Abstract
The paper presents a simple exercise of application of cluster analysis to the set of voting data for the members of Polish Parliament of the previous term, which started in 1993. Each MP is characterized by the vector containing the specification of MP's behaviour during individual votings, distinguishing the following categories: “For”, “Against”, “Abstained”, “Not voted”, and “Absent”. The distances between the “MP descriptions” containing the thus defined categories of behaviour during votings (forming the matrix of dimensions: number of MPs × number of votings) constitute the basis for the analytic procedure based upon clustering. We are looking for the clusters of similar MP descriptions which are, simultaneously, possibly different between clusters.
The analysis performed does not account for the membership of the MPs in the political groupings (parties and alliances) within the parliament, and one of the main goals of the analysis is just to identify the degree of agreement between the results of the cluster analysis and the membership in such groupings. This is done after the procedure of clustering has been performed. Another aspect being of interest in the analysis is dependence upon (sensitivity to) the parametric definitions of distances with respect to the categories adopted in the description of voting (e.g., “is absence the same as not voting?”). The results of analysis are meant to show to what extent the actual behaviour of the MPs reflect their political membership and what are the actual relations (in terms of true behaviour) between political groupings represented in the parliament.
The objective of the altogether modest study was two-fold: (1) to assess the capacity of the (definite algorithms of) cluster analysis in identification of the group structure of attitudes expressed through voting behaviour, and, given that such a capacity exists, (2) to compare the structure obtained with the formal membership in the political organizations, and also, though only marginally, with the structure of the political scene assumed or perceived in the mass media or through the political pronouncements.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
D. Anckar, N. Hannu and M. Wiberg, eds., Rationality and Legitimacy. Essays on Political Theory, The Finnish Political Science Association ( Jyvaskyla, Finland, 1988).
J.S. Chipman and P. Winker, Optimal industrial classification by threshold accepting, Control and Cybernetics 24(4) (1995) 477–494.
M.J. Holler, ed., Power, Voting, and Voting Power(Physica, Wuerzburg, 1982).
J.W. Hołubiec and J.W. Mercik, Techniki i Tajniki Głosowania(Omnitech Press, Warszawa, 1992).
J. Hołubiec, A. Małkiewicz, M. Mazurkiewicz, J.W. Mercik and D. Wagner, Identification of ideological dimensions under fuzziness: the case of Poland, in: Consensus under Fuzziness, eds. J. Kacprzyk et al. (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, 1997) pp. 267–284.
P. Kadłuczka and K. Wala, Tabu search and genetic algorithms for the generalized graph partitioning problem, Control and Cybernetics 24(4) (1995) 459–476.
H. Kliemt, A philosophical view of power, in: Power, Voting, and Voting Power, ed. M.J. Holler (Physica, Wuerzburg, 1982) pp. 52–64.
N.R. Miller, Power in game forms, in: Power, Voting, and Voting Power, ed. M.J. Holler (Physica, Wuerzburg, 1982) pp. 33–51.
H. Nurmi, The problem of the right distribution of voting power, in: Power, Voting, and Voting Power, ed. M.J. Holler (Physica, Wuerzburg, 1982) pp. 203–212.
H. Nurmi, On rationality and legitimacy of voting procedures, in: Rationality and Legitimacy. Essays on Political Theory, eds. D. Anckar et al. (The Finnish Political Science Association, Jyvaskyla, Finland, 1988) pp. 129–145.
J.W. Owsi´nski, On a quasi-objective global clustering method, in: Data Analysis and Informatics, eds. E. Diday et al. (North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1984).
J.W. Owsi´nski, On a new naturally indexed quick clustering method with a global objective function, Applied Stochastic Modelling and Data Analysis 6 (1990) 157–171.
J.W. Owsi´nski, Nowa metoda analizy skupie´nz globalna¸ funkcja¸ celu (A new method of cluster analysis with a global objective function; in Polish), Ph.D. dissertation, Systems Research Institute, Polish Academy of Sciences, Warsaw, Poland (1991).
B.E. Rasch, Political legitimacy and collective rationality of parliamentary voting procedures, in: Rationality and Legitimacy. Essays on Political Theory, eds. D. Anckar et al. (The Finnish Political Science Association, Jyvaskyla, Finland, 1988) pp. 146–164.
G. Szkatuła, J.W. Hołubiec and D. Wagner, Forecasting voting behaviour using machine learning, In this volume (2000).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Owsiński, J.W., Zadrożny, S. Structuring the set of MPs in Polish Parliament: A simple clustering exercise. Annals of Operations Research 97, 15–29 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1018984409716
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1018984409716