‘First do no harm’: Factors influencing teachers’ ability and willingness to use ICT in their subject teaching
Section snippets
The context of the research
Over the past decade, there has been considerable pressure on teachers in the United Kingdom (UK) to use information and communications technology (ICT) in their subject teaching. Politicians outlined a positive vision of the beneficent and transformative influence which ICT would have on educational outcomes (see, for example, Blair, 1995, Blair, 1997, Clarke, 2003) and a series of policy documents talked up the importance of the United Kingdom developing a technologically sophisticated
Rationale for the research design
Although a decade ago there was some evidence of teacher antipathy or ‘ideological’ opposition to the use of ICT – the belief that new technology had little or nothing to offer in particular subject disciplines (see, for example, Easdown, 1994, Summers and Easdown, 1996), more recently, there is evidence to suggest that many teachers are more positive about the possible benefits of using ICT in subject teaching (Easdown, 2000, Haydn, 2004). The research design was predicated on the proposition
The structure of the project
The funding for the project supported the formation of two groups of secondary teachers in science and history. The choice of subjects reflected the curriculum specialisms of the university tutors involved, and all the teachers involved in the project were members of the regional initial teacher education (ITE) partnership. At history and science mentor meetings and in letters to the history and science mentors active in the ITE partnership, teachers were invited to participate in the project,
Processes and outcomes
The discussions on previous use of ICT elicited considerable comment on participants’ experiences of New Opportunities Fund (NOF) training in the use of ICT in subject teaching. The vehemence of teachers’ views was one of the most striking aspects of the feedback from the initial research workshops. The most positive comment was that the training ‘was not a complete failure’, but generally, comments were disparaging and negative:
‘A waste of money … and created a lot of resentment.’
‘It was like a
Evaluation
Feedback from participants was obtained by devoting the last session of the research workshops to reflection on participants’ involvement in the project (audio or video recorded), by follow up emails and by subsequent face to face conversations with those involved. By these means, some comment was elicited from 31 of the 37 participants (three teachers had to leave before the end of the afternoon, and two made no comment and two of these did not respond to follow up emails). ‘Internal’
‘First do no harm’
Given the history of teacher development in the use of ICT we believe the maxim taken from the medical profession of, ‘first do no harm’ is a sensible starting point. Although not all the teachers involved in the project made major strides in embedding ICT into their subject teaching, there were no instances of teacher ‘regression’ or ‘allergic reaction’ to the research workshops, such as that reported in their experiences of NOF training. Almost all the participants reported that they had
References (37)
ICT: Changing education
(2001)Good school/bad school: Paradox and fabrication
British Journal of Sociology of Education
(1997)The teacher’s soul and the terrors of performativity
Journal of Education Policy
(2003)Teaching Today
(1995)Foreword in connecting the learning society
(1997)- Barton, R., & Haydn, T. (2004). Trainee teachers and ‘impact’ learning: A study of trainees’ views on what helps them...
ImpaCT2: Emerging findings from the evaluation of the impact of information and communications technologies on pupil attainment
(2001)Foreword, curriculum online
(2003)- Cochrane, P. (1995). Quoted in Times Educational Supplement. 23...
- Department for Education (1993). Statistical bulletin: Survey of information technology in schools, Issue no. 6/93....
Connecting the learning society
Teaching: High status, high standards. Requirements for courses of initial teacher training, Circular 4/98
Transforming the way we learn: A vision of the future of ICT in schools
Fulfilling the potential: Transforming teaching and learning through ICT in schools
Student teachers, mentors and information technology
Journal of Information Technology for Teacher Education
History teachers and ICT
Action research for educational change
Cited by (36)
Pre-service teachers' self-efficacy perceptions on Web Pedagogical Content Knowledge
2015, Computers and EducationCitation Excerpt :The emergence of modern computer technologies and the new generation of Web has profoundly changed the way students behave and communicate with each other, which in turn altered the mediation of teaching and learning (Chai, Koh, Ho, & Tsai, 2012; Cheon, Song, Jones, & Nam, 2010; Drexler, Baralt, & Dawson, 2008; Tsai, 2001). In most educational settings, teachers are required to utilize ICT in their teaching (Baylor & Ritchie, 2002; Haydn & Barton, 2008; Zhao, Tan, & Mishra, 2001). The importance of integrating ICT in education and teachers' competence in technology mainly results from characterization of a new generation, the so-called ‘Net Generation’ or ‘the digital natives' that refers to young people born roughly between 1982 and 1994 and grew up immersed in technology (Oblinger & Oblinger, 2005; Prensky, 2001; Tapscott, 1998).
Do challenge, task experience or computer familiarity influence the learning of historical chronology from virtual environments in 8-9 year old children?
2012, Computers and EducationCitation Excerpt :Other measures showed no significant differences. The results reinforced earlier findings, that PowerPoint seems to be an especially ineffective medium for conveying chronologically sequenced information (Haydn, 2008; see Foreman et al., 2007), and once again indicated that children of primary school age appear not to experience the kind of benefit from using VEs in the history context that characterises an older, undergraduate sample (Foreman et al., 2008). Although there was no difference among conditions in the present study, it was notable that children in this study (tested with the challenge of having to anticipate up-coming items) performed significantly better than primary school children tested with passive fly-throughs in the previous study (Foreman et al., 2008), demonstrating the benefit of using challenge in this context, as in others where motivation has been enhanced by the use of computer game formats (Barnett et al., 1997; Myers, 1990).
A descriptive survey on New Learning Technologies: a sample of Italian teachers
2022, CEUR Workshop ProceedingsTeachers’ Perspectives on the Integration of Information and Communication Technology: The Case of a Teachers’ Union
2022, Africa Education ReviewDiscovering digital technology training challenges for future-ready educator: A preliminary study from trainer perspective
2020, Universal Journal of Educational Research