Abstract
The illustrations of the late nineteenth-/twentieth-century scientist/artist Ernst Haeckel, as depicted in his book Art Forms in Nature (originally in German as Kunstformen der Natur, 1898–1904), have been at the intersection of art, biology, and mathematics for over a century. Haeckel’s images of radiolaria (microscopic protozoans described as amoeba in glass houses) have influenced various artists for over a century (glass artists Leopold and Rudolph Blaschka; sculptor Henry Moore; architects Rene Binet, Zaha Hadid, Antoni Gaudi, Chris Bosse and Frank Gehry; and designers–filmmakers Charles and Ray Eames). We focus on this history and extend the artistic, biological, and mathematical contributions of this interdisciplinary legacy by going beyond the 3D visual, topological, and geometric analyses of radiolaria to include the nanoscale with graph theory, spatial statistics, and computational geometry. We analyze multiple visualizations of radiolaria generated through Haeckel’s images, light microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, micro- and nanotomography, and three-dimensional computer rendering. Mathematical analyses are conducted using the image analysis package “Ka-me: A Voronoi Image Analyzer.” Further analyses utilize three-dimensional printing, laser etched crystalline glass art, and sculpture. Open sharing of three-dimensional nanotomography of radiolaria and other protozoa through MorphoSource enables new possibilities for artists, architects, paleontologists, structural morphologists, taxonomists, museum curators, and mathematical biologists. Distinctively, newer models of radiolaria fit into a larger context of productive interdisciplinary collaboration that continues Haeckel’s legacy that lay a foundation for new work in biomimetic design and additive manufacturing where artistic and scientific models mutually and robustly generate wonder, beauty, utility, curiosity, insight, environmentalism, theory, and questions.


















Source: Maartens (2017). b Marguerita Hagan (2018) had independently sculpted a three-layer test of a radiolarian and was surprised when Jungck sent her Fric’s image. The piece was one of many in her one-person show at the Philadelphia Area Fine Arts building








Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aita Y, Suzuki N, Ogane K, Sakai T, Lazarus D, Young J, Tanimura Y (2009) Haeckel Radiolaria Collection and the HMS Challenger Plankton Collection. Joint Haeckel and Ehrenberg Project: reexamination of the Haeckel and Ehrenberg microfossil collection as a historical and scientific legacy. Japan National Museum of Nature and Science, Monograph, Tokyo, vol 40, pp 35–45
Ball A, Abel R, Ambers J, Brierley L, Howard L (2011) Micro-computed tomography applied to museum collections. Microsc Microanal 17(S2):1794–1795
Bandyopadhyay A, Heer B (2018) Additive manufacturing of multi-material structures. Mater Sci Eng R Rep 129:1–16
Bergdoll B (2005) Les Esquisses Decoratives de Rene Binet’. Rene Binet 1866–1911, un architecte de la Belle Epoque100–09
Bergdoll B (2007) Of crystals, cells, and strata: natural history and debates on the form of a new architecture in the nineteenth century. Archit Hist 50:1–29
Bertini M, Verveniotou E, Lowe M, Giles Miller C (2016) Laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry investigation of late 19th Century Blaschka marine invertebrate glass models. J Archaeol Sci Rep 6:506–517
Bertol D (2015) The making of geometry. Procedia Technol 20:39–45
Binet R (1902) Esquisses décoratives. Librarie Centrale des Beaux-Arts, Paris
Bouligand Y (2004) The renewal of ideas about biomineralisations. CR Palevol 3(6–7):617–628
Brain RM (2009) Protoplasmania: Huxley, Haeckel and the vibratory organism in late nineteenth- century science and art. In: Larson B, Brauer F (eds) The art of evolution: darwin, darwinisms, and visual culture. Dartmouth College Press, Hanover, pp 92–123
Breidbach O (1998) Brief instructions for viewing Haeckel’s pictures. In: Haeckel E, Breidbach O, Hartman R, Eibl-Eibesfeldt I (eds) Art Forms in Nature: The Prints of Ernst Haeckel One Hundred Color Plates (monograph). Prestel, Munich, pp 9–18
Breidbach O (2002) The former synthesis—some remarks on the typological background of Haeckel’s ideas about evolution. Theory Biosci 121(3):280–296
Breidbach O (2003) The beauties and the beautiful—some considerations from the perspective of neuronal aesthetics. In: Voland E, Grammer K (eds) Evolutionary aesthetics. Springer, Berlin, pp 39–68
Breidbach O (2005) Art forms from the ocean: the radiolarian prints of Ernst Haeckel. Prestel, Munich
Brierley L (2009) Art Forms in nature examination and conservation of a blaschka glass model of the protozoan Aulosphaera elegantissima. Stud Conserv 54(4):255–267
Brill ER, Huber F (2016) Sea creatures in glass: the Blaschka Marine Animals at Harvard. Scala Arts Publishers, New York
Bueno E (2009) Algorithmic Form Generation of a Radiolarian Pavilion. Int J Archit Comput 7(4):677–688
Ceccato C (1999) The architect as toolmaker: computer-based generative design tools and methods. In: CAADRIA ‘99 (Proceedings of the fourth conference on computer aided architectural design research in asia/ISBN 7-5439-1233-3) Shanghai (China) 5–7 May 1999, pp 295–304
Cohen PS, Naginski E (2014) The return of nature: sustaining architecture in the face of sustainability. Routledge, Abingdon
Deane W (1894) The Ware Collection of Blaschka glass models of flowers at Harvard. Bot Gaz 19(4):144–148
Delue RZ (2010) A combined review of: Darwins Korallen: Frühe Evolutionsmodelle und die Tradition der Naturgeschichte; Endless Forms: Charles Darwin, Natural Science, and the Visual Arts; The Art of Evolution: Darwin, Darwinisms, and Visual Culture; and Darwin’s Pictures: Views of Evolutionary Theory, 1837–1874. Art Bull 92(4):386–391
Dolan JR, Le Peter J, Williams B, Evans DW, Roberts DJ, Thomas DN (2015) Art Forms from the Abyss: Ernst Haeckel’s Images from the HMS Challenger Expedition. Prestel, Munich, pp 121–122. ISBN 978-3791381411
Donofrio M (2016) Topology optimization and advanced manufacturing as means for the design of sustainable building components. Procedia Eng 145:638–645
Dyer R (2008) Learning through glass: the Blaschka marine models in North American post-secondary education. Hist Biol 20(1):29–37
Dyke GJ, Julia S (2005) The search for a ‘smoking gun’: No need for an alternative to the Linnean system of classification. In: Minelli A (ed) Animal Names, Istituto Veneto di Scienze, Lettere ed Arti, Venice, pp 49–65
Emmer M (2002) Mathland: from topology to virtual architecture. In: Emmer M (ed) Mathematics and culture II. Visual perfection: mathematics and creativity. Springer, Berlin, pp 65–78
Gamwell L (2003) Beyond the visible-microscopy, nature, and art. Science 299(5603):49–50
Gardner M (2001) The colossal book of mathematics: classical puzzles, paradoxes, and problems. In: Mathematical zoo, WW. North, New York, p 643 (Originally GARDNER, MARTIN. "MATHEMATICAL ZOO OF ASTOUNDING CRITTERS, IMAGINARY AND OTHERWISE." Scientific American 238, no. 6 (1978): 18.)
Gould SJ (1971) D’Arcy Thompson and the science of form. In: New literary history 2 (2) form and its alternatives (Winter), pp 229–258
Guex J, O’Dogherty L, Carter ES, Goričan Š, Bartolini A (2012) Geometrical transformations of selected Mesozoic radiolarians. Geobios 45(6):541–554
Hackethal S (2008) The Blaschka models of the Humboldt University of Berlin and their historical context. Hist Biol 20(1):19–28
Haeckel E (1862) Die Radiolarien (Rhizopoda Radiolaria). Eine Monographie. Atlas von Fünf und Dreissig Kupfertafeln. Verlag von Georg Reimer, Berlin. [Reprinted as: Haeckel E (2005) Art forms from the ocean: the Radiolarian atlas of 1862. Prestel Verlag, Munich and London]
Haeckel E (1866). Generelle Morphologie der Organis men. Allgemeine Grundzüge der organischen Formen-Wis senschaft, mechanisch begründet durch die von Charles Dar win reformierte Deszendenztheorie. Georg Reimer, (v. 1, Allgemeine Anatomie der Organismen; v. 2, All gemeine Entwicklungsgeschichte der Organism), Berlin
Haeckel E (1878). Das Protistenreich: Eine populäre Uebersicht über das Formengebiet der niedersten Lebewesen. Leipzig
Haeckel E (1887) Report on the Radiolaria collected by H.M.S. Challenger during the years 1873–1876. In: Report on the scientific results of the voyage of the H.M.S. Challenger, Zoology, 18, i–clxxxviii + 1–1803
Haeckel E (1888) Die Radiolarien. Eine Monographie, Berlin 1862–88, Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin – Preußischer Kulturbesitz, Abteilung historische Drucke
Haeckel E (1899) Kunstformen der Natur. Verlag des Bibliographischen Instituts, Leipzig
Haeckel E, Breidbach O, Hartman R, Eibl-Eibesfeldt I (1998) Art Forms in Nature: The Prints of Ernst Haeckel One Hundred Color Plates (monograph). Prestel, Munich
Hart G (2000) Reticulated geodesic constructions. Comput Gr 24:907–910
Hopwood N, Chadarevian S (2004) Dimensions of modelling. The third dimension of science, Models, pp 1–15
Hufnagel H, Jäger F, Wanlin N (2018) Une approche pluridisciplinaire d’Ernst Haeckel. Arts Savoirs 9:1–14
Kaniari A (2013) D’Arcy Thompson’s On Growth and Form and the Concept of Dynamic Form in Postwar Avant-Garde Art Theory. Interdisc Sci Rev 38(1):63–73
Khiripet N, Khantuwan W, Jungck JR (2012) Ka-me: a Voronoi image analyzer. Bioinformatics 28(13):1802–1804
Kimoto K, Osamu S, Harumasa K, Masahide W, Tomohisa I, Tomohiro I, Naomi H, Makio H (2013) Seasonal carbonate dissolution at the water column in the North Pacific: the evidence from the Micro-focus X-ray CT Technology. ESSAS Annual Science Meeting, Hakodate, Japan. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWm5q_gkuQ8 )
Knoll AH, Benjamin K (2015) Protistan Skeletons: a geologic history of evolution and constraint. In: Hamm C (ed) Evolution of lightweight structures: analyses and technical applications. Biologically-inspired systems, vol 6. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 1–16
Krausse E (1993) L’lnfluence de Ernst Haeckel sur l’Art nouveau. In: Clair J (ed) L’A.me au corps: Artset sciences 1793-1993. Gallimard/Electa, Paris
Krausse E (1995) Ernst Haeckel: Promorphologie und “evolutionistische” ästhetische Theorie - Konzept und Wirkung. In: Engels EM (Hrsg.) Die Rezeption von Evolutionstheorien im 19. Jahrhundert. Frankfurt/M. Suhrkamp Taschenbuch Wissenschaft; 1229, S 347–394
Krausse E (2001) Natur als Kunstform - Kunstformen der Natur. Ernst Haeckels Einfluß auf die Architekten des Jugendstils. In: K Buchholz, R Latocha, H Peckmann, K Wolbert (eds), Die Lebensreform. Entwürfe zu Neugestaltung von Leben und Kunst um 1900. Band 1. Darmstadt, Häusser, pp 283–290
Lazarus D (1986) Three-dimensional measurement of microfossil morphology. J Paleontol 60(4):960–964
Lazarus D (1994) Neptune: a marine micropaleontology database. Math Geol 26(7):817–832
Lazarus D (2005) A brief review of radiolarian research. Paläontologische Z 79(1):183–200
Lohmann GP (1983) Eigenshape analysis of microfossils: a general morphometric procedure for describing changes in shape. J Int Assoc Math Geol 15(6):659
Ludwig D (2013) Mediating objects: scientific and public functions of models in nineteenth-century biology. Hist Philos Life Sci 35(2):139–166
Maartens A (2017) On Growth and Form in context–an interview with Matthew Jarron. Development 144(23):4199–4202
Malcolm Shick J (2008) Toward an aesthetic marine biology. Art J 67(4):62–86
Mann S, Ozin GA (1996) Synthesis of inorganic materials with complex form. Nature 382(6589):313
Matsuoka A, Yoshino T, Kishimoto N, Ishida N, Kurihara T, Kimoto K, Matsuura S (2012) Exact number of pore frames and their configuration in Mesozoic radiolarian Pantanellium: an application of X-ray micro-CT and layered manufacturing technology to micropaleontology. Mar Micropaleontol 88–89:36–40
McCartney K (1988) SILICO: a computer program for the three-dimensional measurement of silicoflagellate skeletons. Comput Geosci 14(1):99–111
Meier A (2016) Art Nouveau’s Deep Sea Muse. (https://hyperallergic.com/242794/art-nouveaus-deep-sea-muse/)
Merkle A, Boone M, van Loo D (2018) In situ Dynamic X-ray Tomography in the Laboratory. Microsc Microanal 24:998–999
Mertins D (2017) Bioconstructivisms 1. In: Sabin JE, Jones PL (eds) LabStudio: design research between architecture and biology. Routledge, Abingdon, pp 3–16
Miller G, Lowe M (2008) The Natural History Museum Blaschka collections. Hist Biol 20:51–62
Moore R (1999) Appreciating natural beauty as natural. J Aesthet Educ 33(3):42–60
Morduhai-Boltovskoi DD (1936) Geometry of radiolaria. Univ, Fluchen. Zap. Rostov, p 8
Morgan M, Morrison M (1999) Models as Mediators. Cambridge University Press, Cambride
Nakaseko K (1959) On Superfamily Liosphaericae (Radiolaria) from Sediments in the Sea Near Antarctica, Part I. Spec Publ Seto Mar Biol Lab 1(2):1–20
O’Connor B (1996) Confocal laser scanning microscopy: a new technique for investigating and illustrating fossil Radiolaria. Micropaleontology 42(4):395–402
Oliver S, Kuperman A, Coombs N, Lough A, Ozin GA (1995) Lamellar aluminophosphates with surface patterns that mimic diatom and radiolarian microskeletons. Nature 378(6552):47
Ozin GA (1997) Morphogenesis of biomineral and morphosynthesis of biomimetic forms. Acc Chem Res 30(1):17–27
Ozin GA (2000) Panoscopic materials: synthesis over ‘all’length scales. Chem Commun 6:419–432
Posner JK, Jungck JR (2012) Polygonal biological patterns: Do two dimensional laws apply to three dimensional curved surfaces? Beloit Biol 32:1–12
Proctor R (2006) Architecture from the cell-soul: René Binet and Ernst Haeckel. J Archit 11(4):407–424
Proctor R, Breidbach O (2007) Rene Binet: from nature to form. Prestel, New York
Reiling H (1998) The Blaschkas’ glass animal models: origins of design. J Glass Stud 40:106–126
Richards RJ (2005) The foundation of Ernst Haeckel’s evolutionary project in morphology, aesthetics, and tragedy. In: Dessen P, Kemperiuk M (eds) The many faces of evolution in Europe, c. 1860–1914. Peters, Leuven
Richards RJ (2009) The tragic sense of Ernst Haeckel: his scientific and artistic struggles. In: Kort P, Hollein M, Frankfurt SK (eds) Darwin: art and the search for origins. Cologne, Wienand, pp 92–125
Richeson DS (2012) Euler's Gem: the polyhedron formula and the birth of topology. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Richardson MK, Jeffery JE (2002) Editorial: Haeckel and modern biology. Theory Biosci 121:247–251
Rindfleisch JP, Jungck JR (2010) Spatial point analysis: correlations between geometric and topological data from biological samples. Beloit Biol 30(7):1–75
Ritterbush PC (1968) The art of organic forms. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, DC, pp 64–65
Robert JR (2008) The tragic sense of life: Ernst Haeckel and the struggle over evolutionary thought. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Rossi-Wilcox SM, Whitehouse D (2007) Drawing upon nature: studies for the Blaschkas’ glass models. The Corning Museum of Glass, Corning
Sabin JE, Jones PL (2008) Nonlinear systems biology and design: surface design. In: International conference ACADIA proceedings
Sabin JE, Jones PL (eds) (2017) LabStudio: design research between architecture and biology. Routledge, Abingdon
Sakai T, Suzuki N, Ogane K, Lazarus D, Breidbach O, Bach T (2009) Haeckel’s Messina radiolarian collection housed in the Ernst-Haeckel-Haus. Natl Mus Nat Sci Monogr 40:47–54
Scarr G (2010) Simple geometry in complex organisms. J Bodyw Mov Ther 14(4):424–444
Shaw MD, Szczepanski JZ, Murray SF, Hodge S, Vink CJ (2017) Ideas made glass: Blaschka glass models at Canterbury Museum. Rec Canterb Mus 31:5–84
Shirley P, Wyman C (2017) Generating stratified random lines in a square. J Comput Gr Tech 6(2): 48–54. http://jcgt.org/published/0006/02/03/
Sigwart JD (2008) Crystal creatures: context for the Dublin Blaschka Congress. Hist Biol 20(1):1–10
Stafford BM (1991) Body criticism: imagining the unseen in enlightenment art, science, and medicine. MIT Press, Cambridge, p 84
Tsutsui H (2000) Digital characterization of silicoflagellate for numerical taxonomy. Geoinformatics 11(1):35–42
Tucker J (2010) Visualizing Darwinian evolution. Vic Stud 52(3):441–448
van Embden Andres MV, Turrin M (2009) “Structural DNA.” In: Southwest ACSA conference proceedings. http://www-personal.umich.edu/~pvbuelow/publication/pdf/ACSA_09-embden_turrin_pvb.pdf
Waddington CH (1951) The character of biological form. In: Whyte LL (ed) Aspects of form: a symposium on form in nature and art. Publishes, New York, Pelligrini and Cudahy, pp 43–52
Wagner RC, John RJ, Denis VL (2015) Sub-micrometer X-ray tomography of radiolarians: computer modeling and skeletonization. Microscopy Today 23(5):18–23
Wertheim M (2007) A field guide to hyperbolic space: an exploration of the intersection of higher geometry and feminine handicraft. Institute for Figuring, Los Angeles
Wertheim M (2009) Margaret Wertheim on the beautiful math of coral. TED talk. https://www.ted.com/talks/margaret_wertheim_crochets_the_coral_reef
Willmann R, Voss J (2017) The art and science of Ernst Haeckel. Taschen. (See many images from the book at https://www.theguardian.com/books/gallery/2017/nov/01/ernst-haeckel-the-art-of-evolution-in-pictures)
Wormer EJ (2018) Ernst Haeckel: Künstler und Wissenschaftler in Personalunion Fantastische Lebensformen. Orthop Rheuma 21(1):60–61
Yoshino T, Katsunori Kimoto N, Kishimoto AM, Kurihara T, Ishida N, Matsuura S (2009) A simple mathematical model for chamber arrangement of planktic foraminifera. FORMA 25:87–92
Yoshino T, Matsuoka A, Kurihara T, Naoto Ishida N, Kishimoto KK, Matsuura S (2012) Application of Voronoi tessellation of spherical surface to geometrical models for skeleton forms for spherical radiolaria. FORMA 27:45–53
Yoshino T, Matsuoka A, Kurihara T, Ishida N, Kishimoto N, Kimoto K, Matsuura S (2015) Polyhedron geometry of skeletons of Mesozoic radiolarian Pantanellium (Géométrie des polyèdres des squelettes des radiolaires mésozoïques du genre Pantanellium). Revue de micropaléontologie 58:51–56
Acknowledgements
Partial funding for this work was provided by grants to the first author by the Unidel Foundation of the University of Delaware and the Delaware Department of Education Math Science Partnership. Sabbatical support for the first author at the National Institute for Mathematical Biology Synthesis Center (NIMBioS) at the University of Tennessee and at the National Electronics and Computer Technology Center (NECTEC), Bangkok, Thailand, is greatly appreciated. This work would have been impossible except for the incredible assistance provided by Tim Leefeldt. Jordan Posner and J. P. Reindfleisch did some of the scanning electron microscopy and image analysis as student projects. Dr. Doug Boyer at Duke University was especially helpful in building MorpoSource data files for the 3D nanotomography data and 3D print files. Scanner time on a Zeiss XRadia 819 Ultra machine was generously provided by the Zeiss Facility at Thornwood, New York.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This article is a contribution to the Special Issue Ernst Haeckel (1834–1919): The German Darwin and his impact on modern biology—Guest Editors: U. Hossfeld, G. S. Levit, U. Kutschera.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Jungck, J.R., Wagner, R., van Loo, D. et al. Art Forms in Nature: radiolaria from Haeckel and Blaschka to 3D nanotomography, quantitative image analysis, evolution, and contemporary art. Theory Biosci. 138, 159–187 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12064-019-00289-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12064-019-00289-z