Abstract
A common dilemma for modelers in operations research (OR) involves how to construct ethically sensitive models. Concern for ethical modeling has recently become more widespread in the OR literature. Arguably, however, this concern has not manifested into concrete frameworks for analyzing models. This paper presents an approach from the organizational ethics field for evaluating models. After first reviewing the state of ethics in OR—its relevance and current applications—a stakeholder framework for evaluating the social performance of the model is presented. Stakeholder theory is effective for assessing the impacts of models in use. The normative core underlying this theory addresses the ethical concerns in decision support systems and provides a prescriptive solution to ethical issues in modeling.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ackoff RL (1979) The future of operational research. Oper Res Q 30: 361–371
Apte A, Apte UM, Beatty RP et al (2004) The impact of check sequencing on NSF (not-sufficient funds) fees. Interfaces 34: 97–105
Aristotle (1998) Nicomachean ethics. Dover, Toronto
Ashworth L, Free C (2006) Marketing dataveillance and digital privacy: using theories of justice to understand consumers’ online privacy concerns. J Bus Ethics 67: 107–123
Behrens DA, Rauner MS, Caulkins JP (2008) Modelling the spread of hepatitis C via commercial tattoo parlours: implications for public health interventions. OR Spectrum 30(2): 269–288
Ben-Tal A, Nemirovski A (2008) Selected topics in robust convex optimization. Math Program 112: 125–158
Bichescu BC, Micael J, Fry MJ (2009) Vendor-managed inventory and the effect of channel power. OR Spectrum 31(1): 195–228
Bies RJ, Moag JS (1986) Interactional justice: communication criteria of fairness. In: Lewicki RJ, Sheppard BH, Bazerman M (eds) Research on negotiation in organizations, vol 1. JAI Press, Greenwich, pp 43–55
Blumstein A (2002) Crime modeling. Oper Res 50: 16–24
Brans JP (2004) The management of the Future. Ethics in operational research. Respect, multicriteria management, happiness. Eur J Oper Res 153: 466–467
Brans JP, Gallo G (2007) Ethics in OR/MS: past, present and future. Ann Oper Res 153: 165–178
Brey P (2007) Computer ethics and the right of the good. In: Proceedings of computer ethics philosophical enquiry, 7th conference, pp 46–48
Brown R (2005) The operation was a success but the patient died: aider priorities influence decision aid usefulness. Interfaces 35: 511–521
Buchholz RA (1993) Principles of environmental management: the greening of business. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Butler JC, Chebeskov AN, Dyer JS et al (2005) The United States and Russia evaluate plutonium disposition options with multiattribute utility theory. Interfaces 35: 88–101
Churchman CW (1970) Operations research as a profession. Manage Sci 17: B37–B53
Cordoba JR, Midgley G (2006) Broadening the boundaries: an application of critical systems thinking to IS planning in Colombia. J Oper Res Soc 57: 1064–1080
Crama P, De Reyck B, Degraeve Z (2008) Milestone payments or royalties: contract design for R&D licensing. Oper Res 56(6): 1539–1552
Cropanzano R, Prehart CA, Chen PY (2002) Using social exchange theory to distinguish procedural from interactional justice. Group Organ Manage 27: 324–351
De Waegenaere A, Suijs J, Tijs S (2005) Stable profit sharing in cooperative investments. OR Spectrum 27(1): 85–94
Dekker R, de Koster MBM, Roodbergen KJ et al (2004) Improving order-picking response time at Ankor’s warehouse. Interfaces 34: 303–313
Donaldson T, Preston L (1995) The stakeholder theory of the modern corporation: concepts, evidence, implications. Acad Manage Rev 20: 65–91
Driscoll C, Starik M (2004) The primordial stakeholder: advancing the conceptual consideration of stakeholder status for the natural environment. J Bus Ethics 49: 387–402
Dyer JS, Edmunds TE, Butler JC et al (1998) A multi-attribute utility analysis of alternatives for the disposition of surplus weapons-grade plutonium. Oper Res 46: 749–762
Elkington J (1994) Towards the sustainable corporation: win-win-win business strategies for sustainable development. Calif Manage Rev 36: 90–100
Elkington J (1998) Cannibals with forks: the triple bottom line of 21st Century business. New Society Publishers, Gabriola Island
Freeman RE (1984) Strategic management. Pitman, Boston
Freeman RE (1994) The politics of stakeholder theory: some future directions. Bus Ethics Q 4: 409–421
Freeman RE (1999) Divergent stakeholder theory. Acad Manage Rev 24: 233–236
Freeman RE, Wicks AC, Parmar B (2004) Stakeholder theory and the corporate objective revisited. Organ Sci 15: 364–369
Fleße S (2003) Decision support for AIDS control programmes in Eastern Africa. OR Spectrum 25(2): 265–291
Gallo G (2004) Operations research and ethics: responsibility, sharing and cooperation. Eur J Oper Res 153: 468–476
Gass SI, Assad AA (2005) An annotated timeline of operations research: an informal history. Kluwer Academic Publishers, New York
Gazis DC (2002) The origins of traffic theory. Oper Res 50: 69–77
Gerde VW (2001) The design dimensions of the just organization: An empirical test of the relation between organization design and corporate social performance (dissertation abstract). Bus Soc 40: 472–477
Greenberg J (1993) The social side of fairness: Interpersonal and informational classes of organizational justice. In: Cropanzano R (eds) Justice in the workplace: approaching fairness in human resource management. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, pp 70–103
Hervani AA, Helms MM, Sarkis J (2005) Performance measurement for green supply chain management. Benchmarking Int J 12: 330–353
Hughes JS, Thevaranjan A (1995) Current production targets and strategic decisions by corporate managers. J Oper Manage 12(3,4): 321–329
Jonas H (1979) Das prinzip verantwortung. Insel Verlag, Frankfurt
Jones TM (1995) Instrumental stakeholder theory: a synthesis of ethics and economics. Acad Manage Rev 20: 404–437
Jones TM, Wicks AC (1999) Convergent stakeholder theory. Acad Manage Rev 24: 206–221
Kaler J (2000) Positioning business ethics in relation to management and political philosophy. J Bus Ethics 24: 257–272
Kaler J (2002) Morality and strategy in stakeholder identification. J Bus Ethics 39: 91–99
Kaplan RS, Norton DP (1996) The balanced scorecard. Harvard Business School Press, Boston
Keeney RL (2002) Common mistakes in making value trade-offs. Oper Res 50: 935–945
Keeney RL, Raiffa H (1976) Decisions with multiple objectives. John Wiley and Sons, New York
Kim JJ (2009) New FICO credit score debuts. The Wall Street J 29 (January):D3
Kirkwood CW, Slaven MP, Maltz A (2005) Improving supply-chain reconfiguration decisions at IBM. Interfaces 35: 460–473
Kleijnen JPC (2001) Ethical issues in modeling: some reflections. Eur J Oper Res 130: 223–230
Kleijnen JPC (2004) Invited review: an overview of the design and analysis of simulation experiments for sensitivity analysis. Eur J Oper Res 164: 287–300
Koch T (2000) We live in the city, not in a study. OR/MS Today 27(2)
Le Menestrel M, Van Wassenhove LN (2004) Ethics outside, within, or beyond OR models?. Eur J Oper Res 153: 477–484
Leventhal GS (1980) What should be done with equity theory? New approaches to the study of fairness in social relationships. In: Greenberg M, Willis R (eds) Social exchange: advances in theory and research. Plenum, New York, pp 27–55
Lilly JD, Virick M (2003) The effect of personality on perceptions of justice. J Manage Psychol 21: 438–458
Lind E, Tyler T (1988) The social psychology of procedural justice. Plenum, New York
Mele D (2003) Organizational humanizing cultures: do they generate social capital?. J Bus Ethics 45: 3–14
Midgley G (1999) Ethical dilemmas: a reply to Richard Ormerod. J Oper Res 50: 549–553
Midgley G, Munlo I, Brown M (1998) The theory and practice of boundary critique: developing housing services for older people. J Oper Res 49: 467–478
Millet I (1998) Ethical decision making. J Bus Ethics 17: 1197–1204
Mitchell RK, Agle BR, Wood DJ (1997) Toward a theory of stakeholder identification and salience: defining the principle of who and what really counts. Acad Manage Rev 22: 853–886
Muller-Merbach H (2002) The cultural roots linking Europe. Eur J Oper Res 140: 212–224
Natarajan R, Sethuraman K, Suryseker K (2005) Reducing incremental costs associated with the delegation of incentive contracting decisions: An analysis of planning control decisions in a manufacturing setting in the presence of moral hazard. Eur J Oper Res 162(3): 816–838
Nivorozhkin E (2005) Market discipline of subordinated debt in banking: the case of costly bankruptcy. Eur J Oper Res 161(2): 364–376
Papadakis IS, Kleindorfer PR (2005) Optimizing infrastructure network maintenance when benefits are interdependent. OR Spectrum 27(1): 63–84
Rardin RL (1998) Optimization in operations research. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River
Rauner MS (2002) Resource allocation for HIV/AIDS control programs: a model-based policy analysis. OR Spectrum 24(1): 99–124
Rauner MS, Zeiles A, Schaffhauser-Linzatti MM, Hornik K (2003) Modeling the effects of the Austrian inpatient reimbursement system on length-of-stay distributions. OR Spectrum 25(2): 183–206
Rawls J (1999) A theory of justice (revised edition). Belknap Press, Cambridge
Robertson DC (1993) Empiricism in business ethics: suggested research directions. J Bus Ethics 12: 585–600
Rubenstein A (1998) Modeling bounded rationality. MIT Press, Cambridge
Sengupta S (2004) Delegating recruitment under asymmetric information. Int J Ind Organ 22(8,9): 1327–1347
Shrivastava P (1995) The role of corporations in achieving ecological sustainability. Acad Manage Rev 20: 936–960
Simon HA (1957) Models of man: social and rational. Wiley and Sons, New York
Singer MS, Singer AE (1997) Observer judgments about moral agents’ ethical decisions: the role of justice and moral intensity. J Bus Ethics 16: 473–484
Srikantia P, Bilimoria D (1997) Isomorphism in organization and management theory. Organ Environ 10: 384–408
Stadtler H (2009) A framework for collaborative planning and state-of-the-art. OR Spectrum 31(1): 5–30
Starik M (1995) Should trees have managerial standing. J Bus Ethics 14: 207–217
Stead JG, Stead WE (1997) Invisible patterns: ecology and wisdom in business and profit. Bus Soc 36: 438– 441
Stead JG, Stead WE (2000) Eco-enterprise strategy: standing for sustainability. J Bus Ethics 24: 312–329
Stoddard SA (2005) Maximizing federal natural gas royalties. Interfaces 35: 381–392
Swanson DL (1999) Toward an integrative strategy of business and society: a research strategy for corporate social performance. Acad Manage Rev 24: 506–521
Theys M, Kunsch PL (2004) The importance of co-operation for ethical decision-making with OR. Eur J Oper Res 153: 485–488
Van Gigch JP, Koenigsberg E, Dean B (1997) In search of an ethical science: an interview with C. West Churchman, an 80th birthday celebration. J Bus Ethics 16: 731–744
Waddock SA, Bodwell C (2007) Total responsibility management: the manual. Greenleaf Publishers, New York
Waddock SA, Bodwell C, Graves SB (2002) The new business imperative. Acad Manage Executive 16: 132–148
Walker W, Abrahamse A, Bolten JG et al (1993) A policy analysis of Dutch river dike improvements—trading off safety, cost, and environmental impacts. RAND Paper Series, P-7816
Wijnberg NM (2000) Normative stakeholder theory and Aristotle: the link between ethics and politics. J Bus Ethics 25: 329–342
Willemain TR (1994) Insights on modeling from a dozen experts. Oper Res 42: 213–222
Willemain TR (1995) Model formulation: what experts think about and when. Oper Res 43: 916–932
Wilson JR (1997) Doctoral colloquium keynote address: conduct, misconduct, and cargo cult science. In: Andradottir S, Healy KJ, Withers DH, Nelson BL (eds) Proceedings of the 1997 winter simulation conference, pp 1405–1413
Wong EY, Roederer R (2006) Should the U.S. have attacked Iraq?. OR/MS Today 33: 42–50
Wood DJ (1991) Corporate social performance revisited. Acad Manage Rev 16: 691–718
Wright CM, Smith ME, Wright BG (2007) Hidden costs associated with stakeholders in supply management. Acad Manage Perspect 21: 64–82
Zenios SA, Chertow GM, Wein LM (2000) Dynamic allocation of kidneys to candidates on the transplant waiting list. Oper Res 48: 549–569
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Drake, M.J., Gerde, V.W. & Wasieleski, D.M. Socially responsible modeling: a stakeholder approach to the implementation of ethical modeling in operations research. OR Spectrum 33, 1–26 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00291-009-0172-9
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00291-009-0172-9