Abstract
Previous research in conceptual indexing methods of images has furnished us with refined theoretical frameworks characterising various aspects of images that could and should be indexed using textual descriptors. The development of digital image processing technologies has bred a brigade of content-based indexing and retrieval methods available for applications. What the users need and in what kinds of environments different indexing and retrieval methods are relevant, has remained an area of less intensive research work.
This article presents the results of a field study concentrating on journalists as users of a digital newspaper photo archive. The expressed photo needs, applied selection criteria and observed searching behaviours in journalists' daily work were contrasted with the indexing practices applied by the archivists. The results showed that the journalists achieved satisfactory results when trivial query terms were available, e.g. when photos of named persons were needed. Browsing was the main searching strategy applied by the journalists, but the system did not support browsing well. The access problems faced by the users in particular photo needs are discussed in detail. The paper concludes by discussing the potential approaches in developing both the concept-based and content-based indexing methods as well as the user interfaces in photo retrieval systems.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Armitage LH and Enser PG (1997) Analysis of user need in image archives. Journal of Information Science, 23:287¶299.
Ballesteros L and Croft WB (1998) Resolving ambiquity for cross-language retrieval. In: Croft WB, Moffat A and van Rijsbergen CJ, Wilkinson R and Zobel J, Eds., Proceedings of the 21st Annual International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval. ACM, New York, 64¶71.
Batley S (1988)Visual information retrieval: browsing strategies in pictorial databases. In: Online information/'88, Vol 1, (Proceedings of the 12th International Online Information Meeting). Learned Information Ltd, Oxford, pp. 373¶381.
Besser H (1990) Visual access to visual images: The UC Berkeley image database project. Library Trends 38:787¶798.
Brown P and Hidderley R (1996) The democratic indexing of images. The New Review of Hypermedia and Multimedia: Applications and Research, 2:107¶120.
Crehange M, Foucaut JF, Halin G and Mouaddib N (1989) Semantics of user interface for image retrieval: possibility theory and learning techniques. Information Processing & Management, 25:615¶628.
Eakins JP (1996) Automatic image content retrieval·are we getting anywhere? In: Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Electronic Library and Visual Information Research, De Montfort University, Milton Keynes, pp. 123¶135.
Enser PG (1993) Query analysis in a visual information retrieval context. Journal of Document and Text Management, 1:25¶52.
Enser PG (1995) Pictorial information retrieval. Journal of Documentation, 51:126¶170.
Froechlich TJ (1994) Relevance reconsidered·towards an agenda for the 21st century. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 45:124¶134.
Fugmann R (1993) Subject analysis and Indexing·Theorethical Foundations and Practical Advice. Frankfurt/Main, Index Verlag.
Gong Y (1998) Intelligent Image Databases: Towards Advanced Image Retrieval. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston.
Gupta A and Jain R (1997) Visual information retrieval. Communications of the ACM, 40:71¶79.
IPTC-NAA (1993) Digital newsphoto parameter record. Version No.2. Copyright by Comite International Des Telecommunications De Presse and Newspaper Association of America. United Kingdom.
JØrgensen C (1995) Classifying images: criteria for grouping as revealed in a sorting task. In: Schwartz RP, Beghtol C, Jacob EK, Kwasnik BH and Smith PJ, Eds., Proceedings of the 6th ASIS SIG/CR Classification Research Workshop. American Society for Information Science, pp. 65¶78.
JØrgensen C (1996) Indexing images: testing an image description template. In: Harding S, Ed., Proceedings of the 59th ASIS Annual Meeting 1996 (Information Today, Vol. 33), Medford, New Jersey, pp. 209¶213.
JØrgensen C (1998) Attributes of images in describing tasks. Infromation Processing and Management, 34:161¶174.
Keister LH (1994) User types and queries: impact on image access systems. In: Fidel R, Hahn TB, Rasmussen EM and Smith PJ, Eds., Challanges in Indexing Electronic Text and Images. Learned Information, Medford, New Jersey, pp. 7¶22.
Kekäläinen J and Järvelin K (1998). The impact of query structure and query expansion on retrieval performance. In: Croft WB, Moffat A, van Rijsbergen CJ, Wilkinson R and Zobel J, Eds., Proceedings of the 21st Annual International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval. ACM, New York, pp. 130¶137.
Markey K (1986) Subject Access to Visual Resource Collections: A Model for Computer Construction of Thematic Catalogues. Westport, Connecticut, Greenwood Press.
Markkula M and Sormunen E (1998) Searching for photos·Journalists' practices in pictorial IR. In: Eakins JP, Harper DJ and Jose JM, Eds., The Challange of Image Retrieval, (Electronic Workshops in Computing, eWIC). URL: http//www.ewic.org.uk/ewic/workshop/view.cfm/CIR-98.
Mehtre BM, Kankanhalli MS and Lee WF (1998) Content-based image retrival using a composite colorshape approach. Information Processing and Management, 34:109¶120.
O'Connor B (1993) Browsing: a framework for seeking functional information. Knowledge: Creation, Diffusion, Utilization, 15:211¶232.
Ørnager S (1994) The Image database: need for innovative indexing and retrieval. In: Knowledge Organisation and Quality Management, (Proceedings of the Third International ISKO Conference 20¶24 June 1994, Copenhagen, Denmark). Indeks Verlag, Frankfurt/Main, pp. 208¶216.
Ørnager S (1995) The newspaper image database: empirical supported analysis of users' typology and word association clusters. In: Proceedings of the 18th Annual International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval. pp. 212¶218.
Ørnager S (1996) View a picture. Theoretical image analysis and empirical user studies on indexing and retrieval. Swedish Library Research, 2¶3:31¶41.
Panofsky E (1970) Meaning in the Visual Arts. Penguin, London.
Pirkola A (1998) The effects of query structure and dictionary setups in dictionary-based cross-language information retrieval. In: Croft WB, Moffat A, van Rijsbergen CJ, Wilkinson R and Zobel J, Eds., Proceedings of the 21st Annual International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval. ACM, New York, pp. 55¶63.
Price R, Chua T and Al Hawamdeh S (1992) Applying relevance feedback to a photo archiving system. Journal of Information Science, 18:203¶215.
Rasmussen EM (1997) Indexing images. In: Williams ME, Ed., Annual Review of Information Science and Technology, Vol. 32 Information Today, Medford, New Jersey, pp. 169¶196.
Schamber L, Eisenberg MB and Nilan MS (1990) A re-examination of relevance: towards a dynamic, situational definition. Information Processing and Management, 26:755¶776.
Seloff GA (1990) Automated access to the NASA-JSC image archives. Library Trends, 38:682¶695.
Shatford S (1986) Analyzing the subject of a picture: a theoretical approach. Cataloguing and Classification Quarterly, 6:39¶62.
Shatfort Layne S (1994) Some issues in the indexing of images. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 45:583¶588.
Soergel D (1994) Indexing and Retrieval Performance: The Logical evidence. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 45:589¶599.
Sormunen E, Markkula M and Jävelin K. (accepted for publication) The perceived similarity of photos·seeking a solid basis for the evaluation of content-based retrieval algorithms. In: the Proceedings of the Final Mira Conference, Glasgow 14¶16 April 1999.
Taylor RS (1968) Question-negotiation and information seeking in libraries. College & Research Libraries, 29:178¶194.
Turner JM (1994) Indexing “Ordinary” Pictures for Storage and Retrieval. Visual Resources, 10:256¶273.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Markkula, M., Sormunen, E. End-User Searching Challenges Indexing Practices in the Digital Newspaper Photo Archive. Information Retrieval 1, 259–285 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009995816485
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009995816485