Abstract
Michael Tye responds to the problem of higher-order vagueness for his trivalent semantics by maintaining that truth-value predicates are “vaguely vague”: it’s indeterminate, on his view, whether they have borderline cases and therefore indeterminate whether every sentence is true, false, or indefinite. Rosanna Keefe objects (1) that Tye’s argument for this claim tacitly assumes that every sentence is true, false, or indefinite, and (2) that the conclusion is any case not viable. I argue – contra (1) – that Tye’s argument needn’t make that assumption. A version of her objection is in fact better directed against other arguments Tye advances, though Tye can absorb this criticism without abandoning his position’s core. On the other hand, Keefe’s second objection does hit the mark: embracing ‘vaguely vague’ truth-value predicates undermines Tye’s ability to support validity claims needed to defend his position. To see this, however, we must develop Keefe’s remarks further than she does.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
R. Keefe, Theories of Vagueness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (2000).
Vagueness: A Reader. Cambridge: MIT Press (1997).
M. Sainsbury and T. Williamson, Sorites. In: B. Hale and C. Wright (eds.) A Companion to the Philosophy of Language. Oxford: Blackwell (1997) pp. 458-484
M. Tye, ‘Vague Objects’. Mind 99 (1990) 535-557
Tye, M.: 1994a, Sorites Paradoxes and the Semantics of Vagueness, Philosophical Perspectives 8: 189–206. Reprinted with omissions in Keefe and Smith (1997, 281–293).
M. Tye, ‘Why the Vague Need Not be Higher-Order Vague’. Mind 103 (1994b) 42-44
M. Tye, ‘Fuzzy Realism and the Problem of the Many’. Philosophical Studies 81 (1996) 215-225
M. Tye, ‘Vagueness and Reality’. Philosophical Topics 28 (2000) 195-209
T. Williamson, Vagueness. London: Routledge (1994).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gross, S. Trivalent Semantics and the Vaguely Vague. Synthese 156, 97–117 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-005-4542-9
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-005-4542-9