Design and analysis of collaborative interactions in social educational videogames
Introduction
During long periods of hospitalisation, children are liable to develop stress and anxiety caused by physical discomfort due to their illnesses and treatments, by fear of medical procedures, separation, change of environment, and by being confined with restricted movements. Lack of face to face interaction and little communication with the family can contribute to the low morale that could obstruct the efficiency of the medical treatment or cause psychological trauma. One recommended solution is to counteract this situation with toys and promote gaming activities with a proven therapeutic value that involve love and fun, raise their morale, augment tolerance to pain, and improve the effectiveness of the treatments. In this sense, the use of new technologies, and in particular videogames, can become an element of compensation, because games are a vital part in the process of healing for a child and may work as a ‘social companion’ for the minor in a moment of necessity, particularly when there is no one else around.
The lack of motivation for conducting studies on hospitalised minors can be addressed through the use of adequate tools and methodologies which take isolation into consideration. One way to mitigate isolation wold be to use methodologies and techniques originated in collaborative learning systems that make possible and necessary the interaction with other students (Soller & Lesgold, 2000). Since children in hospitals have widely differing personalities, it is difficult for teachers to provide them with individual attention. Also, the circumstances that surround the hospitalised student can change quickly in short periods of time. Their emotional state, necessities and skills can be seriously affected. In order to contribute to the normalisation of children who cannot attend school normally, we have developed educational virtual worlds in which the students have the opportunity to play and go on quests while engaging in activities specially designed so they can learn, play, enjoy and interact.
The type of gaming activity that we propose in this paper not only offers a way to amuse the children in their everyday lives, but also a way of being in touch with others while giving them goals to achieve as a group, thus maintaining their social relationships. Moreover, through the collaborative learning videogame, significant skills like communication, collaboration and team work are improved.
In this paper we aim to design and develop multi-player (collaborative) game-based learning, combining theories based on Digital Game-Based Learning (DGBL) with Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning (CSCL). Our main hypothesis states that tools based on DGBL + CSCL can better support not only the learning of hospitalised children but the development of significant skills like communication, collaboration and team work. We have studied and analysed the human factors (Norman, 2004) associated with the videogame, such as the playability and its attributes (González Sánchez, Gil Iranzo, & Gutiérrez Vela, 2011), paying special attention to the emotional and social aspects resulting from the teamwork (Gunes and Pantic, 2010, Russell, 1980).
The main research questions discussed in this paper are the following:
- (a)
What requisites define the design and development of social educational videogames to connect hospitalised children with their classmates?
- (b)
What types of interactions occur in a multiplayer educational videogame and what emotions does it cause?
The paper is organised as follows: first, we consider the unique problem posed by hospitalised children; second, we offer a theoretical background on digital game based learning and discuss prototypes; third, we present the objectives and methodology; finally, we describe the case study and offer our results and conclusions.
Section snippets
SAVEH context
Integration and inclusion have different connotations in the school organisation of children with special educational needs. School integration means incorporating a philosophy of normalisation against segregational practices and focusing on strategies and methods for adapting disabled children to traditional schooling. Moreover, the inclusive school philosophy is based on a school for all, where every student, regardless of his or her characteristics (disease, disability, etc.), has the
Theoretical background
Although designed for recreational, and not educational, purposes, current commercial games like World of Warcraft provide access to a world of educational possibilities (Chang, 2008, Corneliussen and Walker, 2008, Bainbridge, 2010, Ducheneau, N, 2010, Golub A, 2010, Hui-Yin and Shiang-Kwei, 2010, Pirius and Creel, 2010), such as: students collaborating on and discussing ideas and possible solutions, connecting with other students around the world, immersing students in a learning experience
Prototyping: requisites, design and development
Prototypes are a great communication tool for fleshing out design ideas, testing assumptions, and gathering real-time feedback from users (Dow et al., 2011). For this reason, during the initial phase we developed two prototypes and performed two kinds of tests with members of the research team: (a) prototype testing and iterative redesign and (b) playability evaluation. These two tests complement each another. Three evaluation sessions were held with the experts of the interdisciplinary team to
Method
In an effort to provide an effective approach for supporting the education of hospitalised children that uses the huge potential of technology to connect children with their schools, we have, within the framework of the SAVEH project, designed and evaluated educational videogames with experts and children that take into account the following objectives:
- 1.
Analyse the requisites of the videogame design, in particular those involving collaboration and playability.
- 2.
Evaluate the interactions among
Conclusions
In this paper, we have presented the SAVEH context and the main variables that affect the situation of hospitalised children. Educational videogames, in the context of SAVEH, contribute to developing the social and affective aspects of children who are in hospital. Consequently, we presented a set of requisites that define the design and development of social educational videogames to connect hospitalised children with their classmates. These prototypes included collaborative learning patterns
Acknowledgements
This work has been developed in the context of the European research Project SAVEH MAC/1/100, funded by the INTERREG program PCT-MAC 2007–2013, “Developing healthy habits and physical education through Educational Games for Hospitalized Children and Adolescents, Reference EDU2010-20010 of Ministry of Science and Innovation of Spain and CYTED Project 513RT0481 – “Iberoamerican Network for the support of processes of teaching and learning of skills through collaborative and ubiquitous
References (41)
- et al.
Designing social videogames for educational uses
Computers and Education
(2012) - et al.
Model-checking for adventure video games
Information and Software Technology
(2009) - et al.
A documental approach to adventure game development
Science of Computer Programming
(2007) The Warcraft civilisation: Social science in a virtual world
(2010)Social interaction systems: Theory and measurement
(1999)- et al.
Authoring game-based adaptive units of learning with IMS learning design and <e-Adventure>
International Journal of Learning Technology
(2007) Gaming as writing, or, world of Warcraft as world of Wordcraft
Computers and Composition Online
(2008)Body language: What you need to know
(2007)- et al.
A computational model to support the monitoring of the collaborative learning process
Advanced Technology for Learning
(2004) - et al.
Designing collaborative learning environments using digital games
Journal of Universal Computer Science
(2007)
Children’s unspoken language
Visual cues of communication in children
Enfance
Massively multiplayer online games as living laboratories: Opportunities and pitfalls
Intelligent tutoring systems, educational data mining, and the design and evaluation of video games
Intelligent Tutoring Systems Lecture Notes in Computer Science
Being in the world (of Warcraft): Raiding, realism, and knowledge production in a massively multiplayer online game
Anthropological Quarterly
Cited by (43)
Pedagogical practices developed with children through hospital classes: An integrative literature review
2023, Journal of Pediatric NursingA systematic review of physical–digital play technology and developmentally relevant child behaviour
2021, International Journal of Child-Computer InteractionCitation Excerpt :Previous studies have found mixed and therefore inconclusive evidence of the effects of screen technology use for child learning and development. The studies show both benefits (Cheng et al., 2015; De Aguilera & Mendiz, 2003; González-González et al., 2014; Kirriemuir, 2005) and detriments (Cliff et al., 2017; Kostyrka-Allchorne, Cooper, & Simpson, 2017; Schmidt et al., 2008; Setliff & Courage, 2011; Sigman, 2019) of such a type of technology for children’s cognitive skills, social skills and activity, physical activity, content knowledge and general play behaviour. New research has started to disentangle these inconsistent effects.
Evaluating aspects of usability in video game-based programming learning platforms
2021, Procedia Computer ScienceA systematic review of game technologies for pediatric patients
2018, Computers in Biology and MedicineAffective states in computer-supported collaborative learning: Studying the past to drive the future
2018, Computers and EducationCitation Excerpt :Studies of Validation Research type investigate new techniques that have not been implemented in practice. Four studies, of which two use personality trait (*Hishina, Okada, & Suzuki, 2005; *Graf & Bekele, 2006), one uses emotion (*González-González, Toledo-Delgado, Collazos-Ordoñez, & González-Sáchez, 2014), and one uses personality trait and emotion (*Boff, Vicari, et al., 2008). They were validated through registers and data sets provided by researchers or by the use of population samples (pilot tests).
Requirements of Enjoyable Mobile Learning Applications for Deaf Children
2024, Journal of Information and Communication Technology