Abstract
The ontological analysis of parts and wholes gathers recently increasing interest, and develops into a specific research area called mereology. So far, most research has focused on directions motivated by engineering examples and by linguistic analysis. In contrast to these, the related archeological problem is characterized by missing pieces and information, which cannot easily be recovered, and by reasoning and experimentation with multiple hypotheses. This aspect of mereology has not yet been formally analyzed. In this paper, we continue previous work by addressing the formalization of some of the reasoning needed to identify other parts of the same whole through knowledge about some parts, or to narrow down the category of wholes a part may have belonged to. We define a hierarchical and an associative part-of relation with conservative assumptions about dependency and sharing, and proceed to develop a metamodel and a novel reasoning methodology from factual to categorical knowledge. The ontological commitment and utility of this theory is discussed on the base of practical examples. This work is intended as a first step towards a more comprehensive theory covering the problem of reasoning about partially lost items.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Analyti, A., Spyratos, N., Constantopoulos, P.: Deriving and Retrieving Contextual Categorical Information through Instance Inheritance, Fundamenta Informaticae 33, IOS Press, (1998) 1–37
Artale, A., Franconi, E., Guarino, N., Pazzi, L.: Part — Whole relations in Object — Centered Foralisms: An Overview, Data & Knowledge Engineering 20 (1996)
Artale, A., Franconi, E., Guarino, N.: Open Problems for Part-whole relations: International Workshop on Description Logics, Boston, MA (1996)
Bekiari, Ch., Constantopoulos, P., Bitzou, Th.: DELTOS — A Documentation Sytsem for the Antiquities and Preserved Buildings of Crete, Requirements Analysis. Technical Report FORTH-ICS/TR60 (1992)
Bekiari, Ch., Bitzou Th., Calomoirakis, D., Chronaki, D., Costantopoulos, P.: DELTOS — conservation documentation and administration of site monuments and preserved buildings. Proc. III Convegno Internazionale di Archeologia e Informatica, Roma (1995)
Bekiari, Ch., Gritzapi, Ch., Kalomoirakis, D.: POLEMON—A Federated Database Management System for the Documentation, Management and Promotion of Cultural Heritage. Proc. 26th Conference on Computer Applications in Archaeology, Barchelona, (1998)
Bekiari, Ch., Doerr, M.: Documentation and Reasoning on Parts and Potential Wholes. Computer Applications in Archaeology, Conference, Dublin Ireland (1999)
Constantopoulos, P.: Cultural Documentation—The CLIO System. Technical Report FORTH-ICS/TR-115 (1994)
Crofts, N., Dionissiadou, I., Doerr, M., Stiff, M. (eds): Definition of the CIDOC object-oriented Conceptual Reference Model (version 2.1). ICOM/CIDOC CRM Special Interest Group, http://cidoc.ics.forth.gr (1999)
Dionysiadou, I., Doerr, M.: Mapping of material culture to a semantic network. Proc. JOINT ANNUAL MEETING, International Council of Museums Documentation Committee and Computer Network, Washington USA (1994)
Doerr, M., Crofts, N.: Electronic Communication on Diverse Data — The Role of an Object-Oriented CIDOC Reference Model. CIDOC’98 Conference, Melbourne (1998)
Eaglestone, B., Holton, R., Rold, L.: GENREG—A historical data model based on event graphs. DEXA 96 Conference Proceedings, eds. Roland R. Wagner and Helmut Thoma, Lecture Notes in Computer Science} vol.1134}, Springer-Verlag, Berlin} (
Gangemi, A., Guarino, N., Masolo, C., Oltrami, A.: Understanding top-level ontological distinctions. LADSEB/CNR, Internal Report (2001)
Gerstl, P., Pribbenow, S.: A conceptual theory of part — whole relations and its applications. Data & Knowledge Engineering 20, North Holland-Elsevier (1996) 305-322
Guarino, N., Pribbenow, S., Vieu L.: Modeling Parts & Wholes. Data & Knowledge Engineering vol. 20 no 3 (1996) 257–258
Habel, C., Pribbenow, S., Simmons, G.: Partonomies and Depictions — A Hybrid Approach. In J. Glasgow, H. Narayanan, B. Chandrasekaran (Eds.): Diagrammatic Reasoning: Computational and Cognitive Perspectives,AAAI/MIT Press (1995)
Halper, M, Geller, J., Perl J.: An OODB part-whole model: Semantics, notation and implementation. Data & Knowledge Engineering vol 27 no 1 (1998) 59–95
Motschnig — Pitrik, R.:The Semantics of Parts Versus Aggregates in Data/Knowledge Modelling. Proceedings of the CaiSE.93, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, No. 685, Springer 352–373 (1993)
Motschnig — Pitrik, R., Kaasboll, J.: Part — Whole Relationship Categories and Their Application in Object. Oriented Analysis. IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering, Vol. 11, No. 5, (1999)
Mylopoylos, J., Borgida, A., Jarke, M., Koubarakis, M.: Telos: Representing Knowledge about Information Systems. ACM Transactions on Information Systems 8(4) (1990)
Pantos, P., Bekiari, Ch.: POLEMON — A Project to Computerize the Monument Records at the Greek Ministry of Culture. Proc. Archaelogical Heritage: Inventory and Documentations Standards in Europe, Oxford (1995)
Pazzi, L.: Implicit versus Explicit characterization of complex Entities and Events. Data & Knowledge Engineering 31 (1999)
Pfisterer — Haas, S.: Wenn der Topf aber num ein Loch hat. Sonderausstellung im Antikenmuseum der Universitat Leipzig, vom 13. Mai bis (1998)
Polkowski, L., Skowron, A.: Rough Mereology. Lecture notes in Computer Science vol. 869, (1994) 85–94
Rold, L.: GENREG: A simple and flexible system for object registration at the National Museum of Denmark. Selected papers from the 3rd International Conference on hypermedia and interactivity in Museums. San Diego, California.
Smith, B., Varzi, A.: Fiat and Bona Fide Boundaries: Towards on Ontology of Spatially Extended Objects. International Conference COSIT’97, Proceedings. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 1329, Springer, (1997) 103–119
Uschold, M.: The use of the typed Lambda Calculus for guiding Naïve Users in the Representation and Acquisition of Part — Whole Knowledge. Data & Knowledge Engineering vol 20 no 3 (1996) 385–404
Vandenberg, Ph.: Nofrete. Eine archaeologische Biographie. Scherz Verlag Bern und (1975).
Varzi, A.: Parts, Wholes and part-whole relations—The prospects of mereotopology. Data & Knowledge Engineering 20, North Holland-Elsevier (1996) 259–286.
Winston, M., Chaffin, R., Herrmann, D.: A Taxonomy of Part-Whole Relations. Cognitive Science 11(4), (1987) 417–444
Wolinski, F., Perrot, J.: Representation of Complex Objects: Multiple Facets with Part—Whole Hierarchies. Lecture Notes in Computer Science vol 512 (1991)
Zadrozny, W., Kim, M.: Computational Mereology — A Study of Part-of Relations for Multimedia Indexing. Annals of Mathematics and Artificial Intelligence, vol 15 (1995) 83–100
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2001 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this paper
Cite this paper
Doerr, M., Plexousakis, D., Bekiari, C. (2001). A Metamodel for Part ñ Whole Relationships for Reasoning on Missing Parts and Reconstruction. In: S.Kunii, H., Jajodia, S., Sølvberg, A. (eds) Conceptual Modeling — ER 2001. ER 2001. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol 2224. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/3-540-45581-7_31
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/3-540-45581-7_31
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-540-42866-4
Online ISBN: 978-3-540-45581-3
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive