Abstract
This article gives an overview of the current state of research in the field of off-road robotics. It focuses on techniques used in the areas of perception, environment representation, as well as navigation, and introduces different types of robot control systems. A presentation of different applications is given along with an outlook on future developments.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Notes
pmd: Photonic Mixer Device.
hdrc: High Dynamic Range cmos.
References
Albus J (1987) NASA/NBS standard reference model for telerobot control system architecture (NASREM). Tech. rep., NIST
Albus J (2002) A reference model architecture for intelligent unmanned ground vehicles. In: Proc SPIE 16th annual international symposium on aerospace/defense sensing, simulation and controls. CiteSeer, pp 303–310
Andersen J, Blas M, Ravn O, Andersen N, Blanke M (2006) Traversable terrain classification for outdoor autonomous robots using single 2D laser scans. Integr Comput-Aided Eng 13(3):223–232
Arkin R (1998) Behaviour-based robotics. MIT Press, Cambridge
Armbrust C, Braun T, Föhst T, Proetzsch M, Renner A, Schäfer H, Berns K (2010) RAVON—the robust autonomous vehicle for off-road navigation. In: Baudoin Y, Habib MK (eds) Using robots in hazardous environments: Landmine detection, de-mining and other applications, chap. RAVON—the robust autonomous vehicle for off-road navigation. Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge
Armbrust C, Schäfer H, Berns K (2009) Using passages to support off-road robot navigation. In: Proc ICINCO 2009, INSTICC, Milan, Italy, pp 189–194
Balch T, Arkin R (1998) Behavior-based formation control for multirobot teams. IEEE Trans Robot Autom 14(6):926–939
Baudoin Y, Habib MK (eds) (2010) Using robots in hazardous environments: Landmine detection, de-mining and other applications. Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge
Bay H, Ess A, Tuytelaars T, Gool LV (2008) SURF: Speeded up robust features. Comput Vis Image Underst 110(3):346–359
Billingsley J, Visala A, Dunn M (2008) Robotics in agriculture and forestry. In: Siciliano B, Khatib O (eds) Springer handbook of robotics, Chap 46. Springer, Berlin, pp 1065–1077
Blas M, Agrawal M, Sundaresan A, Konolige K (2008) Fast color/texture segmentation for outdoor robots. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2008. IEEE Press, New York, pp 4078–4085.
Bonnafous D, Lacroix S, Siméon T (2001) Motion generation for a rover on rough terrain. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2001
Boots B (2008) Inferring depth from single images in natural scenes
Bosse M, Newman P, Leonard J, Soika M, Feiten W, Teller S (2003) An atlas framework for scalable mapping. In: Proc IEEE ICRA 2003, vol 2, pp 1899–1906
Braun T (2009) Cost-efficient global robot navigation in rugged off-road terrain. RRLab dissertations. Verlag Dr. Hut
Braun T, Schäfer H, Berns K (2009) Topological large-scale off-road navigation and exploration—RAVON at the European Land Robot Trial 2008. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2009. IEEE Press, St. Louis, pp 4387–4392
Brenneke C, Wulf O, Wagner B (2003) Using 3D laser range data for slam in outdoor environments. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2003, vol 1. IEEE Press, New York, pp 188–193
Brooks C, Iagnemma K (2005) Vibration-based terrain classification for planetary exploration rovers. IEEE Trans Robot 21(6):1185–1191
Brooks R (1991) Intelligence without reason. Artificial intelligence: critical concepts 3
Buttgen B, Seitz P (2008) Robust optical time-of-flight range imaging based on smart pixel structures. IEEE Trans Circuits Syst I, Regul Pap 55(6):1512–1525
Cariou C, Lenain R, Thuilot B, Berducat M (2009) Automatic guidance of a four-wheel-steering mobile robot for accurate field operations. J Field Robot—Special Issue: Agricultural Robot 26(6–7):504–518
Darabiha A, Rose J, MacLean W (2003) Video-rate stereo depth measurement on programmable hardware
Debenest P, Fukushima EF, Hirose S (2003) Proposal for automation of humanitarian demining with buggy robots. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2003
Dupont E, Moore C, Collins E, Coyle E (2008) Frequency response method for terrain classification in autonomous ground vehicles. Auton Robots 24(4):337–347
Eck D, Stahl M, Schilling K (2007) The small outdoor rover merlin and its assistance system for tele-operations. In: 6th int conf field and service robotics, Chamonix, France, pp 277–286
Egger A (1997) Regensensor. Europäisches Patent EP 0 856 44 B1
Everson J, Kopala E, Lazofson L, Choe H, Pomerleau D (1995) Sensor performance and weather effects modeling for Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) applications. In: Proc of SPIE, vol 2344, p 118
Ferguson D, Stentz A (2006) Using interpolation to improve path planning: The field d ∗ algorithm. J Field Robot 23(1):79–101
Ferguson IA (1992) Touringmachines: autonomous agents with attitudes. IEEE Comput 25(5):51–55
Forstmann S, Kanou Y, Ohya J, Thuering S, Schmitt A (2005) Real-time stereo by using dynamic programming. In: Computer vision and pattern recognition workshop, 2004. CVPRW’04. Conf. IEEE Press, New York, p 29
Frese U (ed) (2010) Simultaneous localization and mapping. KI – Künstliche Intelligenz, vol 24. Springer, Berlin
Gat E (1998) Three-layer architectures. In: Kortenkamp D, Bonasso R, Murphy R (eds) Artificial intelligence and mobile robots. AAAI Press/MIT Press, Melno Park, pp 195–210
Ghurchian R, Hashino S, Nakano E (2004) A fast forest road segmentation for real-time robot self-navigation. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2004
Gong M, Yang R (2005) Image-gradient-guided real-time stereo on graphics hardware. In: 5th int conf 3D digital imaging and modeling. IEEE Press, New York, pp 548–555
Hadsell R, Sermanet P, Ben J, Erkan A, Han J, Flepp B, Muller U, LeCun Y (2007) Online learning for offroad robots: Using spatial label propagation to learn long-range traversability. In: Proc robotics: science and systems. CiteSeer
Halatci I, Brooks C, Iagnemma K (2007) Terrain classification and classifier fusion for planetary exploration rovers. In: IEEE Aerospace Conf 2007. IEEE Press, New York, pp 1–11
Hautière N, Labayrade R, Aubert D (2005) Detection of visibility conditions through use of onboard cameras. In: Proc IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium 2005. IEEE Press, New York, pp 193–198
Hautière N, Labayrade R, Aubert D (2006) Estimation of the visibility distance by stereovision: a generic approach. IEICE Trans Inf Syst 89(7):2084
Hellström T, Lärkeryd P, Nordfjell T, Ringdahl O (2009) Autonomous forest vehicles: Historic, envisioned, and state-of-the-art. Int J For Eng 20(1):31–38
Helmick DM, Cheng Y, Clouse DS, Bajracharya M, Matthies LH, Roumeliotis SI (2005) Slip compensation for a mars rover. In: Proc. IEEE IROS 2005, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, pp 2806–2813
Hilbert K, Brunnett G (2005) A hybrid LOD based rendering approach for dynamic scenes. In: Computer graphics international, 2004 Proc. IEEE Press, New York, pp 274–277
Himmelsbach M, von Hundelshausen F, Lüttel T, Manz M, Müller A, Schneider S, Wünsche HJ (2009) Team mucar-3 at c-elrob 2009. Tech. rep. In: Proc of workshop on field robotics, civilian European robot trial 2009. Oulu, Finland. ISBN 978-951-42-9176-0
Hoiem D, Efros A, Hebert M (2005) Geometric context from a single image. In: IEEE int conf computer vision, vol 1. IEEE Press, New York, pp 654–661
Hong TH, Rasmussen C, Chang T, Shneier M (2002) Fusing ladar and color image information for mobile robot feature detection and tracking. In: Gini M, Shen WM, Torras C, Yuasa H (eds) 7th int conf intelligent autonomous systems. IOS Press, Amsterdam, pp 124–133
Horn J (2006) Zweidimensionale Geschwindigkeitsmessung texturierter Oberflächen mit flächenhaften bildgebenden Sensoren. Schriftenreihe. Institut für Mess-und Regelungstechnik, Universität Karlsruhe (TH); 6
von Hundelshausen F, Himmelsbach M, Hecker F, Müller A, Wünsche HJ (2008) Driving with tentacles: Integral structures for sensing and motion. J Field Robot 25(9):640–673
Iagnemma K, Brooks C, Dubowsky S (2004) Visual, tactile, and vibration-based terrain analysis for planetary rovers. In: Proc IEEE aerospace conf 2004, vol 2. IEEE Press, New York, pp 841–848
Iagnemma K, Dubowsky S (2002) Terrain estimation for high-speed rough-terrain autonomous vehicle navigation. In: Proc SPIE conf unmanned ground vehicle technology IV, vol 4715
Ingrand F, Lacroix S, Lemai-Chenevier S, Py F (2007) Decisional autonomy of planetary rovers. J Field Robot 24(7):559–580
Kelly A, Stentz A (1998) Rough terrain autonomous mobility—part 2: An active vision, predictive control approach. In: Autonomous robots, vol 5, pp 163–198
Kim D, Sun J, Oh S, Rehg J, Bobick A (2006) Traversability classification using unsupervised on-line visual learning for outdoor robot navigation. In: Proc IEEE ICRA 2006. IEEE, New York, pp 518–525
Konolige K, Agrawal M, Blas MR, Bolles RC, Gerkey B, Solà J, Sundaresan A (2009) Mapping, navigation, and learning for off-road traversal. J Field Robot—Special Issue on LAGR Program, Part I 26(1):88–113
Kratz L, Nishino K (2010) Factorizing scene albedo and depth from a single foggy image. In: 12th IEEE int conf computer vision. IEEE Press, New York, pp 1701–1708
Krause T, Protzel P (2005) Einfaches Steuerungskonzept für mobile Roboter in dynamischen unstrukturierten Umgebungen. In: Autonome mobile systeme 2005
Krebs A, Risch F, Thueer T, Maye J, Pradalier C, Siegwart R (2010) Rover control based on an optimal torque distribution—application to 6 motorized wheels passive rover. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2010, Taipei, Taiwan, pp 4372–4377
Kuhnert KD (2008) Software architecture of the autonomous mobile outdoor robot AMOR. In: Proc IEEE intelligent vehicles symposium 2008. Eindhoven, The Netherlands, pp 889–894
Kuhnert KD, Seemann W (2007) Design and realisation of the highly modular and robust autonomous mobile outdoor robot AMOR. In: Proc 13th IASTED int conf robotics and applications. ACTA Press, Würzburg, pp 464–469
Kuhnert L, Kuhnert KD (2011) Sensor-fusion based real-time 3D outdoor scene reconstruction and analysis on a moving mobile outdoor robot. Künstl Intell, doi:10.1007/s13218-011-0093-z
Kurihata H, Takahashi T, Mekada Y, Ide I, Murase H, Tamatsu Y, Miyahara T (2006) Raindrop detection from in-vehicle video camera images for rainfall judgment. In: Int conf innovative computing, information and control 2006, vol 2. IEEE Press, New York, pp 544–547
Langer M, Zucker S (1994) Shape-from-shading on a cloudy day. J Opt Soc Am A 11(2):467–478
Langerwisch M, Reimer M, Hentschel M, Wagner B (2010) Control of a semi-autonomous UGV using lossy low-bandwidth communication. In: Proc 2nd IFAC symposium on telematics applications. IFAC, Politehnica University, Timisoara, Romania. Invited paper
Lowe DG (2004) Distinctive image features from scale invariant keypoints. Int J Comput Vis 60(2):91–110
Macedo J, Manduchi R, Matthies L (2001) Ladar-based discrimination of grass from obstacles for autonomous navigation. In: Experimental robotics VII, pp 111–120
Marra M, Dunlay R, Mathis D (1989) Terrain classification using texture for the ALV. In: Mobile robots III, pp 64–70
Matarić MJ (1997) Behavior-based control: Examples from navigation, learning, and group behavior. J Exp Theor Artif Intell—Special Issue on Software Architectures for Physical Agents 9(2–3):323–336
Matarić MJ (2002) Situated robotics, invited contribution to the encyclopedia of cognitive science, Nature Publishing Group, Macmillan Reference Limited
Montemerlo M, Thrun S (2004) A multi-resolution pyramid for outdoor robot terrain perception. In: Proc national conf artificial intelligence. AAAI Press/MIT Press, Menlo Park, Cambridge, pp 464–469
Mori K, Kato T, Takahashi T, Ide I, Murase H, Miyahara T, Tamatsu Y (2006) Visibility estimation in foggy conditions by in-vehicle camera and radar. In: Int conf innovative computing, information and control 2006, vol 2. IEEE Press, New York, pp 548–551
Müller J, Pischel M (1993) The agent architecture interrap: Concept and application. Tech. rep., DFKI Saarbrücken
Murphy RR, Tadokoro S, Nardi D, Jacoff A, Fiorini P, Choset H, Erkmen AM (2008) Search and rescue robotics. In: Siciliano B, Khatib O (eds) Springer handbook of robotics. Springer, Berlin, pp 1151–1173
Narasimhan S, Nayar S (2003) Contrast restoration of weather degraded images. In: IEEE transactions on pattern analysis and machine intelligence, pp 713–724
Nedović V, Smeulders A, Redert A, Geusebroek J (2008) Depth estimation via stage classification. In: 3DTV conference: the true vision: capture, transmission and display of 3D video: 2008. IEEE Press, New York, pp 77–80
Nguyen DV, Kuhnert L, Ax M, Kuhnert KD (2010) Combining distance and modulation information for detecting pedestrians in outdoor environment using a PMD camera. In: Proc 11th IASTED int conf computer graphics and imaging, vol 679, pp 020–163
Nüchter A (2009) 3D robotic mapping: the simultaneous localization and mapping problem with six degrees of freedom. Springer, Berlin
Pirjanian P (1999) Behaviour coordination mechanisms—state-of-the-art. Tech. rep. IRIS-99-375, Institute for robotics and intelligent systems, school of engineering, University of Southern California
Poppinga J, Birk A, Pathak K (2008) Hough based terrain classification for realtime detection of drivable ground. J Field Robot 25(1–2):67–88
Potetz B, Lee T (2003) Statistical correlations between two-dimensional images and three-dimensional structures in natural scenes. J Opt Soc Am A 20(7):1292–1303
Proetzsch M (2010) Development process for complex behavior-based robot control systems. RRLab Dissertations. Verlag Dr. Hut
Ranganathan A, Koenig S (2003) A reactive robot architecture with planning on demand. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2003, Las Vegas, Nevada, USA, pp 1462–1468
Rasmussen C, Lu Y, Kocamaz M (2009) Appearance contrast for fast, robust trail-following. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2009. IEEE Press, Piscataway, pp 3505–3512
Rovira-Más F, Han S, Wei J, Reid JF (2007) Autonomous guidance of a corn harvester using stereo vision. Agricultural Engineering International: the CIGR Ejournal IX
Saxena A, Chung S, Ng A (2006) Learning depth from single monocular images. Adv Neural Inf Process Syst 18:1161–1168
Saxena A, Sun M, Ng A (2009) Make 3d: learning 3D scene structure from a single still image. IEEE Trans Pattern Anal Mach Intell 35(5):824–840
Schäfer BH, Proetzsch M, Berns K (2007) Obstacle detection in mobile outdoor robots—a short-term memory for the mobile outdoor platform ravon. In: Proc. ICINCO 2007, Angers, France, pp 141–148
Schäfer H (2011) Control system design schemata and their application in off-road robotics. PhD thesis, University of Kaiserslautern. To be published
Schäfer H, Hach A, Proetzsch M, Berns K (2008) 3D obstacle detection and avoidance in vegetated off-road terrain. In: Proc IEEE ICRA 2008, Pasadena, USA, pp 923–928
Scharstein D, Szeliski R (2002) A taxonomy and evaluation of dense two-frame stereo correspondence algorithms. Tech. rep. Available on http://vision.middlebury.edu/stereo/
Schenker P, Huntsberger T, Pirjanian P, Dubowsky S, Iagnemma K, Sujan V (2003) Rovers for intelligent, agile traverse of challenging terrain. In: Int conf advanced robotics
Schmidt D, Proetzsch M, Berns K (2010) Simulation and control of an autonomous bucket excavator for landscaping tasks. In: Proc IEEE ICRA 2010, Anchorage, Alaska, USA, pp 5108–5113
Schneider FE, Röhling T, Brüggemann B, Wildermuth D (2010) CBRNE reconnaissance with an unmanned vehicle—a semi-autonomous approach. In: Proc 2nd IFAC symposium on telematics applications. IFAC, Politehnica University, Timisoara, Romania. Invited paper
Schneider FE, Wildermuth D, Brüggemann B, Röhling T (2010) European land robot trial (elrob), towards a realistic benchmark for outdoor robotics. In: Proc 1st international conference on robotics in education, RiE2010. FEI STU, Slovakia, pp 65–70
Schwarte R, Xu Z, Heinol H, Olk J, Klein R, Buxbaum B, Fischer H, Schulte J (1997) New electro-optical mixing and correlating sensor: facilities and applications of the photonic mixer device (PMD). In: Proc of SPIE, vol 3100, p 245
Schwendner J, Grimminger F, Bartsch S, Kaupisch T, Yüksel M, Bresser A, Akpo JB, Dieterle A, Schmidt S, Seydel M, Kirchner F (2009) CESAR: A lunar crater exploration and sample return robot. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2009, St. Louis, MO, United States of America, pp 3355–3360
Seemann W, Kuhnert K (2007) Localisation for an outdoor robot by optically measuring the ground movement. In: Proc 13th IASTED int conf robotics and applications. ACTA Press, Calgary, pp 113–118
Sermanet P, Hadsell R, Scoffier M, Grimes M, Ben J, Erkan A, Crudele C, Miller U, LeCun Y (2009) A multirange architecture for collision-free off-road robot navigation. J Field Robot—Special Issue on LAGR Program, Part I 26(1):52–87
Stentz A, Hebert M (1995) A complete navigation system for goal acquisition in unknown environments. In: Proc IEEE IROS 1995, vol 1, pp 425–432
Thrun S, Montemerlo M, Dahlkamp H, Stavens D, Aron A, Diebel J, Fong P, Gale J, Halpenny M, Hoffmann G et al. (2007) Stanley: The robot that won the DARPA Grand Challenge. In: The 2005 DARPA Grand Challenge, pp 1–43
Thrun S, Montemerlo M, Dahlkamp H, Stavens D, Aron A, Diebel J, Fong P, Gale J, Halpenny M, Hoffmann G, Lau K, Oakley C, Palatucci M, Pratt V (2006) Pasc: Stanley: The robot that won the darpa grand challenge. J Field Robot 23(9):661–692
Torralba A, Oliva A (2002) Depth estimation from image structure. IEEE Trans Pattern Anal Mach Intell 24(9):1226–1238
Urmson C, Ragusa C, Ray D, Anhalt J, Bartz D, Galatali T, Gutierrez A, Johnston J, Harbaugh S, Kato HY, Messner W, Miller N, Peterson K, Smith B, Snider J, Spiker S, Ziglar J, Whittaker WR, Clark M, Koon P, Mosher A, Struble J (2006) A robust approach to high-speed navigation for unrehearsed desert terrain. J Field Robot 23(8):467–508
Vandapel N, Huber D, Kapuria A, Hebert M (2004) Natural terrain classification using 3-d ladar data. In: Proc IEEE ICRA 2004, vol 5. IEEE, New York, pp 5117–5122
Wang L, Liao M, Gong M, Yang R, Nister D (2006) High-quality real-time stereo using adaptive cost aggregation and dynamic programming
Wellington C, Stentz A (2004) Online adaptive rough-terrain navigation in vegetation. In: Proc IEEE ICRA 2004, vol 1, pp 96–101
Wooden D, Powers M, MacKenzie D, Balch T, Egerstedt M (2007) Control-driven mapping and planning. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2007. San Diego, CA, USA, pp 3056–3061
Wulf O, Wagner B (2003) Fast 3D scanning methods for laser measurement systems. In: 14th int conf control systems and computer science, Bucharest
Yang Q, Wang L, Yang R, Wang S, Liao M, Nister D (2006) Real-time global stereo matching using hierarchical belief propagation. In: The British machine vision conference, pp 989–998
Zhang Y, Schervish M, Acar EU, Choset H (2001) Probabilistic methods for robotic landmine search. In: Proc IEEE IROS 2001
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Berns, K., Kuhnert, KD. & Armbrust, C. Off-road Robotics—An Overview. Künstl Intell 25, 109–116 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13218-011-0100-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13218-011-0100-4