The influence of task demand and social categorization diversity on performance and enjoyment in a language learning game
Introduction
The effects of the competition and cooperation aspects of group task demand on motivation, engagement, and task performance have been researched in a wide range of domains, including physical persistence, motor performance, learning, and group decision making (Deutsch, 1949, Johnson et al., 1986, Lungu and Debas, 2013, Tauer and Harackiewicz, 2004). As competition and cooperation are the basic mechanics present in most computer and video games, particularly multiplayer gaming, scholars are beginning to examine the effects of competition and cooperation in digital games on enjoyment (Schmierbach, Xu, Oeldorf-Hirsch, & Dardis, 2012), motor performance (Peng and Crouse, 2013, Peng and Hsieh, 2012, Staiano et al., 2012), and aggression (Eastin, 2007, Ewoldsen et al., 2012, Schmierbach, 2010, Velez et al., 2012).
The effects of group task demand on lower performing (inferior) individuals is relatively understudied. Understanding how lower performing individuals are impacted by task demand and identifying ways to promote performance and motivation are critical for serious games (Ritterfeld, Cody, & Vorderer, 2009) and mediated educational tools because it is crucial to benefit all users when leveraging serious games and other technology-based tools for motivation and performance enhancement. Otherwise, this might result in “the poor get poorer”. To the best of our knowledge, the current research in serious games and computer-based education lacks evidence regarding lower performing individuals. Therefore, the first goal of the present study is to add research evidence regarding the effects of task demand type on lower performing individuals.
One type of group task demand that has received considerable attention in the group process and motivation literature are conjunctive tasks, in which the group's overall performance depends on the results of the inferior group member(s). Studies have consistently found that conjunctive tasks are effective in promoting inferior members' motivation, particularly in physical and motor performance tasks (see Weber & Hertel, 2007, for a meta-analytic review). However, conjunctive tasks have not been fully explored as a game mechanic or in cognitive performance tasks. Given its motivational potential in the physical and motor performance domain, research is needed to examine whether conjunctive tasks would result in similar motivational gains for the low-performing partner in game contexts or cognitive performance contexts. If similar results are found, conjunctive task demand can be applied for motivational gain and may have significant impact for educational games or academic learning. Further, there is very limited research evidence on the effects of conjunctive task demand on cognitive tasks, especially learning outcomes. Thus, it is almost unknown if a less capable individual would also benefit from conjunctive tasks when it comes to the educational context. Therefore, the second goal of the present study is to fill the gap in the current body of research regarding the effects of conjunctive task demand on motivation and performance in the domain of learning and cognitive tasks (i.e., a foreign language learning computer game).
Additionally, motivation gain related studies targeting inferior group members predominantly center on extrinsic motivation, while overlooking intrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation, which is mostly operationalized as enjoyment of task, is an important component for both explaining and predicting human activities (Deci & Ryan, 1985). The assumption of gaming is based on the premise of engaging players via a fun experience. Understanding how task demand type influences enjoyment is critical for the development of games to increase motivation. Therefore, the third goal of the present research is to examine the effects of competitive, cooperative, and conjunctive task demands on intrinsic motivation as well as performance for lower performing individuals in a cognitive task using a digital game.
Competitive, cooperative, and conjunctive task demands all operate in the group setting. As such, social categorization diversity of the group is an important factor to consider. However, only limited evidence is available regarding the potential moderating effects of social categorization diversity in multiplayer gaming and these studies mostly focus on physical exertion games or violent video games (Peng and Hsieh, 2012, Velez et al., 2012). Therefore, the fourth goal of the present research is to expand empirical evidence regarding the potential interaction effects of social categorization diversity and group task demand on motivation and performance to the serious games for learning domain.
Section snippets
Task demand type, motivation, and performance
Working in a group elicits an increase in effort of individuals when compared to working alone (Allen and Hecht, 2004, Hüffmeier and Hertel, 2011). The most frequently studied task demands in group settings include competitive, cooperative, and conjunctive tasks. Competitive tasks involve at least two individuals attempting to outperform the others in a zero-sum manner. Cooperative tasks involve at least two individuals working together to attain a common goal (Johnson & Johnson, 1989). It
Study design
The study employed a 2 (social categorization diversity: in-group or out-group) × 3 (group task demand: competitive, conjunctive, or cooperative) +1 control (individual task demand) design. The individual task demand condition serves as a control group to compare with the six group task demand conditions. To examine the task demand effects on performance and enjoyment, comparisons were conducted among the individual game play condition, the competitive conditions (including both in-group and
Results
To examine the effects of the four task demand types (individual, competitive, cooperative, and conjunctive tasks) on performance, a one-way analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) was conducted. The game score of the trial game session (i.e., family-related Italian words) was used as the covariate to control for individual difference in language learning. ANCOVA results indicated that the four study conditions resulted in significant difference in performance of learning of food-related Italian
Discussion and conclusions
This study attempted to examine the effects of task demand type as well as its interaction with social categorization diversity on performance and enjoyment in a cognitive task—learning Italian in a digital game. Consistent with previous literature on task demand type in physical persistence tasks (Weber & Hertel, 2007), we found that conjunctive task demand was the most effective in the cognitive domain—learning new knowledge. No difference was found for enjoyment among the four task demand
References (51)
- et al.
When the whole is more than the sum of its parts: group motivation gains in the wild
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
(2011) - et al.
Social gaming is inSIDE: impact of anonymity and group identity on performance in a team game-based learning environment
Computers & Education
(2015) - et al.
Working harder with the out-group: the impact of social category diversity on motivation gains
Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes
(2007) - et al.
The influence of competition, cooperation, and player relationship in a motor performance centered computer game
Computers in Human Behavior
(2012) - et al.
Looking down and ramping up: the impact of status differences on effort in intergroup contexts
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
(2010) - et al.
Perceptions and experiences of, and outcomes for, university students in culturally diversified dyads in a computer-supported collaborative learning environment
Computers in Human Behavior
(2014) - et al.
Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations: classic definitions and new directions
Contemporary Educational Psychology
(2000) - et al.
The ‘romance of teams’: toward an understanding of its psychological underpinnings and implications
Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology
(2004) Among the better ones: upward assimilation in social comparison
- et al.
Intrinsic motivation and self-determination in human behavior
(1985)
An experimental study of the effects of co-operation and competition upon group process
Human Relations
The influence of competitive and cooperative group game play on state hostility
Human Communication Research
Rules and instances in foreign language learning: interactions of explicit and implicit knowledge
European Journal of Cognitive Psychology
Effect of playing violent video games cooperatively or competitively on subsequent cooperative behavior
Cyberpsychology Behavior and Social Networking
Buddy up: the Köhler effect applied to health games
Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology
A theory of social comparison processes
Human Relations
Distinctiveness of social categorization and attitude toward in-group members
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
The impact of collectivism and in-group/out-group membership on the evaluation generosity of team members
Academy of Management Journal
Achievement goal orientations and intrinsic motivation in physical fitness testing with children
Pediatric Exercise Science
Social indispensability or social comparison: the why and when of motivation gains of inferior group members
Journal of Applied Social Psychology
“Don't let the group down”: facets of instrumentality moderate the motivating effects of groups in a field experiment
European Journal of Social Psychology
Interindividual- intergroup discontinuity effect as a function of trust and categorization: the paradox of expected cooperation
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Aerobic exercise is promoted when individual performance affects the group: a test of the Köhler motivation gain effect
Annals of Behavioral Medicine
Cooperation and competition: Theory and research
Comparison of computer-assisted cooperative, competitive, and individualistic learning
American Educational Research Journal
Cited by (15)
Emotional responses to performance feedback in an educational game during cooperation and competition with a robot: Evidence from fNIRS
2023, Computers in Human BehaviorCitation Excerpt :Additionally, competition is one of the most important approaches to promote motivation and positive gaming experience in entertainment games (Vorderer et al., 2003). In serious games, cooperative and competitive structures attract continuing research interest, including their effects on performance (Badatala et al., 2017), engagement (Creighton & Szymkowiak, 2014), enjoyment (Peng et al., 2016), motivation (Novak et al., 2014), etc. Emotions related to performance, enjoyment, engagement, and motivation (Cheng et al., 2020; Greipl et al., 2021; Ninaus et al., 2019) can be a gateway to understanding the cooperative and competitive structures in educational games.
Standards, engagement, and Minecraft: Optimizing experiences in language teacher education
2019, Teaching and Teacher EducationCitation Excerpt :Task engagement can generally be defined as the level of involvement that learners have in a task (Egbert & Borysenko, 2018). Opportunities for teacher education students to understand, explore, and experience task engagement are central because research has linked engagement positively to task outcomes and learner achievement (see, for example, Christenson, Reschly, & Wylie, 2012; Peng, Song, Kim, & Day, 2016). Providing engaging opportunities is also one element of learning over which language teacher education students will have control in their future classrooms.
Investigating students' interaction patterns and dynamic learning sentiments in online discussions
2019, Computers and EducationCitation Excerpt :Concerning the different types of learning tasks, this study unraveled that group-oriented learning tasks could generate more diverse and in-depth interactions, such as “negotiation” → “test and modification” and “test and modification” → “agreement statement” (i4 → i5). This result is very similar to the findings of the earlier research such as Fairclough et al. (2005), Lu and Churchill (2014), and Peng et al. (2016). Nevertheless, more research on task-based interactions is needed to further explore how learning tasks affect interactions.
A scoping review of research on digital game-based language learning
2018, Computers and EducationDigital Game-Based Technology for English Language Learning in Preschools and Primary Schools: A Systematic Analysis
2024, IEEE Transactions on Learning TechnologiesInvestigating teachers’ participation patterns in online teacher professional development: what is the relationship between participation frequency and participation quality?
2023, Education and Information Technologies