Abstract
In situations where robots share their workspace with humans, and where physical human-robot interaction is possible or even necessary, safety is of paramount importance. This paper presents a study of the safety of a lightweight robot actuated by pneumatic muscles. Due to its low weight, it has excellent hardware safety characteristics. In spite of this, it is shown that the system can be unsafe when under PID control. It is also shown that safety can be greatly increased by using Proxy-Based Sliding Mode Control (PSMC). The role of passive compliance in safety is also investigated. It is argued that passive compliance can have positive as well as negative effects on robot safety, depending on the situation.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Albu-Schäffer A, Ott C, Hirzinger G (2007) A unified passivity-based control framework for position, torque and impedance control of flexible joint robots. Int J Robot Res 26(1):23–39
Albu-Schäffer A, Eiberger O, Grebenstein M, Haddadin S, Ott C, Wimböck T, Wolf S, Hirzinger G (2008) Soft robotics. IEEE Robot Autom Mag 15(3):20–30
Avivzienis A, Laprie JC, Randell B, Landwehr C (2004) Basic concepts and taxonomy of dependable and secure computing. IEEE Trans Dependable Secure Comput 1(1):11–33
Bicchi A, Tonietti G (2004) Fast and soft arm tactics: dealing with the safety-performance trade-off in robot arms design and control. IEEE Robot Autom Mag 11(2):22–33
Bicchi A, Rizzini SL, Tonietti G (2001) Compliant design for intrinsic safety: general issues and preliminary design. In: Proceedings of the 2001 IEEE/RSJ international conference on intelligent robots and systems, Maui, HI, vol 4, pp 1864–1869
Bicchi A, Tonietti G, Bavaro M, Piccigallo M (2003) Variable stiffness actuators for fast and safe motion control. In: Siciliano B, Khatib O, Groen F (eds) Proceedings of the international symposium on robotics research, springer tracts in advanced robotics (STAR). Springer, Berlin
Bicchi A, Peshkin MA, Colgate JE (2008) Safety for physical human-robot interaction. In: Springer handbook of robotics. Springer, Berlin, pp 1335–1348
Buerger SP, Hogan N (2007) Complementary stability and loop shaping for improved human-robot interaction. IEEE Trans Robot 23(2):232–244
Chou CP, Hannaford B (1996) Measurement and modelling of McKibben pneumatic artificial muscles. IEEE Trans Robot Autom 12(1):90–102
Daerden F, Lefeber D (2001) The concept and design of pleated pneumatic artificial muscles. Int J Fluid Power 2(3):41–50
Daerden F, Lefeber D (2002) Pneumatic artificial muscles: actuators for robotics and automation. Eur J Mech Environ Eng 47(1):10–21
De Luca A (2000) Feedforward/feedback laws for the control of flexible robots. In: Proceedings of the IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, pp 233–240
De Luca A, Book W (2008) Robots with flexible elements. In: Springer handbook of robotics. Springer, Berlin, pp 287–319
De Santis A, Siciliano B, De Luca A, Bicchi A (2008) An atlas of physical human-robot interaction. Mech Mach Theory 43(3):253–270
Dhillon BS, Fashandi ARM, Liu KL (2002) Robot systems reliability and safety: a review. J Qual Maint Eng 8(3):170–212
Diolaiti N, Melchiorri C, Stramigioli S (2005) Contact impedance estimation for robotic systems. IEEE Trans Robot 21(5):925–935
EuroNCAP (2008) European new car assessment programme—assessment protocol and biomechanical limits
Filippini R, Sen S, Bicchi A (2008) Toward soft robots you can depend on. IEEE Rob Autom Mag 15(3):31–41
Formica D, Zollo L, Guglielmelli E (2006) Torque-dependent compliance control in the joint space for robot-mediated motor therapy. J Dyn Syst Meas Control 128:152–158
Gilardi G, Sharf I (2002) Literature survey of contact dynamics modelling. Mech Mach Theory 37:1213–1239
Haddadin S, Albu-Schäffer A, Hirzinger G (2007) Approaching Asimov’s 1st law: the role of the robot’s weight class. In: Robotics: science and systems conference (RSS2007), Atlanta, USA
Haddadin S, Albu-Schäffer A, Hirzinger G (2007) Safety evaluation of physical human-robot interaction via crash-testing. In: Robotics: science and systems conference (RSS2007), Atlanta, USA
Haddadin S, Albu-Schäffer A, De Luca A, Hirzinger G (2008) Collision detection & reaction: a contribution to safe physical human-robot interaction. In: Proceedings of the 2008 IEEE/RSJ international conference on intelligent robots and systems, Nice, France, pp 3356–3363
Haddadin S, Albu-Schäffer A, Hirzinger G (2008) The role of the robot mass and velocity in physical human-robot interaction, part I non-constrained blunt impacts. In: Proceedings of the 2008 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, Pasadena, CA, pp 1331–1338
Haddadin S, Albu-Schäffer A, Hirzinger G (2008) The role of the robot mass and velocity in physical human-robot interaction, part II: constrained blunt impacts. In: Proceedings of the 2008 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, Pasadena, CA, pp 1339–1345
Hägele M, Nilsson K, Pires JN (2008) Industrial robotics. In: Springer handbook of robotics. Springer, Berlin, pp 963–986
Heinzmann J, Zelinsky A (2003) Quantitative safety guarantees for physical human-robot interaction. Int J Robot Res 22(7–8):479–504
Hirzinger G, Sporer N, Albu-Shäffer A, Hähnle M, Krenn R, Pascucci A, Schedl M (2002) DLR’s torque-controlled light weight robot III-are we reaching the technological limits now? In: Proceedings of the 2002 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, Washington, DC, pp 1710–1716
Hogan N (1985) Impedance control: an approach to manipulation, parts I–III. J Dyn Syst Meas Control 107:1–24
Hung JY, Gao W, Hung JC (1993) Variable structure control: a survey. IEEE Trans Ind Electron 40(1):2–22
Hunt KH, Crossley FRE (1975) Coefficient of restitution interpreted as damping in vibroimpact. ASME J Appl Mech, pp 440–445
Ikuta K, Ishii H, Nokata M (2003) Safety evaluation method of design and control for human-care robots. Int J Robot Res 22(5):281–297
Inoue K (1987) Rubbertuators and applications for robots. In: Proceedings of the 4th international symposium on robotic research, pp 57–63
Kikuuwe R, Fujimoto H (2006) Proxy-based sliding mode control for accurate and safe position control. In: Proceedings of the 2006 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, pp 25–30
Kulić D, Croft EA (2006) Real-time safety for human-robot interaction. Robot Auton Syst 54(1):1–12
Laprie JC (1985) Dependable computing and fault tolerance: concepts and terminology. In: Proceedings of the 15th IEEE international symposium on fault-tolerant computing, pp 2–11
Lim Ho, Tanie K (2000) Human safety mechanisms of human-friendly robots: passive viscoelastic trunk and passively movable base. Int J Robot Res 19(4):307–335
Oberer S, Schraft RD (2007) Robot-dummy crash tests for robot safety assessment. In: 2007 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, Rome, Italy, pp 2934–2939
Pervez A, Ryu J (2008) Safe physical human robot interaction—past, present and future. J Mech Sci Technol 22:469–483
Pratt GA, Williamson MM (1995) Series elastic actuators. In: IEEE international workshop on intelligent robots and systems (IROS 1995), Pittsburgh, USA, pp 399–406
Salisbury K, Townsend W, Eberman B, DiPietro D (1988) Preliminary design of a whole-arm manipulation system (WAMS). In: Proceedings of the 1988 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, Philadelphia, PA, vol 1, pp 254–260
Sardellitti I, Park J, Shin D, Khatib O (2007) Air muscle controller design in the distributed macro-mini (DM2) actuation approach. In: Proceedings of the 2007 IEEE/RSJ international conference on intelligent robots and systems, pp 1822–1827
Schulte HF (1961) The characteristics of the McKibben artificial muscle. In: The application of external power in prosthetics and orthotics, publication 874, National Academy of Sciences, National Research Council, Washington, pp 94–115
Shin D, Sardellitti I, Khatib O (2008) A hybrid actuation approach for human-friendly robot design. In: Proceedings of the 2008 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, Pasadena, CA, pp 1747–1752
Slotine JJ, Li W (1991) Applied nonlinear control. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River
Spong MW (1987) Modeling and control of elastic joint robots. ASME J Dyn Syst Meas Control 109:310–319
Tomei P (1991) A simple PD controller for robots with elastic joints. IEEE Trans Autom Control 36(10):1208–1213
Van Damme M, Daerden F, Lefeber D (2005) A pneumatic manipulator used in direct contact with an operator. In: Proceedings of the 2005 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, Barcelona, Spain, pp 4505–4510
Van Damme M, Vanderborght B, Van Ham R, Verrelst B, Daerden F, Lefeber D (2007) Proxy-based sliding mode control of a manipulator actuated by pleated pneumatic artificial muscles. In: Proceedings of the 2007 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, pp 4355–4360
Van Ham R, Sugar TG, Vanderborght B, Hollander KW, Lefeber D (2009) Compliant actuator designs—review of actuators with passive adjustable compliance/controllable stiffness for robotic applications. IEEE Robot Autom Mag 16(3):81–94
Vanderborght B, Verrelst B, Van Ham R, Van Damme M, Lefeber D, Meira Y, Duran B, Beyl P (2006) Exploiting natural dynamics to reduce energy consumption by controlling the compliance of soft actuators. Int J Robot Res 25(4):343–358
Vanderborght B, Tsagarakis N, Semini C, Van Ham R, Caldwell D (2009) MACCEPA 2.0: compliant actuator used for energy efficient hopping robot CHOBINO. In: Proceedings of the 2009 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, Kobe, Japan, pp 544–549
Verrelst B, Van Ham R, Vanderborght B, Lefeber D, Daerden F, Van Damme M (2006) Second generation pleated pneumatic artificial muscle and its robotic applications. Adv Robot 20(7):783–805
Versace J (1971) A review of the severity index. In: Proceedings 15th stapp car crash conference, New York
Wassink M, Stramigioli S (2007) Towards a novel safety norm for domestic robotics. In: Proceedings of the 2007 IEEE/RSJ international conference on intelligent robots and systems, San Diego, CA, pp 3354–3359
Willinger R, Kang HS, Diaw B (1999) Three-dimensional human head finite-element model validation against two experimental impacts. Ann Biomed Eng 27:403–410
Wolf S, Hirzinger G (2008) A new variable stiffness design: matching requirements of the next robot generation. In: Proceedings of the 2008 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, Pasadena, CA, pp 1741–1746
Yamada Y, Hirasawa Y, Huang S, Umetani Y, Suita K (1997) Human-robot contact in the safeguarding space. IEEE/ASME Trans Mech 2(4):230–236
Zinn M, Khatib O, Roth B, Salisbury JK (2002) A new actuation approach for human friendly robot design. In: Proceedings of international symposium on experimental robotics, Santa Angelo d’Ischia, Italy
Zinn M, Khatib O, Roth B, Salisbury JK (2004) Playing it safe. IEEE Robot Autom Mag 11(2):12–21
Zinn M, Roth B, Khatib O, Salisbury JK (2004) A new actuation approach for human friendly robot design. Int J Robot Res 23(4–5):379–398
Zollo L, Siciliano B, Laschi C, Teti G, Dario P (2003) An experimental study on compliance control for a redundant personal robot arm. Robot Auton Syst 44:101–129
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This work has been funded by the European Commision’s 7th Framework Program as part of the VIACTORS project (grant No. 231554).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Van Damme, M., Beyl, P., Vanderborght, B. et al. The Safety of a Robot Actuated by Pneumatic Muscles—A Case Study. Int J of Soc Robotics 2, 289–303 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12369-009-0042-2
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12369-009-0042-2