Time-dependent analysis and simulation-based reliability assessment of suspended cables with rheological properties
Introduction
Ropes made from high strength synthetic fibres may soon be preferred for use in cable suspension bridges and roofs. They have many advantages over traditional materials and could be used to replace high tensile steel cables in many application areas of tension structures, particularly where low weight and corrosion resistance are of important concern [1]. It is clear that in contrast to the classical tension steel rods and bars, which operate in the linear elastic range, steel cables and mainly fibre ropes have time-dependent non-linear viscoelastic properties. To predict the structural response and assess the structural reliability and serviceability of tension structures with suspended fibre cables during their entire service life, adequate closed-form and numerical analytical models for time-dependent analysis and adequate methods for estimating the probability of failure must be available.
Various papers and books have been published concerning closed-form [2], [3], [4], [5] and numerical [6], [7], [8], [9], [10], [11], [12], [13], [14] methods for analysis of suspended cable structures considering geometrical and material non-linearities. Most of the recent methods of non-linear analysis of cable structures are based on the discretisation of the equilibrium equations using FEM and solving the resulting non-linear algebraic equations by numerical methods. The non-linear material model of cable structural element was proposed by Jonatowski and Birnstiel [6]. The complementary energy principle for a cable modelled as one-dimensional continuum has been presented for large deflection analysis by Cannarozzi [15]. Kanno et al. [16] derived a special method for friction or friction-less analysis of non-linear elastic cable structures based on second-order cone programming. Lefik and Schrefler [17] present an example of the use of an artificial neural network for parameter identifications of a theoretical elasto-plastic model of the behaviour of a superconducting cable under cyclic loading. Iványi and Topping [18] presented a new graph representation for cable-membrane structures modelled using both one- and two-dimensional elements. Al-Quassab and Nair [19] applied the wavelet-Galerkin method to study the free vibrations of a suspended cable.
The common approach to these investigations is to study the cable structure as a geometrically non-linear system. However, only a little attention is paid to the time-dependent analyses of suspended cable with rheological properties. Therefore the purpose of this paper is to derive and present non-linear time-dependent closed-form and discrete static solutions of a suspended cable with viscoelastic properties considering the creep effects of the synthetic fibre ropes. For the time-dependent analysis of a suspended cable, the time domain is divided into a discrete number of time steps. The creep theory is adopted for rheological analysis. In the case of closed-form analysis the Irvine’s convenient form of the cable equation [2] is modified because the effects of a creep strain need to be incorporated to the cable and deflection equation. For the time-dependent discrete non-linear analysis of the suspended cable, a finite element method based on the displacement formulation is used. A time-dependent tangential stiffness matrix of the cable element is defined. Incremental and iterative solution strategies have been implemented to solve the geometrically and physically non-linear behaviour problem.
Structural reliability theory has received considerable attention in the literature [20], [21], [22], [23]. The general principles for a probabilistic design of bearing structures were published by the Joint Committee on Structural Safety and can be found in [24].
The available methods for estimating the probability of failure Pf(t) can be roughly classified into two groups, which can be marked as gradient-based (FORM and SORM approaches) and simulation-based methods (Monte Carlo method). The progress in the use for bearing structures and elements reached the Monte Carlo simulation method and its modifications [25], [26], [27]. Simulation-based methods hinge upon the creation of a set of N(t) response samples on which the probability of failure can be estimated at time t as Pf(t) = Nf(t)/N(t), where Nf(t) is the number of samples lying in the failure domain at time t. The last from the described methods will be applied in the paper.
The intention of the paper is to illustrate the ability of the probabilistic time-dependent reliability assessment procedure applied to non-linear suspended cable structure with rheological properties, when a rope made from the high strength synthetic fibres is used in order to demonstrate the new qualitatively different concept. Attention is turned to the individual main steps in the assessment procedure, i.e. to the selection of an appropriate method of the time-dependent structural analysis and to derivation of an appropriate closed-form and discrete analytical models, analysis of random variables representing individual actions, evaluation of the structural response with respect to the interaction of the random variables considering a history of the time-dependent action effects and to the definition of the limiting values considering serviceability of cable structure.
Finally, it is, perhaps, necessary mentioning that although the engineering theory of a suspended cable was well developed, despite numerous examples in the literature, no other closed-form model has as yet been proposed which can predict the creep and associated deflections in suspended cables composed of synthetic fibres. An area, included improvement of theoretical approaches (which unlike of the previous solutions, include creep) for predicting the time-dependent behaviour of suspended cable composed of synthetic fibres, can be considered as distinct in this work.
Section snippets
Time-dependent closed-form analysis
All the geometrical and force quantities and equations of the suspended cable, geometrical–deformational equations considering large deflections, physical and constitutive equations as well as all deflections and state cable equations are expressed as the time and stress functions respecting non-linear creep and rheological parameters. They can be expressed by the only one unknown value at the investigated time t, i.e. by the horizontal component of the cable force H(t) = H(t0) ± ΔH(t), where H(t0)
Description of computational model
A computational model of the geometrically and parametrically non-linear cable structures with the rheologic properties is based on the deformation variant of the FEM [6], [7], [8]. Time-dependent behaviour of structure during the construction process as well as during the service life of structure can be analyzed through the derived model. For the time-dependent analysis of the cable structure, the time domain is divided into a discrete number of time steps. At each time increment, the
Numerical applications and discussions of results
The following examples are given to briefly illustrate the application of the closed-form and numerical theories to practical problems. Synthetic fibre ropes are an attractive practical alternative to steel wire ropes and they are used in prestressed suspension roofs and bridges. It is clear that for these applications a good understanding of the creep behaviour of material and rheological behaviour of structure is highly desirable, because load durations of many decades are required. The
Simulation-based time-dependent reliability assessment of suspended cable with rheological properties
The fully probabilistic simulation-based time-dependent reliability assessment is applied on the suspended cable shown in Fig. 8.
At this point, it is, worthwhile explaining the difference between a classical time-dependent reliability analysis and a time-dependent reliability analysis in the case presented in the paper. In classical time-dependent reliability problems, interest often lies in estimating the probability of failure Pf(t) over an investigated time interval, say from t0 to tk. This
Conclusions
In this paper the non-linear time-dependent closed-form static solution of suspended cable with unmovable and elastic yielding supports subjected to various types of loads has been presented. Irvine’s forms of the deflection and the cable equations were modified because of the effects of non-linear creep.
For the non-linear time-dependent discrete analysis of the suspended cable, a finite element method based on the displacement formulation was used. Modelling of the rheological cable properties
Acknowledgement
This work is a part of the research project No. 1/0357/03, partially founded by the Scientific Grant Agency of the Ministry of Education of Slovak Republic and the Slovak Academy of Sciences.
References (29)
- et al.
Exact solutions for elastic cable systems
Int J Solids Struct
(1981) A finite element approach for cable problems
Int J Solids Struct
(1979)- et al.
A curved element for the analysis of cable structures
Comput Struct
(1981) Finite element modelling of cable networks with flexible supports
Comput Struct
(2001)- et al.
Finite element formulation for modeling sliding cable elements
Comput Struct
(2004) A minimum principle for tractions in the elastostatics of cable networks
Int J Solids Struct
(1987)- et al.
Artificial neural network for parameter identifications for an elasto-plastic model of superconducting cable under cyclic loading
Comput Struct
(2002) - et al.
A new graph representation for cable-membrane structures
Adv Eng Software
(2002) - et al.
Estimation of failure probabilities for intersections of non-linear limit states
Structural Safety
(2001) - et al.
Monte-Carlo simulation of the time dependent failure of bundles of parallel fibres
Eur J Mech, A/Solids
(1996)
Cable structures
Contribution on nonlinear solution of cable systems
Bauingenieur
An introduction to cable roof structures
Inelastic stiffened suspension cable structures
J Struct Div, ASCE
Cited by (13)
Time-dependent reliability analysis of the suspender in half-through arch bridge considering temperature effect
2022, StructuresCitation Excerpt :A time-dependent safety level assessment method for suspension cables considering corrosion is proposed by Elachachi [4]. The time-dependent serviceability of suspension cables in required time is assessed by Kmet [5] taking into account of the variability of structural geometry, elasticity modulus, creep strain increments and loads. Time-dependent reliability prediction for the main cable of a suspension bridge is conducted by Fan [6] based on the dynamic monitoring data.
An innovative approach for numerical simulation of stress relaxation of structural cables
2017, International Journal of Mechanical SciencesCitation Excerpt :Creep or relaxation causes changes in cable length or pretension level, which will influence member lengths and internal force in tension structures. This behavior, when interacting with other sources of time-dependent deformations, may affect the long-term structural performance, especially for pretension reinforced concrete structures [5], cable stayed bridges [6] and cable structures [7]. Due to the wide application of pre-stressed concrete structures, previous researches on creep and relaxation were mainly focused on high strength steel wires and spiral strands used for concrete reinforcement.
Finite element simulation of creep of spiral strands
2016, Engineering StructuresCitation Excerpt :Creep of cables causes permanent strain in cable members, slackening of cables, additional deflections of the structure and a decrease in stiffness which should be considered during the design process. Experience with a number of cable structures constructed from steel wire ropes or synthetic fibre ropes have shown that their possible failure is characterised by time-dependent changes in the tension stiffness and consequently by excessive deflections of structures due to the increments of cable member lengths subjected to creep [1]. Thus, it is necessary to be precise in predicting creep strains as the size of creep strains can significantly influence the total deformation of cables and consequently, the actual behaviour of cable structures, too.
Time-dependent analysis of cable nets using a modified nonlinear force-density method and creep theory
2015, Computers and StructuresCitation Excerpt :Kmet [31] proposed a finite element analysis of pre-stressed net structures made of steel cables with rheological properties. Kmet et al. [50] presented closed-form solutions and a simulation-based reliability assessment of suspension cables made of synthetic materials with time-dependent properties. Actual values of cables lengths at investigated times are determined by means of corresponding rheological constitutive equations.
Time-dependent analysis of cable domes using a modified dynamic relaxation method and creep theory
2013, Computers and StructuresCitation Excerpt :Therefore, authors in [6] established a general method to determine the distribution of initial prestresses for different types of cable domes. Experiences with a number of cable structures constructed of steel wire ropes or synthetic fibre ropes have shown that their possible failure is characterised by the time-dependent changes in the tension stiffness and consequently by excessive deflections of structures due to the increments of cable member lengths subjected to creep [7]. Thus it is necessary to be precise in prediction of creep strains as the size of creep strains can significantly influences total deformations of cables and consequently, the actual behaviour of cable structures, too.
Reliability Evaluation Based on Multiple Response Surfaces Method Considering Construction Uncertainties of Cable Tension for a Hybrid Roof Structure
2021, ASCE-ASME Journal of Risk and Uncertainty in Engineering Systems, Part A: Civil Engineering