Decision SupportA multi-stage financial hedging approach for the procurement of manufacturing materials
Highlights
► We develop a hedging strategy to deal with uncertain demand and price fluctuation. ► We use tradable commodities as the tool for hedging. ► The risk hedging model is based on discrete-time control theory. ► Futures positions are adjusted in response to price and demand movements. ► The approach outperforms hedging models without rebalancing of futures positions.
Section snippets
Introduction and review of relevant literature
Relatively stable commodity and raw materials prices are obviously preferred for production and business operations, but unfortunately, manufacturers are continuously forced to face highly volatile prices, especially in recent years. Such price volatility is in part due to variations in supply and demand, but excessive speculation, which has become a normal part of modern markets, has significantly increased price volatility and in turn the complexity of the procurement problem. According to
Formulation of the procurement risk mitigation problem
A multi-stage financial hedging strategy is proposed that performs a hedge against the uncertain procurement cost. The entire planning horizon is divided into several stages, depending on the frequency of rebalancing desired by the company management. The multi-stage financial hedging strategy consists of the initial futures position and the subsequent rebalancing and adjustment of the position. At the beginning of the planning horizon, the company will first take an initial position in the
Problem solution
The best solution for DSCM model will in fact be the optimal multi-stage financial hedging strategy. First, we analyse the model when L is the utility for a given :Since is a function of the hedging strategy, will also be a function of Y. If is the conditional expected value of L at stage t + 1, then the optimal hedging strategies after stage t are:The optimal, , is the one that maximise the value .
Numerical experiments
In this section, the proposed multi-stage hedging strategy is assessed by a comparative study and a sensitivity analysis. The study compares the proposed approach with other hedging strategies that do not perform any futures position rebalancing. The sensitivity analysis assesses the effects of changes in commodity price and/or procurement volume volatilities on the hedging strategy.
The comparison between the proposed multi-stage hedging strategy and a single hedging strategy can be easily done
Concluding remarks
A financial hedging approach was presented in this paper that mitigates the procurement risk arising from volatile commodity prices. To deal with uncertainties in procurement volume and price, a discrete-time stochastic control model was developed and tested, and an economic replenishment strategy was obtained for a multi-stage financial commodity futures hedging. Numerical results obtained from the Monte Carlo simulation showed that the multi-stage financial hedging strategy obtained from the
Acknowledgement
The authors are grateful to the support provided by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC No. 71071126).
References (26)
- et al.
A semiparametric estimation of the optimal hedge ratio
The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance
(2007) - et al.
A Markov regime switching approach for hedging energy commodities
Journal of Banking & Finance
(2008) - et al.
A review of methods supporting supplier selection
European Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management
(2001) - et al.
Fair transfer price and inventory holding policies in two-enterprise supply chains
European Journal of Operational Research
(2002) - et al.
Testing for constant hedge ratios in commodity markets: a multivariate GARCH approach
Journal of Empirical Finance
(2002) - et al.
Commodity derivatives valuation with autoregressive and moving average components in the price dynamics
Journal of Banking & Finance
(2010) Measures of risk
European Journal of Operational Research
(2005)- et al.
Objective comparisons of the optimal portfolios corresponding to different utility functions
European Journal of Operational Research
(2009) - et al.
Strategic transfer pricing
Management Science
(1998) Risk, return, and utility
Management Science
(1995)
The effects of financial risks on inventory policy
Management Science
Optimal control and hedging of operations in the presence of financial markets
Mathematics of Operations Research
Cited by (21)
Risk management through financial hedging in inventory systems with stochastic price processes
2024, International Journal of Production EconomicsBuy now and price later: Supply contracts with time-consistent mean–variance financial hedging
2018, European Journal of Operational ResearchCitation Excerpt :For studies involving financial hedging, commodity price risk mitigation using financial instrument has gained attention from the perspective of commodity buyers. See, e.g., Froot, Scharfstein, and Stein (1993), Gaur and Seshadri (2005), Neuberger (1999), Ni, Chu, & Yen, 2016, Ni, Chu, Wu, Sculli, and Shi (2012), Smith and Stulz (1985), and Kouvelis, Li, and Ding (2013). However, few researchers have considered the problem from the perspective of the other supply chain parties and/or the entire supply chain, with the possible exception of Caldentey and Haugh (2009) and Turcic, Kouvelis, and Bolandifar (2015).
Capacity decisions with debt financing: The effects of agency problem
2017, European Journal of Operational ResearchCitation Excerpt :Using a similar exponential utility, Ni, Chu, and Yen (2016) then revealed that there can be a weak separation between the operations decision and financial hedging strategy of a firm. Other related studies can be found in Chen, Sim, Simchi-Levi, and Sun (2007), Kouvelis et al. (2012), Ni, Chu, Wu, Sculli, and Shi (2012), Okyay, Karaesmen, and Özekici (2014), Sayin et al. (2014), Van Mieghem (2003), and Zhao and Huchzermeier (2015). The rationale for hedging in a risk-neutral setting has also begun to gain attention in the operations management literature.
On the risk-averse procurement strategy under unreliable supply
2015, Computers and Industrial EngineeringCitation Excerpt :With more information, buyers can forecast demand more precisely, and thus endure less demand risk. Moreover, Ni, Chu, Wu, Sculli, and Shi (2012) combined information updating with financial hedging to mitigate demand risk and price risk simultaneously. Other strategies include emergent purchase (Ma, Zhao, Xue, Cheng, & Yan, 2012; Sun, Liu, & Lan, 2010), dynamic pricing (Araman & Caldentey, 2009; Gong, Chao, & Zheng, 2014), etc.
High-dimensional stochastic control models for newsvendor problems and deep learning resolution
2024, Annals of Operations Research