Online service quality and perceived value in mobile government success: An empirical study of mobile police in China
Introduction
The measurement of information system (IS) success has garnered significant attention from researchers and practitioners for many years (Rana, Dwivedi, & Williams, 2013; Iannacci & Cornford, 2018; Rana, Dwivedi, & Williams, 2013; Sabherwal, Jeyaraj, & Chowa, 2006). While some authors have focused on how to form an IS success model for measuring general IS (DeLone & McLean, 1992, 2003; Seddon, 1997; Petter, DeLone, & McLean, 2008). Others have focused on how the updated IS success models are used in specific areas, such as e-commerce success (Delone & Mclean, 2004; Wang, 2008), m-commerce success (Zhou, 2013), and e-government success (Scott, DeLone, & Golden, 2016; Teo, Srivastava, & Jiang, 2009). Although various aspects related to quality have been examined in the m-government context (see review in Appendix A), this has not been done using the updated IS success model. Consequently, our study adapts the updated IS success model to the m-government context, which need not necessarily be the same as the e-commerce and e-government contexts.
Governments around the world are actively promoting m-government. M-government can be defined as the strategy utilized by a government to provide information and services to stakeholders (e.g. employees, citizens, businesses, and other organizations) via mobile technology and devices without restrictions of time and place (Ishmatova & Obi, 2009). Due to the mobility, identification and personalization advantages offered by m-government, users can overcome time and space limitations. First, it is convenient for citizens to access information from m-government services 24/7 in a timely manner. Moreover, m-government can provide users with personalized services, facilitate user participation, and enhance the interaction between the government and citizens (Trimi & Sheng, 2008). Despite this, however, the effects of m-government use have mostly fallen short of their potential in a similar way to e-government (Vincent & Harris, 2008). This problem is even more pronounced in the context of developing countries, with only about 15 % of e-government initiatives successfully achieving their key goals without any major adverse consequences (Teo et al., 2009). Therefore, measuring the effectiveness of m-government is a significant challenge for government departments.
As mentioned above, although DeLone and McLean’s (2003) updated IS success model is most commonly used to measure the success of a variety of Internet-based systems, such as e-commerce, m-commerce, and e-government, there is no empirical research measuring m-government success based on this updated model. Given that DeLone and McLean’s model (2003) is recognized as a basic framework for measuring IS success (Scott et al., 2016), and that we are examining the role of online and offline service quality in our research model, we here use the DeLone and McLean updated model (2003) rather than the DeLone and McLean model (1992). Measuring the success of an m-government system is of great significance in theory and practice. In theory, m-government is different from m/e-commerce because m-government frequently encompasses social goals (e.g., enhancing social justice, advancing public value, and promoting the sustainable development of society) (Grimsley & Meehan, 2007); moreover, it can also provide personalized and localization-based services (Wang, 2014), which may change the relevant variables (e.g., service quality related to the mobile context) and the relationships between them in the updated IS success model.
Increasingly, governments are providing public services to citizens through online and offline (O&O) channels. Correspondingly, it is important to consider both offline service quality (e.g., Lee, Kim, & Ahn, 2011) and online service quality (Rana, Dwivedi, Williams, & Weerakkody, 2016; Shareef, Archer, & Dwivedi, 2015). Only minimal research has paid attention to the role of offline service quality in citizens’ use of online public services; moreover, the emergence of O&O-based public services has also brought challenges to the updated IS success model, as the construct of service quality in the updated IS success model is a single-dimensional variable. Last but not least, the construct of ‘net benefits’ is too general and needs to be defined in terms of a specific context (Scott et al., 2016). For example, continuance intention is often used to measure IS success in the extant research (e.g., Teo et al., 2009). Although both government IS and business IS have similar goals as regards creating value for customers/citizens, there are some differences in their application goals. The former mainly focuses on the public interest (e.g., social equity, social sustainable development), while the latter focuses mainly on profit and improving output efficiency (e.g., cost reduction, market share) (Grimsley & Meehan, 2007; Perry & Rainey, 1988; Scott et al., 2016). Given that government IS and business IS encompass different strategic goals, we also need to conduct more research into whether other variables (such as the value of perceived public services) can be used as dependent variables when measuring the success of government IS. It is therefore necessary to extend and validate the updated IS success model to encompass the m-government context. In practice, government agencies around the world have embraced the digital revolution and increased investment in m-government. By evaluating m-government success, the key factors associated with usage can be identified, which will help the government to improve both the system design and the efficiency of service delivery. Hence, it is necessary to assess m-government success and extend IS success research into m-government so that we can improve m-government practices for government agencies.
The purpose of this study is to develop a contextual model based on the updated DeLone and McLean model (DeLone & McLean, 2003) in order to measure m-government success. In doing so, we make three key contributions to our understanding of the updated IS success model in the m-government context. First, although assessing m-government success is a significant challenge faced by the public sector, there has been no empirical research on m-government success to date. We accordingly offer a framework that extends IS success studies into the m-government context and test this framework using survey data. Second, although the government is increasingly inclined to provide public services to citizens through O&O channels, it is not clear how O&O service quality affects IS success. Thus, we refine the connotation of service quality from the perspective of service channels – namely, online service quality (ONQ), and offline service quality (OFQ) – and explore their effects on m-government success. Note that OFQ is used to moderate the relationship between ONQ and citizen satisfaction, thereby facilitating an understanding of why the offline service experience in O&O services is increasingly valued by service providers (Leung, Wu, Ip, & Ho, 2019). Finally, although existing research has identified the difference between a business IS (e.g., e-commerce) and a government IS (e.g., e-government), this differentiation is less important when using net benefits to measure their success. We provide new insights by using perceived value to measure net benefits in order to reflect the balance of costs and benefits in the mobile technology environment. Furthermore, perceived value (similar to public value) is measured from the public sector perspective.
The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. First, we review extant research on m-government, IS success, service quality, and perceived value, and outline our research model and hypotheses. Second, we describe our method and report our empirical results. Finally, we discuss the implications of our results and conclude the paper.
Section snippets
Theory development
In this section, we provide an overview of the literature on m-government, the IS success model, service quality, and perceived value. Subsequently, we develop the research model and outline the hypotheses.
Measures
To ensure content validity, the items used to measure all variables in our model (such as information quality, system quality, online service quality, offline service quality, citizen satisfaction, and perceived value) were adapted from validated instruments in extant literature, although they were reworded to fit our context (see Appendix B). Information quality and system quality were measured using the instrument suggested by Teo et al. (2009). According to the measurement of service quality
Results
Similar to some extant studies (e.g., Teo et al., 2009; Tan et al., 2013), partial least squares (PLS) was used to test our model. This method employs a component-based approach with fewer restrictions on sample size and residual distributions, and has thus been recognized as an effective method for measuring construct reliability and validity (Chin, Marcolin, & Newsted, 2003). Using the Smart-PLS 2.0, we first evaluated the measurement model to assess reliability and validity, then tested the
Discussion
Grounded in DeLone and McLean’s (2003) updated IS success model, we constructed an m-government success model and examined the relationship between constructs related to quality, citizen satisfaction, and perceived value. The results indicated that our research model were suitable measures of m-government system success. Consistent with prior IS success model research (Floropoulos et al., 2010; Wang & Liao, 2008; Wang, 2008), both information quality and online service quality were found to be
Conclusion
When attempting to implement m-government systems, the public sector faces the challenge of measuring IS success. Accordingly, to address this concern, we develop an m-government success model based on DeLone and McLean’s (2003) updated IS success model. Compared with this updated model, which considers service quality as a single-dimensional variable, we subdivide service quality into online service quality and offline service quality and use the latter as a moderator. Moreover, considering
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgments
This work was partly supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) under Grant [NSFC-71403080] and Department of Science & Technology of Henan Province under Grant [172400410135 and 182400410140].
References (103)
- et al.
Exploring mobile government from the service quality perspective
Journal of Enterprise Information Management
(2017) - et al.
Information on the move: The use of mobile information systems by UK police forces
Information Research
(2008) - et al.
Social acceptance of location-based mobile government services for emergency management
Telematics and Informatics
(2014) - et al.
Examining Jordanian citizens’ intention to adopt electronic government
Electronic Government an International Journal
(2013) - et al.
Citizen’s adoption of an e-government system: Validating the extended theory of reasoned action (TRA)
International Journal of Electronic Government Research
(2020) - et al.
The moderator–mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
(1986) - et al.
Using ICTs to create a culture of transparency: E-government and social media as openness and anti-corruption tools for societies
Government Information Quarterly
(2010) Back-translation for cross-culture research
Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology
(1970)- et al.
The effects of differences between e-commerce and m-commerce on the consumers’ usage transfer from online to mobile channel
International Journal of Mobile Communications
(2015) - et al.
Modeling citizen satisfaction with mandatory adoption of an e-government technology
Journal of the Association for Information Systems
(2010)
Examining the success factors for mobile work in healthcare: A deductive study
Decision Support Systems
How to satisfy citizens? Using mobile government to reengineer fair government processes
Decision Support Systems
A mixed method investigation of sharing economy driven car-hailing services: Online and offline perspectives
International Journal of Information Management
A partial least squares latent variable modeling approach for measuring interaction effects: Results from a Monte Carlo simulation study and an electronic-mail emotion/adoption study
Information Systems Research
How we should measure “change”
Psychological Bulletin
Measuring e-commerce success: Applying the DeLone & McLean information systems success model
International Journal of Electronic Commerce
Information systems success: The quest for the dependent variable
Information Systems Research
The DeLone and McLean model of information systems success: A tenyear update
Journal of Management Information Systems
Explaining and predicting mobile government microblogging services participation behaviors: A SEM-Neural network method
IEEE Access
A generalised adoption model for services: A cross-country comparison of mobile health (m-health)
Government Information Quarterly
E-government to m-government: A study in a developing economy
International Journal of Mobile Communications
E-government in digital era: Concept, practice, and development
International Journal of the Computer, the Internet and Management
Mobile police service in mobile government
Measuring the success of the Greek taxation information system
International Journal of Information Management
Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error
Journal of Marketing Research
Integration of online and offline channels in retail: The impact of sharing reliable inventory availability information
Management Science
Internet retailing: Enablers, limiters and market consequences
Journal of Business Research
e-Government information systems: Evaluation-led design for public value and client trust
European Journal of Information Systems
Understanding consumer online grocery behavior: Results from a Swedish study
Journal of Euromarketing
Modern factor analysis
Security strategy for mobile police information system using SMS
Wireless Personal Communications
Privatization and its reverse: Explaining the dynamics of the government contracting process
Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory
Antecedents and consequences of customer satisfaction: Do they differ across online and offline purchases?
Journal of Retailing
User acceptance of mobile e-government services: An empirical study
Government Information Quarterly
Unravelling causal and temporal influences underpinning monitoring systems success: A typological approach
Information Systems Journal
M-government services: User needs and value
The Journal of E-Government Policy and Regulation
Trustworthiness of digital government services: Deriving a comprehensive theory through interpretive structural modelling
Public Management Review
Exploring perceived risk, perceived trust, perceived quality and the innovative characteristics in the adoption of smart government services in Jordan
International Journal of Mobile Communications
E-shopping in a multiple channel environment
The Journal of Consumer Marketing
Research note—Two competing perspectives on automatic use: A theoretical and empirical comparison
Information Systems Research
Value-based adoption of mobile internet: An empirical investigation
Decision Support Systems
The willingness of e-Government service adoption by business users: The role of offline service quality and trust in technology
Government Information Quarterly
Enhancing online-to-offline specific customer loyalty in beauty industry
Enterprise Information Systems
Effects of perceived online–offline integration and internet censorship on mobile government microblogging service continuance: A gratification perspective
Government Information Quarterly
The impact of mobile technology on a UK police force and their knowledge sharing
Journal of Information & Knowledge Management
Empirical evaluation of a technology acceptance model for mobile policing
Police Practice and Research
Assessing leading institutions, faculty, and articles in premier information systems research journals
Communications of the Association for Information Systems (CAIS)
Exogenous and endogenous antecedents of online shopping in a multichannel environment: Evidence from a catalog retailer in the German-speaking world
Journal of Electronic Commerce in Organizations (JECO)
Evaluating quality of conceptual modelling scripts based on user perceptions
Data & Knowledge Engineering
SALT: A semantic adaptive framework for monitoring citizen satisfaction from e-government services
Expert Systems with Applications
Cited by (89)
Determining influence of service quality on user identification, belongingness, and satisfaction on mobile social media: Insight from emotional attachment perspective
2024, Journal of Retailing and Consumer ServicesThe linkage between quality of information systems and the impact of trust-based privacy on behavioral outcomes in unmanned convenience store: Moderating effect of gender and experience
2023, Technological Forecasting and Social Change