jahn et al., Narrow- and wideband channel characterization for land mobile satellite systems: experimental results...
  • G. Losquadro, Multimedia services using portable and mobile satellite terminals, in: Proceedings of the ACTS Mobile...
  • RACE D751, Common Functional Specification, Workshop STG 2.5 Satellite Systems,...
  • F. Ananasso, M. Carosi, Architecture and networking issues in satellite systems for personal communications,...
  • F. Ananasso, F. Delli Priscoli, The role of satellites in personal communication services, IEEE Journal on Selected...
  • F. Ananasso, F. Delli Priscoli, Satellite personal communications: integration scenarios with terrestrial networks, in:...
  • Cited by (15)

    View all citing articles on Scopus

    Fawzi Daoud got his Ph.D. in Computer Science from University of Paris 6. He held several research positions: at ALCATEL Telecom and within the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique labs in France, at the National Research Council of Canada (Institute for Information Technology) and at the University of Toronto (Knowledge Media Design Institute, Computer Systems Research Institute) in Canada and at GMD-German National Research Center for Information Technology (FIT-Institute for Applied Information Technology, IPSI-Integrated Publication and Information Systems Institute, and FOKUS-Institute for Open Communication Systems) in Germany. He has been a member of several IEEE technical Committees and the IFIP TC6.6 technical committee. He has been member of program committees of major IEEE Conferences, chair of several international workshops and guest editor for several international journals.

    View full text