Abstract
Probability logics have been an active topic of investigation of beliefs in type spaces in game theoretical economics. Beliefs are expressed as subjective probability measures. Savage’s postulates in decision theory imply that subjective probability measures are not necessarily countably additive but finitely additive. In this paper, we formulate a probability logic Σ+ that is strongly complete with respect to this class of type spaces with finitely additive probability measures, i.e. a set of formulas is consistent in Σ+ iff it is satisfied in a finitely additive type space. Although we can characterize Σ+-theories satisfiable in the class as maximally consistent sets of formulas, we prove that any canonical model of maximally consistent sets is not universal in the class of type spaces with finitely additive measures, and, moreover, it is not a type space. At the end of this paper, we show that even a minimal use of probability indices causes the failure of compactness in probability logics.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aliprantis, C., & Border, K. (2006). Infinite dimension analysis. In A Hitchhiker’s guide (3rd edn). New York: Springer.
Aumann R. (1999a) Interactive epistemology: Knowledge. International Journal of Game Theory 28: 263–300
Aumann R. (1999b) Interactive epistemology: Probability. International Journal of Game Theory 28: 301–314
Aumann, R., & Heifetz, A. (2002). Incomplete information. In: R. Aumann & S. Hart (Eds.), Handbook of game theory (pp. 1665–1686). Handbook Series in Economics.
Blackburn P., de Rijke M., Venema Y. et al (2000) Modal logic. In: Abramsky S. (eds) Cambridge tracts in theoretical computer science (vol. 53). Oxford University Press, Oxford
de Finetti B. (1975) Theory of probability. Wiley, New York
Fagin R., Halpern J. (1994) Reasoning about knowledge and probability. Journal of ACM 41: 340–367
Fagin R., Megiddo N., Halpern J. (1990) A logic for reasoning about probabilities. Information and Computation 87: 78–128
Fishburn C. (1986) The axioms of subjective probability. Statistical Science 1: 335–345
Gerla G. (1994) Inferences in probability logic. Artificial Intelligence 70(1–2): 33–52
Gerla G. (2001) Fuzzy logic: Mathematical tools for approximate reasoning. In: Wojcicki R. (eds) Trends in logic. Kluwer, Studia Logica Library, Amsterdam, pp 1–1
Goldblatt, R. (1993). Mathematics of modality (vol. 43). CSLI Lecture Notes. Stanford: CSLI.
Goldblatt, R. (2008). Deduction systems for coalgebras over measurable spaces. Journal of Logic and Computation (to appear).
Halpern J., Fagin R., Moses Y., Vardi V. (1995) Reasonign about knowledge. MIT Press, MA
Harsanyi J. (1967) Games with incomplete information played by bayesian players, part one. Management Science 14: 159–182
Heifetz A., Mongin P. (2001) Probability logic for type spaces. Games and Economic Behavior 35: 31–53
Heifetz A., Samet D. (1998) Knowledge space with an arbitrary high rank. Games and Economic Behavior 22: 260–273
Heifetz A., Samet D. (1998) Topology-free typology of beliefs. Journal of Economic Theory 82: 324–341
Heifetz A., Samet D. (1999) Coherent beliefs are not always types. Journal of Mathematics and Economics 32: 475–488
Horn A., Tarski A. (1948) Measures in boolean algebras. Transactions of AMS 64: 467–497
Howson C., De finetti (2008) countable addivity, consistency and coherence. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 59(3): 1–23
Los J., Marszewski E. (1949) Extensions of measures. Fundamenta Mathematicae 36: 267–276
Machina M., Schmeidler D. (1992) A more robust definition of subjective probability. Econometrica 60(4): 745–780
Meier M. (2006) Finitely additive beliefs and universal type spaces. Annals of Probability 34: 386–422
Meier, M. (2009). An infinitary probability logic for type spaces. Israel Journal of Mathematics (to appear).
Moss L., Viglizzo I. (2006) Final coalgebras for functors on measurable spaces. Information and Computation 204: 610–636
Ognjanovic Z., Raskovic M. (1999) Some probability logics with new types of probability operators. Journal of Logic and Computation 9(2): 181–195
Ognjanovic Z., Raskovic M. (2000) Some first-order probability logics. Theoretical Computer Science 247(1–2): 191–212
Ognjanovic Z., Perovic A., Raskovic M. (2008a) An axiomatization of qualitative probability. Acta Polytechnica Hungarica 5(1): 105–110
Ognjanovic Z., Perovic A., Raskovic M. (2008b) Logics with the qualitative probability operator. Logic Journal of the IGPL 16(2): 105–120
Samet D. (2000) Quantified beliefs and believed quantities. Journal of Economic Theory 95: 169–185
Savage L. (1972) The foundations of statistics. Dover, New York
Williamson J. (1999) Countably additivity and subjective probability. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 50(3): 401–416
Williamson, J. (2002). Probability logic. In: D. Gabbay, R. Johnson, H. Jurgen Ohlbach, & J. Woods (Eds.), Handbook of the logic of inference and argument: The turn towards the practical (pp. 397–424). Studies in Logic and Practical Reasoning.
Zhou, C. (2007). Complete Deductive Systems for Probability Logic with Application in Harsanyi Type spaces. PhD thesis, Indiana University, Bloomington.
Zhou, C. (2009). A complete deductive system for probability logic. Journal of Logic and Computation (to appear).
Ziemer, W. (2004). Modern real analysis. Online lecture notes.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Zhou, C. Probability Logic of Finitely Additive Beliefs. J of Log Lang and Inf 19, 247–282 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10849-009-9100-2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10849-009-9100-2