Abstract
Dominance hierarchies are ubiquitous in the societies of human and non-human animals. Evidence from comparative, developmental, and cognitive psychological investigations is presented that show how social dominance hierarchies shaped the evolution of the human mind, and hence, human social institutions. It is argued that the pressures that arise from living in hierarchical social groups laid a foundation of fundamental concepts and cognitive strategies that are crucial to surviving in social dominance hierarchies. These include recognizing and reasoning transitively about dominance relations, fast-track learning of social norms (permissions, prohibitions, and obligations), detecting violations of social norms (cheating), monitoring reciprocal obligations, and reading the intentions of others.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Altmann, J., S. C. Alberts, S. A. Haines, J. Dubach, P. Muruth, T. Coote, E. Geffen, D. J. Cheesman, R. A. Mututua, S.N. Saiyalel, R. K. Wayne, R. C. Lacy, and M. W. Bruford: 1996, 'Behavior Predicts Genetic Structure in a Wild Primate Group', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 93, 5795–801.
Anew, A.: 1996, 'Innateness and Canalization', Philosophy of Science 63, S19–S27.
Aruguete, M.: 1994, 'Cognition, Tradition, and the Explanation of Social Behavior in Non-Human Primates', [Review of Social Processes and Mental Abilities in Non-Human Primates]. American Journal of Primatology 33, 71–4.
Axelrod, R., and W. D. Hamilton: 1981, 'The Evolution of Cooperation', Science 211, 1390–6.
Bartsch, K. and H. M. Wellman: 1989, 'Young Children's Attribution of Action to Beliefs and Desires', Child Development 60, 946–64.
Bentham, J.: 1789, The Principles of Morals and Legislation, Prometheus Books, Buffalo, N.Y.
Bertram, B. C. R.: 1976, 'Kin Selection in Lions and Evolution', in P. P. G. Bateson and R. A. Hinde (eds), Growing Points in Ethology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 281–302.
Boehm, C.: 1992, 'Segmentary “Warfare” and theManagement of Conflict: Comparison of East African Chimpanzees and Patrilineal-Patrilocal Humans', in A. Harcourt and F. B. M. de Waal (eds), Coalitions and Alliances in Humans and Other Animals, pp. 137–75, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Boesch, C.: 1991, 'Teaching in Wild Chimpanzees', Animal Behavior 41, 530–2.
Bygott, J. D., B. C. R. Bertram, and J. P. Hanby: 1979, 'Male Lions in Large Coalitions Gain Reproductive Advantage', Nature 282, 839–41.
Byrne, R.: 1995, The Thinking Ape: Evolutionary Origins Of Intelligence, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Bussey, K.: 1992, 'Children's Lying and Truthfulness: Implications for Children's Testimony', in S. J. Ceci, M. De Simone Leichtman, and M. Putnick (eds), Cognitive and Social Factors in Early Deception, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp. 89–110.
Caro, T. M. and M. D. Hauser: 1992, 'Is There Teaching in Non-Human Animals?', Quarterly Review of Biology 67, 151–74.
Chapais, B.: 1988, 'Rank Maintenance in Female Japanese Macaques: Experimental Evidence For Social Dependency', iBehavior 104, 41–59.
Chapais, B.: 1992, 'Role of Alliances in the Social Inheritance of Rank Among Female Primates', in A. Harcourt and F. B. M De Waal (eds), Cooperation in Contests in Animals and Humans, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 29–60.
Cheney, D. L.: 1983, 'Extra-Familial Alliances Among Vervet Monkeys', in R. A. Hinde (ed.), Primate Social Relationships, Blackwell, Oxford.
Cheney, D. L. and R. M. Seyfarth: 1990, How Monkeys See the World, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Cheng, P. W. and K. J. Holyoak: 1985, 'Pragmatic Reasoning Schemas', Cognitive Psychology 17, 391–416.
Cheng, P. W. and K. J. Holyoak: 1989, 'On the Natural Selection of Reasoning Theories', Cognition 33, 285–313.
Clutton-Brock, T. H.: 1988, 'Reproductive Success', in T. H. Clutton-Brock (ed.), Reproductive Success, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Clutton-Brock, T. H. and P. H. Harvey: 1976, 'Evolutionary Rules and Primate Societies', in P. P. G. Bateson and R. A. Hinde (eds), Growing Points in Ethology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 195–238.
Cosmides, L.: 1989, 'The Logic of Social Exchange: Has Natural Selection Shaped How Humans Reason? Studies With the Wason Selection Task', Cognition 31, 187–276.
Cosmides, L. and J. Tooby: 1992, 'Cognitive Adaptations for Social Exchange', in J. Barkow, L. Cosmides and J. Tooby (eds), The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture, Oxford University Press, New York.
Cosmides, L. and J. Tooby: 1994, 'Origins of Domain Specificity: The Evolution of Functional Organization', in L. A. Hirshfeld and S. Gelman (eds), Mapping the Mind: Domain Specificity in Cognition and Culture, pp. 85–116, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Cummins, D. D.: 1996(a), 'Evidence of Deontic Reasoning in 3-and 4-Year-olds', Memory and Cognition 24, 823–9.
Cummins, D. D.: 1996(b), 'Evidence for the Innateness of Deontic Reasoning', Mind and Language 11, 160–90.
Cummins, D. D.: 1996(c), 'Dominance Hierarchies and the Evolution of Human Reasoning', Minds and Machines 6, 463–80.
Cummins, D. D.: 1997, 'Rationality: Biological, Psychology, and Normative Theories', Cahiers de Psychologie Cognitive (Current Psychology of Cognition 16, 78–86.
Cummins, D. D.: 1998(a), 'Social Norms and Other Minds: The Evolutionary Roots of Higher Cognition', in D. D. Cummins and C. A. Allen (eds), The Evolution of Mind, Oxford University Press, New York, pp. 30–50.
Cummins, D. D.: 1998(b), 'Can Humans Form Hierarchically Embedded Mental Representations?' Commentary on R. W. Byrne and A. E. Russon 'Learning By Imitation: A Hierarchical Approach', Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21, 687–8.
Cummins, D. D.: 1999, 'Cheater Detection is Modified by Social Rank', Evolution and Human Behavior 20, 229–48.
Cummins, D. D.: in press, 'Adaptive Cognitive Mechanisms: Reasoning about Social Norms and Other Minds', in R. Elio (ed.), Commonsense, Reasoning, and Rationality: Vancouver Studies in Cognitive Science, Vol. 11, Oxford University Press, Oxford
Cummins, D. D. and R. C. Cummins: in press, 'Biological Preparedness and Evolutionary Explanation', Cognition.
Datta, S. B.: 1983(a), 'Relative Power and the Acquisition of Rank', in R. A. Hinde (ed.), Primate Social Relationships, Blackwell, Oxford
Datta, S. B.: 1983(b), 'Relative Power and the Maintenance of Rank', in R. A. Hinde (ed.), Primate Social Relationships, Blackwell, Oxford.
Dewsbury, D. A.: 1982, 'Dominance Rank, Copulatory Behavior and Differential Reproduction', Quarterly Review of Biology 57, 135–59.
Duhem, P.: 1954, The Aim and Structure of Physical Theory, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ (Original work published in 1914.)
Earman, J.: 1992, Bayes or Bust?, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Ellis, L.: 1995, 'Dominance and Reproductive Success Among Nonhuman Animals: A Cross-Species Comparison', Ethology and Sociobiology 16, 257–333.
Fedigan, L.: 1983, 'Dominance and Reproductive Success in Primates', Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 26, 91–129.
Flavell, J. H., E. R. Flavell, G. L. Green, and L. J. Moses: 1990, 'Young Children”s Understanding of Fact Beliefs Versus Value Beliefs', Child Development 61, 915–28.
Frankel, D. G. and T. Arbel: 1980, 'Group Formation by Two-Year-Olds', International Journal of Behavioral Development 3, 287–98.
Frankena, W. K.: 1963, Ethics, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
Gagneux, P., D. S. Woodruff, and C. Boesch: 1997, 'Furtive Mating in Female Chimpanzees', Nature 387, 358–69.
Goodall, J.: 1986, The Chimpanzees of Gombe, Belknap Press, Cambridge.
Gopnik, A.: 1993, 'How We Know Our Minds: The Illusion of First-Person Knowledge of Intentionality', Behavioral and Brain Sciences 16, 1–15.
Griggs, R. A. and J. R. Cox: 1982, 'The Elusive Thematic Materials Effect in Wason's Selection Task', British Journal of Psychology 73, 407–20.
Hall, K. R. L.: 1964, 'Aggression in Monkey and Ape Societies', in J. Carthy and F. Ebling (eds), The Natural History of Aggression, Academic Press, London, pp. 51–64.
Harcourt, A. H.: 1988, 'Alliances in Contests and Social Intelligence', in R. W. Byrne and A. Whiten (eds), Machiavellian Intelligence, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 131–52.
Harcourt, A. H. and K. J. Stewart: 1987, 'The Influence of Help in Contests on Dominance Rank in Primates: Hints From Gorillas', Animal Behaviour 35, 182–90.
Harcourt, A. H. and F. B. M. de Waal (eds), 1992, Coalitions and Alliances in Humans and Other Animals, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Harkness, S., C. Pope Edwards, and C. M. Super: 1981, 'Social Roles and Moral Reasoning: A Case Study in a Rural African Community', Developmental Psychology 17, 595–603.
Harris, P. L.. and M. Nuñez: 1996, 'Understanding of Permission Rules by Preschool Children', Child Development 67, 1572–91.
Haugaard, J. and N. D. Reppucci: 1992, 'Children and the Truth', in S. J. Ceci, M. De Simone Leichtman and M. Putnick (eds), Cognitive and Social Factors in Early Deception, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp. 29–46.
Hausfater, G.: 1975, 'Dominance and Reproduction in Baboons (Papio Cynocephalus): A Quantitative Analysis', Contributions in Primatology 7, 1–150.
Haviland, J. M. and M. Lelivica: 1987, 'The Induced Affect Response: 10 Week Old Infants' Responses to Three Emotional Expressions', Developmental Psychology 23, 97–104.
Hilpinen, R.: 1971, Deontic Logic: Introductory and Systematic Readings, Reidel/Kluwer, Boston.
Hilpinen, R.: 1981, New Studies in Deontic Logic, Reidel/Kluwer, Boston.
Hokanson, J. E.: 1961, 'The Effect of Frustration and Anxiety on Overt Aggression', Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 62, 346–51.
Hokanson, J. E. and S. Shetler: 1961, 'The Effect of Overt Aggression on Physiological Arousal', Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 63, 446–8.
Hold-Cavell, B. C. and D. Borsutzky: 1986, 'Longitudinal Study of a Group of Preschool Children', Ethology and Sociobiology 7, 39–56.
Hollos, M., P. E. Leis and E. Turiel: 1986, 'Social Reasoning in Ijo Children and Adolescents in Nigerian Communities', Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 17, 352–74.
Holyoak, K. J. and P. W. Cheng: 1995, 'Pragmatic Reasoning with a Point of View', 1, 289–313.
Horwich, P.: 1982, Probability and Evidence, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Jenkins, J. and J. W. Astington: 1996, 'Cognitive Factors and Family Structure Associated with Theory of Mind Development in Young Children', Developmental Psychology 32, 70–8.
Johnson-Laird, P. N., P. Legrenzi and M. S. Legrenzi: 1972, 'Reasoning and a Sense of Reality', British Journal of Psychology 63, 395–400.
Keating, C. F. and K. R. Heltman: 1994, 'Dominance and Deception in Children and Adults: Are Leaders the Best Misleaders?', Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 54, 312–21.
Kosslyn, S. M. and O. Koenig: 1995, Wet Mind: The New Cognitive Neuroscience, Free Press, New York.
Krebs, J. R. and R. Dawkins: 1984, 'Animal Signals: Mind-Reading and Manipulation', in J. R. Krebs and N. B. Davies (eds), Behavioral Ecology: An Evolutionary Approach, 2nd ed., Blackwell, Oxford, pp. 380–402.
La Freniere, P. and W. R. Charlesworth: 1983, 'Dominance, Attention, and Affiliation in a Preschool Group: A Nine-Month Longitudinal Study', Ethology and Sociobiology 4, 55–67.
Lakatos, I.: 1970, 'Falsification and the Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes', in I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave (eds), Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 91–196.
Leslie, A. M.: 1994, 'ToMM, ToBY, and Agency: Core Architecture and Domain Specificity', in L. A. Hirshfeld and S. A. Gelman (eds), Mapping the Mind: Domain Specificity in Cognition and Culture, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 119–48.
Lewis, C., N. Freeman, C. Kyriakidou, K. Maridaki-Kassotaki and D. Berridge: 1996, 'Social Influences on False Belief Access: Specific Contagion or General Apprenticeship?', Child Development 67, 2930–47.
Manktelow, K. I. and D. E. Over: 1991, 'Social Roles and Utilities in Reasoning With Deontic Conditionals', Cognition 39, 85–105.
Manktelow, K. I., and D. E. Over: 1995, 'Deontic Reasoning', in S. E. Newstead and J. St. B. Evans (eds), Perspectives On Thinking and Reasoning, Erlbaum, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
McCann, T. S.: 1981, 'Aggression and Sexual Activity of Male Southern Elephant Seals (Mirounga Leonina)', Journal of Zoology 195, 295–310.
McGuffin, P. and J. Scourfield: 1997, 'A Father's Imprint on His Daughter's Thinking', Nature 387, 652–3.
McKenzie, J. A. and K. O'Farrell: 1993, 'Modification of Developmental Instability and Fitness: Malathion-Resistance in the Australian Sheep Blowfly', Genetica 89, 67–76.
Mealey, L., C. Daood and M. Krage: 1996, 'Enhanced Memory for Faces of Cheaters', Ethology and Sociobiology 17, 119–28.
Meltzoff, A. N.: 1995, 'Understanding the Intentions of Others: Re-enactment of Intended Acts by 18-month-old Children', Developmental Psychology 31, 838–50.
Menzel, E. W.: 1974, 'A Group of Chimpanzees in a 1-Acre Field: Leadership and Communication', in A. M. Schrier and F. Stollnitz (eds), Behavior of Nonhuman Primates, Academic Press, New York, pp. 83–153.
Milgram, S.: 1974. Obedience to Authority, Harper and Row, New York.
Mitchell, R. W.: 1986, 'A Framework for Discussing Deception', in R. W. Mitchell and N. S. Thompson (eds), Deception: Perspectives on Human and Nonhuman Deceit, SUNY Press, New York, pp. 3–40.
Nishida, T.: 1983, 'Alpha Status and Agonistic Alliance in Wild Chimpanzees (Pan Troglodytes Schweinfurthü)', Primates 24, 318–336.
Nucci, L. P., E. Turiel and G. Encarnacion-Gawrych: 1983, 'Children's Social Interactions and Social Concepts', Journal of Cross Cultural Psychology 14, 469–87.
Oaksford, M. and N. Chater: 1994, 'A Rational Analysis of the Selection Task As Optimal Data Selection', Psychological Review 101, 608–31
Perner, J.: 1991, Understanding the Representational Mind, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Perner, J., T. Ruthman and S. R. Leekam: 1994, 'Theory of Mind is Contagious: You Catch It from Your Sibs', Child Development 65, 1228–38.
Perner, J. and H. Wimmer: 1985, 'John Thinks That Mary Thinks That...: Attribution of Second-Order Beliefs by 5-10-Year-Old Children', Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 38, 437–71.
Pope Edwards, C.: 1982, 'Moral Development in Comparative Cultural Perspective', in D. A. Wagner and H. W. Stevenson (eds), Cultural Perspectives on Child Development, W. H. Freeman, San Francisco.
Politzer, G. and A. Nguyen-Xuan: 1992, 'Reasoning about Conditional Promises and Warnings: Darwinian Algorithms, Mental Models, Relevance Judgments, or Pragmatic Schemes?', Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 44A, 401–421.
Povinelli, D. J.: 1994, 'What Chimpanzees (Might) Know about the Mind', in R. W. Wrangham, W. C. McGrew, F. B. M. de Waal and P. G. Heitne (eds), Chimpanzee Cultures, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 285–300.
Prud'homme, J. and B. Chapais: 1993, 'Aggressive Interventions and Matrilineal Dominance Relations in Semifree-Ranging Barbary Macaques', Primates 34, 271–83.
Putnam, H.: 1974, 'The 'Corroboration' of Theories', in P. A. Schilpp (ed.), The Philosophy of Karl Popper, Vol. 1, Open Court, LaSalle, IL, pp. 221–40.
Rabbie, J. M.: 1992, 'The Effect of Intragroup Cooperation and Intergroup Competition on In-Group and Out-Group Hostility', in F. de Waal and A. H. Harcourt (eds), Coalitions and Alliances in Humans and Other Animals, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 175–208.
Riggs, K. J., D. M. Peterson, E. J. Robinson, and P. Mitchell: 1998, 'Are Errors in False Belief Tasks Symptomatic of a Broader Difficulty with Counterfactuality?', Cognitive Development 13, 73–90.
Riss, D. C. and J. Goodall: 1977, 'The Recent Rise to the Alpha-Rank in a Population of Free-Living Chimpanzees', Folia Primatologica 27, 134–51.
Robinson, J. G.: 1982, 'Intrasexual Competition and Mate Choice in Primates', American Journal of Primatology, 1 Supplement, 131–44.
Rubin, K. and R. J. Caplan: 1992, Peer Relationships in Childhood, Erlbaum, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
Ruffman, T., J. Perner, M. Naito, L. Parkin and W. C. Clements: 1998, 'Older (But Not Younger) Siblings Facilitate False Belief Understanding', Developmental Psychology 34, 161–74.
Scribner, S.: 1975, 'Recall of Classical Syllogisms: A Cross-Cultural Investigation of Errors on Logical Problems', in R. J. Falmagne (ed.), Reasoning: Representation and Process in Children and Adults, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ.
Seyfarth, R. M.: 1976, 'Social Relationships among Adult Female Monkeys', Animal Behavior 24, 917–38.
Seyfarth, R. M. and D. L. Cheney: 1984, 'Grooming, Alliances, and Reciprocal Altriusm in Vervet Monkeys', Nature 308, 541–3.
Silk, J. B.: 1987, 'Social Behavior in Evolutionary Perspective', in B. B. Smuts, D. L. Cheney, R. M. Seyfarth, R. W. Wrangham and T. T. Struhsaker (eds), Primate Societies, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 318–29.
Smith, P. K.: 1988, 'The Cognitive Demands of Children's Social Interactions With Peers', in R. W. Byrne and A. Whiten (eds), Machiavellian Intelligence: Social Expertise and the Evolution of Intellect in Monkeys Apes and Humans, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 94–110.
Smuts, B.: 1985, Sex and Friendship in Baboons, Aldine Press, Hawthorne.
Snarey, J. R.: 1985, 'Cross-Cultural Universality of Social-Moral Development: A Critical Review of Kohlbergian Research', Psychological Bulletin 97, 202–32.
Stanovich, K. E. and R. F. West, in press, 'Cognitive Ability and Variation in Selection Task Performance', Thinking and Reasoning 4, 193-230.
Strayer, F. F. and M. Trudel: 1984, 'Developmental Changes in the Nature and Function of Social Dominance Among Young Children', Ethology and Sociobiology 5, 279–95.
Strichartz, A. F. and R. V. Burton: 1990, 'Lies and Truth: A Study in the Development of the Concept', Child Development 61, 211–20.
Tutin, C. E. G.: 1979, 'Mating Patterns and Reproductive Strategies in a Community of Wild Chimpanzees (Pan Troglodytes Schweinfurtü)', Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 6, 29–38.
Uehara, S., M. Hiraiwa-Hasegawa, K. Hosaka and M. Hamai: 1994, 'The Fate of Defeated Alpha Male Chimpanzees in Relation To Their Social Networks', Primates 35, 49–55.
Vandell, L. and K. S. Wilson: (1987), 'Infant's InteractionsWith Mother, Sibling, and Peer: Contrasts and Relations Between Interaction Systems', Child Development 58, 176–86.
de Waal, F. B.M.: 1982, Chimpanzee Politics, Johns-Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
de Waal, F. B. M.: 1989, 'Food Sharing and Reciprocal Obligations among Chimpanzees', Journal of Human Evolution 18, 433–59.
de Waal, F. B. M.: 1992, 'Coalitions As Part of Reciprocal Relations in the Arnhem Chimpanzee Colony', in A. H. Harcourt and F. De Waal (eds), Coalitions and Alliances in Humans and Other Animals, Oxford University, Oxford, pp. 233–58.
de Waal, F. B. M.: 1996, Good Natured: The Origins of Right and Wrong in Humans, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Waddington, C. H.: 1975, The Evolution of an Evolutionist, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY.
Walters, J. R. and R. M. Seyfarth: 1987, 'Conflict and Cooperation', in B. B. Smuts, D. L. Cheney, R.M. Seyfarth, R.W. Wrangham, and T. T. Struhsaker (eds), Primate Societies, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 306–17.
Watts, C. R. and A. W. Stokes: 1971, 'The Social Order of Turkeys', Scientific American 224, 112–8
Weg, E. and V. Smith: 1993, 'On the Failure To Induce Meager Offers in Ultimatum Games', Journal of Economic Psychology 14, 17–32
Wellman, H. M.: 1990, The Child's Theory of Mind, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Whiten, A. and R. W. Byrne: 1988, 'The Manipulation of Attention in Primate Tactical Deception', in R. W. Byrne and A. Whiten (eds), Machiavellian Intelligence, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 211–24.
Wimmer, H., S. Gruber and J. Perner: 1984, 'Young Children's Conception of Lying: Lexical Realism - Moral Subjectivism', Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 37, 1–30.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cummins, D.D. How the Social Environment Shaped the Evolution of Mind. Synthese 122, 3–28 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005263825428
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005263825428