Abstract
I defend, to a certain extent, the traditional view that perceptual indiscriminability is non-transitive. The argument proceeds by considering important recent work by Benj Hellie: Hellie argues that colour perception represents ‘inexactly’, and that this results in violations of the transitivity of colour indiscriminability. I show that Hellie’s argument remains inconclusive, since he does not demonstrate conclusively that colour perception really does represent inexactly. My own argument for the non-transitivity of perceptual indiscriminability uses inexactness instead as one horn of a dilemma: the key idea is that there is a class of perceptual experiences which might plausibly be supposed either to represent inexactly or to represent exactly—but which demonstrate the non-transitivity of perceptual indiscriminability either way.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Chisholm R. (1942) The problem of the speckled hen. Mind 51: 368–373
De Clercq R., Horsten L. (2004) Perceptual indiscriminability: In defence of Wright’s proof. The Philosophical Quarterly 54: 439–444
Fara D. Graff (2001) Phenomenal continua and the sorites. Mind 110: 905–935. (Originally published under the name ‘Graff’).
Fodor J. (1990) A theory of content and other essays. The MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass
Hellie B. (2005) Noise and perceptual indiscriminability. Mind 114: 481–508
Jackson F., Pinkerton R. (1973) On an argument against sensory items. Mind 82: 269–272
McDowell J. (1994) Mind and world. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass
Raffman D. (2000) Is perceptual indiscriminability nontransitive?. Philosophical Topics 28: 153–175
Williamson T. (1990) Identity and discrimination. Blackwell, Oxford
Wright C. (1975) On the coherence of vague predicates. Synthese 30: 325–365
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pelling, C. Exactness, inexactness, and the non-transitivity of perceptual indiscriminability. Synthese 164, 289–312 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-007-9227-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-007-9227-0