Abstract
It is a well-known fact that only factive propositional attitude predicates are felicitous with wh- (indirect question) complements. It has also been noted that so-called emotive factive predicates are only felicitous with some, not all, indirect question complements. But the reasons for these two constraints have remained unclear. I propose a competition-based explanation in terms of optimality theoretic pragmatics: Due to the competition with factive predicates, predicates like believe are infelicitous with complements automatically verifying the factive presupposition; and emotive factive predicates are infelicitous with wh- complements to the extent that these complements compete with more informative that complements. To arrive at these results, it is necessary to assume an analysis of questions on which they denote propositions and to be more careful than has been customary about the formulation of the presuppositions of factive and what I call super-factive predicates.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Abels, K.: Remarks on Grimshaw’s clausal typology. In: Maier, E., Bary, C., Huitink, J. (eds.) Proceedings of SuB9, Nijmegen, pp. 1–15 (2005)
Beaver, D.: Presuppositions. In: van Benthem, J., ter Meulen, A. (eds.) The Handbook of Logic and Language, pp. 939–1008. Elsevier, North-Holland (1997)
Blutner, R.: Lexical Pragmatics. Journal of Semantics 15, 115–162 (1998)
Blutner, R.: Some Aspects of Optimality in Natural Language Interpretation. Journal of Semantics 17, 189–216 (2000)
Blutner, R.: Lexical Semantics and Pragmatics. In: Hamm, F., Zimmermann, E. (eds.) Semantics (= Linguistische Berichte Sonderheft 10), pp. 27–58 (2002)
Blutner, R.: Pragmatics and the lexicon. In: Horn, L., Ward, G. (eds.) Handbook of Pragmatics, pp. 488–514. Blackwell, Oxford (2004)
Blutner, R.: Embedded Implicatures and Optimality Theoretic Pragmatics. In: Solstad, T., Grønn, A., Haug, D. (eds.) A Festschrift for Kjell Johan Sæbø, Oslo, pp. 11–29 (2006)
Blutner, R., Zeevat, H.: Optimality Theory and Pragmatics. Palgrave MacMillan, London (2003)
Boër, S.: Towards a Theory of Indirect Question Clauses. Linguistics and Philosophy 2, 307–345 (1978)
d’Avis, F.: On the interpretation of wh- clauses in exclamative environments. Theoretical Linguistics 28, 5–32 (2002)
Egré, P.: Question-Embedding and Factivity. Presentation at the 3iéme Journée de Sémantique et Modélisation, ENS, Paris (2005)
Elliott, D.: The Grammar of Emotive and Exclamative Sentences in English. Doctoral dissertation, Ohio State University (1971)
Gallin, D.: Intensional and higher-order modal logic, Amsterdam (1975)
Ginzburg, J.: Resolving Questions, II. Linguistics and Philosophy 18, 567–609 (1995)
Grimshaw, J.: English Wh-Constructions and the Theory of Grammar. Doctoral dissertation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst (1977)
Grimshaw, J.: Complement selection and the lexicon. Linguistic Inquiry 10, 279–326 (1979)
Groenendijk, J., Stokhof, M.: Semantic analysis of Wh-complements. Linguistics and Philosophy 5, 175–233 (1982)
Huddleston, R.: Remarks on the Construction. You won’t believe who Ed has married. Lingua 91, 175–184 (1993)
Kiparsky, P., Kiparsky, C.: Fact. In: Bierwisch, M., Heidolph, K.E. (eds.) Progress in Linguistics, pp. 143–173. Mouton, The Hague (1970)
Lahiri, U.: Lexical Selection and Quantificational Variability in Embedded Interrogatives. Linguistics and Philosophy 23, 325–389 (2000)
Lahiri, U.: Questions and Answers in Embedded Contexts. OUP, New York (2002)
Lewis, D.: Whether Report. In: Pauli, T. (ed.) Philosophical Essays Dedicated to Lennart Åqvist on his Fiftieth Birthday, Uppsala, pp. 194–206 (1982)
Zimmermann, E.: Kontextabhängigkeit. In: Stechow, A., Wunderlich, D. (eds.) Semantics. An International Handbook of Contemporary Research, Berlin, pp. 156–229 (1991)
Zimmermann, E.: Knowledge and Desire, from a German Perspective. In: Solstad, T., Grønn, A., Haug, D. (eds.) A Festschrift for Kjell Johan Sæbø, Oslo, pp. 211–223 (2006)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2007 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this paper
Cite this paper
Sæbø, K.J. (2007). A Whether Forecast. In: ten Cate, B.D., Zeevat, H.W. (eds) Logic, Language, and Computation. TbiLLC 2005. Lecture Notes in Computer Science(), vol 4363. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-75144-1_14
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-75144-1_14
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-540-75143-4
Online ISBN: 978-3-540-75144-1
eBook Packages: Computer ScienceComputer Science (R0)