Michael A. Katz
Abstract
Users faced with Web sites containing many possibly relevant pages often have a decision to make about navigation: use the menu of links or use the provided site search function. Two studies were conducted to examine what users do when faced with this decision on e-commerce Web sites, and how users go about deciding which method to attempt. An exploratory study revealed a wide distribution of searching and browsing behavior across sites and users. Counter to some predictions, use of the site search functions did not yield faster or more accurate performance in locating products. Questionnaire data suggested that factors relevant to the menu structure, interface element prominence, information scent and user dispositions all influenced the decision of whether to browse or search a site for a product. A second experiment utilizing novel e-commerce sites and allowing for more control of factors found to be important in the first study found that browsing behavior was influenced by both the breadth and information scent of the menus. These results suggest that providing site search should not be used to compensate for poor menu design, and provide further evidence regarding the design of effective menu structures.
- Blackmon, M. H., Polson, P. G., Kitajima, M., and Lewis, C. 2002. Cognitive Walkthrough for the Web, In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 2002. ACM, New York, 463--470. Google Scholar
- Byrne, M. D., John, B. E., Wehrle, N. S., and Crow, D. C. 1999. The tangled web we wove: A taskonomy of WWW use. In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 99. ACM, New York, 544--551. Google Scholar
- Campagnoni, F. R. and Ehrlich, K. 1989. Information retrieval using a hypertext-based help system. In Proceedings of the Twelfth Annual International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval. ACM, New York, 212--220. Google Scholar
- Card, S. K., Pirolli, P., Wege, M. V. D., Morrison, J. B., Reeder, R. W., Schraedley, P. K., and Boshart, J. 2001. Information scent as a driver of Web behavior graphs: Results of a protocol analysis method for Web usability. In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 2001. ACM, New York, 498--505. Google Scholar
- Chi, E. H., Pirolli, P., and Pitkow, J. 2000. The scent of a site: A system for analyzing and predicting information scent, usage, and usability of a Web site. In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 2000. ACM, New York, 161--168. Google Scholar
- Deerwester, S., Dumais, S., Furnas, G., Landauer, T., and Harshman, R. 1990. Indexing by latent semantic analysis. J. Am. Soc. Inf. Sci. 41, 391--407.Google Scholar
- Evans, G. W. 1980. Environmental cognition. Psych. Bull. 88, 259--287.Google Scholar
- Golledge, R. G., Smith, T. R., Pellegrino, J. W., Doherty, S., and Marshall, S. P. 1985. A conceptual model and empirical analysis of children's acquisition of spatial knowledge. J. Exper. Psych. 5, 125--152.Google Scholar
- Kleinmuntz, D. N. and Schkade, D. A. 1993. Information displays and decision processes. Psych. Sci. 4(4), 221--227.Google Scholar
- Koman, R. 1998. The scent of information: Helping users find their way by making your site "smelly." http://webreview.com/wr/pub/98/05/15/feature/index.html.Google Scholar
- Landauer, T., Foltz, P., and Laham, D. 1998. Introduction to latent semantic analysis. Discourse Processes, 25, 259--284.Google Scholar
- Larson, K. and Czerwinski, M. 1998. Web page design: Implications of memory, structure, and scent for information retrieval. In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 98. ACM, New York, 25--32. Google Scholar
- Lohse, G. L. and Spiller, P. 1998. Quantifying the effect of user interface design features on cyberstore traffic and sales. In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 98. ACM, New York, 211--218. Google Scholar
- Marchionini, G. 1989. Making the transition from print to electronic encyclopedias: Adaptation of mental models. Int. J. Man-Machine Studies, 30, 591--618. Google Scholar
- Nielsen, J. 2000. Designing web usability: The practice of simplicity. New Riders Publishing, Indianapolis, IN. Google Scholar
- Nisbett, R. and Wilson, T. 1977. Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes. Psych. Rev. 84(3), 231--259.Google Scholar
- Norman, K. L. 1991. The psychology of menu selection: Designing cognitive control at the human/computer interface. Ablex, Norwood, NJ. Google Scholar
- Payne, J. W., Bettman, J. R., and Johnson, E. J. 1993. The adaptive decision maker. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
- Pirolli, P. 1997. Computational models of information scent-following in a very large browsable text collection. In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 97. ACM, New York, 3--10. Google Scholar
- Pirolli, P. and Card, S. 1995. Information foraging in information access environments. In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 95. ACM, New York, 51--58. Google Scholar
- Pirolli, P. and Card, S. 1999. Information foraging. Psych. Rev. 106(4), 643--675.Google Scholar
- Powell, T. A. 2000. The complete reference: Web design. Berkeley, CA: Osborne/McGraw-Hill. Google Scholar
- Rada, R. and Murphy, C. 1992. Searching versus browsing in hypertext. Hypermedia, 4(1), 1--30. Google Scholar
- Sanderson, P. M., Mcneese, M. D., and Zaff, B. S. 1994. Handling complex real-world data with two cognitive engineering tools: COGENT and MacSHAPA. Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, and Computers, 26(2), 117--124.Google Scholar
- Sawyer, P. 2000. Links that give off scent. User Interface Engineering, Inc. Report. North Andover, MA.Google Scholar
- Scanlon, T. 2000. On-site searching and scent. User Interface Engineering, Inc. Report. North Andover, MA.Google Scholar
- Schamber, L., Eisenberg, M. B., and Nilan, M. S. 1990. A re-examination of relevance: Towards a dynamic situational definition. Information Processing and Management, 26, 755--776. Google Scholar
- Sellen, A. J., Murphy, R., and Shaw, K. L. 2002. How Knowledge Workers Use the Web, In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 2002. ACM, New York, 227--234. Google Scholar
- Spool, J. 2001. Are there users who always search? http://world.std.com/∼uieweb/always.htmGoogle Scholar
- Spool, J. M. and Klee, M. 2000. Designing for scent. North Andover, MA: User Interface Engineering, Inc. Report.Google Scholar
- Soto, R. 1999. Learning and performing by exploration: Label quality measured by latent semantic analysis. In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI 99. ACM, New York, 418--425. Google Scholar
- Tilson, R., Dong, J., Martin, S., and Kieke, E. 1998. A comparison of two current e-commerce sites. In Proceedings of the ACM 16th International Conference on Systems Documentation. ACM, New York, 87--92. Google Scholar
- Todd, S. and Kramer, A. 1993. Attentional guidance in visual attention. In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 37th Annual Meeting. Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Santa Monica, CA, 1378--1382.Google Scholar
- Vinson, N. G. 1999. Design guidelines for landmarks to support navigation in virtual environments. In Human Factors in Computing Systems: Proceedings of CHI '99. ACM, New York, 278--285. Google Scholar
- Wang, P. and Soergel, D. 1998. A cognitive model of document use during a research project. Study I. Document selection. J. Am. Soc. Inf. Sci. 49(2), 115--133. Google Scholar
Index Terms
- Effects of scent and breadth on use of site-specific search on e-commerce Web sites
Recommendations
What do web users do? An empirical analysis of web use
This paper provides an empirical characterization of user actions at the web browser. The study is based on an analysis of 4 months of logged client-side data that describes user actions with recent versions of Netscape Navigator. In particular, the ...
Designing Web Sites for Customer Loyalty Across Business Domains: A Multilevel Analysis
Web sites are important components of Internet strategy for organizations. This paper develops a theoretical model for understanding the effect of Web site design elements on customer loyalty to a Web site. We show the relevance of the business domain ...
Studying information seeking on the non-English Web: An experiment on a Spanish business Web portal
Human-computer interaction research in the managemant information systems disciplineThe Internet is estimated to grow significantly as access to Web content in some non-English languages continues to increase. However, prior research in human-computer interaction (HCI) has implicitly assumed the primary language used on the Web to be ...
Comments