Coupled hydrological–economic modelling for optimised irrigated cultivation in a semi-arid catchment of West Africa
Introduction
In the Volta Basin of West Africa, water availability is of great importance in supporting economic and social development. Population growth and increasing water demand in different sectors, in combination with high spatial and temporal variability of limited rainfall, underscore the need for sound interdisciplinary management of water distribution and allocation. The use of coupled hydrological–economic models permits integration of socio-economic behaviour and objectives into the physical water balance framework, and hence improves rational and sustainable water management. The coupled hydrological–economic model CMS-HYDROECON was developed by IMK-IFU and ZEF within the scope of the international project GLOWA-Volta (www.glowa-volta.de) to investigate regional interdependencies between economy and hydrology and to identify optimised irrigation strategies. It is applied within the Atankwidi catchment in the Guinea Sudan zone of West Africa, an important project research area, as a case study and prototype development, to be integrated within a prospective decision-support system for the planning, management and use of water resources in the Volta Basin. The scope of this study was to test the models' suitability and the operability of the model interface using fictitious scenarios involving variable levels of water availability. The coupled model system will provide policy simulation capacity in the Upper East Region where irrigation is expected to expand significantly (FAO, 2005a, FAO, 2005b, Van Edig et al., 2003). Policy-makers seek to know which development strategies are most cost-effective in a traditional sense (capital cost per ha of irrigation development), and which are most hydrologically efficient (yield per unit water). The well-situated Atankwidi catchment was chosen as an appropriate study area due to the availability of climatic, hydrologic and socio-economic data.
In the last decades, development and application of interdisciplinary coupled models has increased considerably, with several applications in water resources management. Against the background of limited water resources, growing populations, and projected increases in the demand for water in different sectors, problems of inter-sectoral water distribution and availability need to be solved (Young et al., 1994).
McKinney et al. (1999) evaluate a range of integrated hydrological–economic models, and subdivide them into holistic and compartment modelling approaches. While the holistic approach tightly combines both disciplines in a consistent model, the compartment modelling approach is based on a loose connection between the economic and the hydrological components (McKinney et al., 1999). Early compartment modelling approaches to integrating hydrology and socio-economic aspects are reported by Noel and Howitt (1982). To determine optimal spatial and temporal water allocation, a quadratic economic welfare function is incorporated in a multi-basin conjunctive use model modified and advanced by Lefkoff and Gorelick, 1990a, Lefkoff and Gorelick, 1990b. Economics of externalities in irrigated agriculture in the Colorado River basin were analysed by Lee and Howitt (1996) using a hydrology model and the Cobb–Douglas production function for regional production models. More recent studies developed combined models within the framework of decision-support systems for agro-economic and agro-ecological problems, for example Fohrer et al., 2001, Qiu and Prato, 2000, and Frede et al. (2002). Gillig et al. (2001) analysed different water use scenarios with respect to groundwater and surface water in Texas using a complex coupled hydrological–economic model for profit optimisation. Ecological and economic consequences of simulated flood scenarios were analysed by Duvail and Hamerlynck (2003). Quinn et al. (2004) coupled the hybrid hydrological model CALSIM II (“California Water Resource Simulation Model”) with the non-linear economic model APSIDE (“Agricultural Production Salinity Irrigation Drainage Economics Model”) for an integrated water management in the San Joaquin Basin (California, USA). An integrated hydrological–economic model was developed by Lanini et al. (2004) for the Hérault Basin (France). Bhuiyan (2005) coupled the hydrological model SWAT (“Soil and Water Assessment Tool”) with the linear economic model MIDAS (“Model of Dryland Agricultural System”) for the investigation of different land use scenarios and the development of optimal cultivation strategies in arid areas. Letcher et al. (2007) provide a generalised conceptual framework for representing the interactions of the stream system with water allocation, agricultural production and other water use decisions in integrated water allocation models.
As an early example of holistic model integration, the “Colorado River Network Model” (CRM) was developed to investigate hydrological consequences of droughts and different political water management strategies for the Colorado River (USA). The holistic model was studied by Harding et al. (1995) and upgraded by Booker and Young (1994) and Booker (1995). For water management in California, Howitt et al. (1999) developed the economic optimisation model CALVIN (“California Value Integration Model”). Jenkins et al. (2004) summarise the results of the long-term study of optimal water allocation in California. Optimal reservoir management and irrigation strategies for profit optimisation in Karnataka (India) were analysed with an integrated agro-economic-hydrological model by Vedula and Kumar (1996), which was improved by Mujumdar and Ramesh (1997). A GIS-based model for the investigation of regional water allocation strategies in the Aral Sea basin was developed by McKinney and Cai (1996). The optimisation model consists of a network flow hydrologic model containing source (inflow) and demand nodes, and representing important hydraulic (e.g., dams) and economic components; and optimizes water allocation while preserving mass balance. An advanced version was used by Rosegrant et al. (2000) in the Maipo Basin (Chile) to evaluate crop choice and irrigation technology options. To analyse alternative water management and policy strategies, the model approach was also used on the Mekong Basin in China (Ringler, 2001) and in the Dong-Nai Basin in Vietnam (Ringler and Nguyen, 2004). Cai et al., 2001, Cai et al., 2002, Cai et al., 2003 reapplied the advanced version of the agro-economic-hydrological model to the Aral Sea basin, focusing on the effects of salinization. Cai (2008) stresses the difficulties involved in large-scale holistic modelling for integrated river basin management. An alternative configuration is the spatial-dynamic model of structural change in agriculture developed by Balmann, 1995, Balmann, 1997, advanced and refined by Berger (2001) which utilizes a multi-agent/cellular automata approach by using heterogeneous farm-household models. Communication of the hydrological component with the agent-based economic component occurs via a raster-based GIS. The model was applied in Chile and selected regions of Baden-Wuerttemberg, Germany. Krol and Bronstert (2007) analyse climate change impacts on water resources in semi-arid Northeast Brazil by an integrated model that dynamically describes the relationships between climate forcing, water availability, agriculture and selected societal processes. Van Delden et al. (2007) present a Policy Support System (PSS) that incorporates socio-economic and physical processes in a strongly coupled manner and allows policy making in the fields of water management and sustainable farming.
In contrast to the holistic coupling approaches (above) based on comparatively simple conceptual hydrological models, this study utilizes a complex, physically based distributed hydrological model. The modelling approach corresponds with compartment modelling and facilitates continuous improvement of the model components. The study emphasizes the sustainable use of water resources and the preservation of a stable regional water balance. Results of the interdisciplinary hydrological–economic modelling approach will be presented for two fictitious scenarios in the Atankwidi catchment of West Africa.
Section snippets
The Atankwidi catchment (Volta Basin, West Africa)
Particularly in savannah areas like West Africa with high spatial and temporal variability of rainfall and high evapotranspiration rates, overexploitation of water resources can seriously compromise efforts to achieve sustainable regional development. Population growth in the Volta Basin has induced increasing demands for freshwater for human consumption, industrial and agricultural production and the generation of hydropower. With few other natural resources available, rain-fed and irrigated
Hydrological modelling using WaSiM
For hydrological simulation of the Atankwidi catchment, the Water balance Simulation Model WaSiM (Schulla and Jasper, 2001) was used. It is a deterministic, fully distributed modular model for the simulation of the hydrologically relevant parts of the water balance, and uses physically based algorithms for most hydrological processes. Fluxes in the unsaturated zone are calculated on the basis of the Richards equation (Richards, 1931). Potential evapotranspiration is calculated according to
Case study scenarios
Two different scenarios were defined to investigate the operability and capability of the coupled model system and to demonstrate the interactions between hydrology and agricultural economy in a savannah catchment. Both scenarios address common problems in sustainable water resources management, namely, the provision of irrigation water under two “redline” constraints: (1) keeping a minimum reservoir filling, and (2) keeping a minimum reservoir outflow. The values of the scenario-dependent
Summary and conclusions
In the present study, a coupled hydrological–economic modelling was performed. The developed coupled model system CMS-HYDROECON has been designed as a decision-support tool for reservoir management and irrigated agriculture in the Volta Basin. It is based on a communication interface between the hydrological model WaSiM and the non-linear economic optimisation model GAMS-ECIM. The interdisciplinary model coupling was aimed at identifying optimised cultivation strategies for the Atankwidi
Acknowledgements
This work was funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) within the framework of the GLOWA-Volta project (http://www.glowa-volta.de). The financial support is gratefully acknowledged.
References (55)
Agent-based spatial models applied to agriculture: a simulation tool for technology diffusion, resource use changes and policy analysis
Agricultural Economics
(2001)- et al.
Modeling intrastate and interstate markets for Colorado River water resources
Journal of Environmental Economics and Management
(1994) Implementation of holistic water resources-economic optimization models for river basin management – reflective experiences
Environmental Modelling and Software
(2008)- et al.
Regional integrated modeling of climate change impacts on natural resources and resource usage in semi-arid Notheast Brazil
Environmental Modelling and Software
(2007) - et al.
Socio-hydrosystem modelling for integrated water-resources management – the Hérault catchment case study, southern France
Environmental Modelling & Software
(2004) - et al.
Integrated assessment modelling for water resource allocation and management: a generalised conceptual framework
Environmental Modelling and Software
(2007) - et al.
Model integration for assessing future hydroclimate impacts on water resources, agricultural production and environmental quality in the San Joaquin Basin, California
Environmental Modelling & Software
(2004) - et al.
Integration of multi-scale dynamic spatial models of socio-economic and physical processes for river basin management
Environmental Software and Modelling
(2007) Pfadabhängigkeiten in Agrarstrukturentwicklungen –Begriff
(1995)Farm-based modelling of regional structural change: a cellular automata approach
European Review of Agricultural Economics
(1997)
Hydrologic and economic impacts of drought under alternative policy responses
Water Resources Bulletin
GAMS. A User's Guide
A framework for sustainability analysis in water resources management and application to the Syr Darya Basin
Water Resources Research
Integrated hydrologic–agronomic–economic model for river basin management
Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Sustainability Analysis for Irrigation Water Management: Concepts, Methodology and Application in the Aral Sea Region
Mitigation of negative ecological and socio-economic impacts of the Diama dam on the Senegal River Delta wetland (Mauritania), using a model based decision support system
Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
Yield Response to Water
Crop Evapotranspiration – Guidelines for Computing Crop Water Requirements
Burkina Faso. Aquastat Information System on Water and Agriculture
Ghana. Aquastat Information System on Water and Agriculture
Applying the SWAT model as a decision support tool for land use concepts in peripheral regions in Germany
Interdisciplinary modeling and the significance of soil functions
Journal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science
An economic, hydrologic, and environmental assessment of water management alternative plans for the South Central Texas Region
Journal of Agricultural & Applied Economics
Poverty Trends in Ghana in the 1990s (Ghana Statistical Service)
Impacts of a severe sustained drought on Colorado River water resources
Water Resources Bulletin
Cited by (41)
Exploring strategies to control the cost of food security: Evidence from Bangladesh
2022, Agricultural SystemsAgricultural water optimization coupling with a distributed ecohydrological model in a mountain-plain basin
2020, Journal of HydrologyCitation Excerpt :Optimization models are essential tools of agricultural water optimization. These models are generally based on traditional programming method, such as linear programming (LP), nonlinear programming and fractional programming (Ahrends et al., 2008; Garcia-Vila and Fereres, 2012; Garg and Dadhich, 2014; Jiang et al., 2016; Zhao et al., 2017; Sadeghi et al., 2020); uncertain programming method, such as stochastic optimization, robust programming, fractile optimization, fuzzy programming, interval programming and chance-constrained programming (Wang and Huang, 2015; Yang et al., 2015; Zeng et al., 2017; Dai et al., 2018; Dong et al., 2018; Tan and Zhang, 2018; Li et al., 2019a, 2019b); heuristic optimization algorithm, such as genetic algorithm (GA) and ant colony optimization (Cai et al., 2002; Alvarez et al., 2004; Nguyen et al., 2017; Wen et al., 2017; Li et al., 2020b); and other optimization methods, such as particle swarm optimization, game model and pattern search algorithm (Su et al., 2014; Fu et al., 2019; Linker, 2020). A few scholars have carried out agricultural water resources optimization at the basin scale with the optimization models mentioned above.
Evaluating the coordinated development of social economy, water, and ecology in a heavily disturbed basin based on the distributed hydrology model and the harmony theory
2019, Journal of HydrologyCitation Excerpt :Currently, distributed hydrological models that consider the interaction mechanism of the social economy, water, and ecology have attracted attention with the increasing complexity of the human-water relationship (Liu et al., 2014; Sivapalan, 2015; He et al., 2018). For example, Rosegrant et al. (2000) introduced an integrated economic-hydrologic modeling framework that accounted for the interactions among water allocation, farmer input choice, agricultural productivity, nonagricultural water demand, and resource degradation; Cai et al. (2003) developed a new, integrated hydrologic-agronomic-economic model; Ahrends et al. (2008) developed a coupled model system that included a distributed hydrological model and an economic optimization model. Due to a lack of in-depth research on the interaction mechanisms between natural and social water cycle factors and their interaction with river water quantity, quality, and ecological indicators, few distributed models have been built that consider the complex interactions of the social economy, water, and ecology factors as a whole.
Integrated modelling of the impacts of hydropower projects on the water-food-energy nexus in a transboundary Himalayan river basin
2019, Applied EnergyCitation Excerpt :The coupling of independently developed hydrological and economic models allows for the inclusion of more relevant details in both realms [36]. Examples of modular models include different hydrological simulation models coupled with economic models such as REALM [42] or MIKE Basin-based economic optimization models [43], WaSIM coupled with a non-linear economic model [30], SWAT coupled with a linear economic model [44], and WEAP coupled economic optimization model [32]. The modular models can be soft coupled where component models run independently and results are fed into the optimization model or hard coupled where models run interdependently with feedback loops with an interface [30].
Modeling social–economic water cycling and the water–land nexus: A framework and an application
2018, Ecological ModellingDevelopment of an integrated hydrological-irrigation optimization modeling system for a typical rice irrigation scheme in Central Vietnam
2018, Agricultural Water ManagementCitation Excerpt :In total, 12 blocks are modelled to account for 144 ha of SA paddy rice. A vast number of integrated hydrological and agro-economic models have been developed for different spatial scales (e.g. Rosegrant et al., 2000; Cai et al., 2003; Ahrends et al., 2008; Al-Juaidi et al., 2014). The modelling system of this study consists of the hydrological model WaSiM and an irrigation optimization model, which allows to simulate the connections between the hydrologic and irrigation components of the case-study irrigation scheme.