Gaëtan Mourmant
ABSTRACT
A new model for understanding job turnover was introduced into the management literature a decade ago [26], analyzing the process by which employees decide to leave their jobs. This "unfolding model of voluntary turnover" is a radical departure from traditional models of job turnover, positing that turnover is not necessarily triggered by job dissatisfaction. In addition to empirical testing with nurses, accountants, and other knowledge workers, the unfolding model has also been applied to study IS personnel. Based on a study of IS graduates from two American universities, Niederman and Sumner [34] concluded that IS employees appear not to follow the common decision paths identified by Lee and Mitchell in their initial conceptualization of the unfolding model; instead, a vast majority of respondents followed turnover decisions path not specified in the model. Although other modifications to the model have since been made [12], it is still not clear why the study of IS professionals diverged so much from prior studies of other types of knowledge workers. We first explore and identify the divergence of results between IS employees and other occupations that have been studied with the model, and then propose that an individual's personality type can affect the likelihood that he or she will follow specific decision paths in the model -- such as leaving without having a new job arranged in advance. We contribute to the IS personnel literature by offering a novel explanation for the divergence in prior empirical results. In addition, by examining personality type, we seek to open a new area of study, in terms of examining the relationship between personality type and employees' preferences for following certain paths leading to job turnover.
- Alavi, M. and Joachimstaler, E.A. "Revisiting DSS Implementation Research: A Meta-Analysis of the Literature and Suggestions for Researchers," MIS Quarterly, 16: 1, 1992, 95--116. Google Scholar
Digital Library
- Bartol, K.M. "Turnover among DP Personnel: A Casual Analysis," Communications of the ACM, 26: 10, 1983, 807--811. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Barton, K.M. and Martin, K. "Managing Information Systems Personnel: A Review of the Literature and Managerial Implications." MIS Quarterly, 6, 1982, 49--70.Google ScholarDigital Library
- Benbasat, I. and Taylor, N. "The Impact of Cognitive Styles on Information System Design," MIS Quarterly, 2: 2, 1978, 45--56.Google ScholarDigital Library
- Bradley, J.H. and Hebert, F.J. "The Effect of Personality Type on Team Performance." Journal of Management Development, 16: 5, 1997, 337--353.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Buie, E.A. "Psychological Type and Job Satisfaction in Scientific Computer Professionals," Journal of Psychological Type 15, 1988, 50--53.Google Scholar
- Bush, C.M., Schkade, L.L. "In Search of the Perfect Programmer," Datamation, 31: 6, 1985, 128--132. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Capretz, L.F. "Personality Types in Software Engineering," International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 58: 2, 2003, 207--214. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Chilton, M.A., Hardgrave, B.C., and Armstrong, D.J. "Person-Job Cognitive Style Fit for Software Developers," Journal of Management Information Systems, 22: 2, 2005, 193--226. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Clark, J.G., Walz, D. and Wynekoop, J. "Identifying Exceptional Application Software Developers: A Comparison of Students and Professionals," Communications of the AIS, 11, 2003. cais.aisnet.orgGoogle Scholar
- Davis, D.L. and D.F. Davis. "The Effect of Training Techniques and Personal Characteristics on Training End Users of Information Systems," Journal of Management Information Systems, 7: 2, 1990, 93--110. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Donnelly, D.P. and Quinn, J.J. "An Extension of Lee and Mitchell's Unfolding Model of Voluntary Turnover," Journal of Organizational Behavior, 27: 1, 2006, 59--77.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Garfield, M.J., Taylor, N.J., Dennis, A.R., and Satzinger, J.W. "Modifying Paradigms: Individual Differences, Creativity Techniques and Exposure to Ideas in Group Idea Generation," Information Systems Research, 12: 3, 2001, 322--333. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Gardner, William L.; Martinko, Mark J. "Using the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator to Study Managers: A Literature Review and Research Agenda," Journal of Management, 22: 1, 1996, 45--83.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Gorla, N. and Lam, Y.-W. "Who Should Work with Whom?" Communications of the ACM, 47: 6, 2004, 79--82. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Hirsh, S.K. Using the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator in Organizations (2nd ed.). Palo Alto, CA : Consulting Psychologists Press, 1991.Google Scholar
- Huber, G.P. "Cognitive Style as a Basis for MS and DSS Designs: Much Ado About Nothing?" Management Science, 29:5, 1983, 567--579.Google ScholarDigital Library
- Igbaria, M., Greenhaus, J. and Parasuraman, S. "Career Orientations of MIS Employees: An Empirical Analysis," MIS Quarterly, 15: 2, 1991, 151--169. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Jahng, J.J., Jain, H. and Ramamurthy, K. "Personality Traits and Effectiveness of Presentation of Product Information in eBusiness Systems," European Journal of Information Systems, 11, 2002, 181--194.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Jiang, J.J., Klein, G. and Balloun, J.L. "The Joint Impact of Internal and External Career Anchors on Entry-level IS Career Satisfaction," Information & Management, 39: 1, 2001, 31--39. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Joseph, D. and Ang, S. "Turnover of IT Professionals: A Quantitative Analysis of the Literature," Proceedings of ACM SIG MIS Computer Personnel Research Conference, Philadelphia, PA, 2003, 130--132. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Joseph, D., Ang, S., and Slaughter, S. "Identifying the Prototypical Career Paths of IT Professionals: A Sequence and Cluster Analysis," Proceedings of ACM SIG MIS Computer Personnel Research Conference, Claremont, CA, 2005, 94--96. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Jung, C.-G., Psychological Type, Geneva, Switzerland: Georg Editeur, 1993.Google Scholar
- Kaiser, K.M. and Bostrom, R.P. "Personality Characteristics of MIS Project Teams: An Empirical Study and Action-Research Design," MIS Quarterly, 6: 4, 1982, 43--60.Google ScholarDigital Library
- Kennedy, R.B., and Kennedy, D.A. "Using the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator in Career Counseling," Journal of Employment Counseling, 41: 1, 2004, 38--44.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Lee, T.W. and Mitchell, T.R., "An Alternative Approach: The Unfolding Model of Voluntary Employee Turnover," Academy of Management Review, 19: 1, 1994, 51--89.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Lee, T.W., Mitchell, T.R., Wise, L. and Fireman, S. "An Unfolding Model of Voluntary Employee Turnover," Academy of Management Journal, 39: 1, 1996, 5--36.Google Scholar
- Lee, T.W. and Maurer, S.D., "The Retention of Knowledge Workers with the Unfolding Model of Voluntary Turnover," Human Resource Management Review, 7: 3, 1997, 247--275.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Lee, T.W., Mitchell, T.R., Holtom, B.C., McDaniel, L.S. and Hill, J.W. "The Unfolding Model of Voluntary Turnover: A Replication and Extension," Academy of Management Journal, 42: 4, 1999, 450--462.Google Scholar
- Lyons, M.L., 1985. "The DP Psyche," Datamation, 31: 16, 103--110. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Moore, J.E. and Love, M.S. "An Examination of Prestigious Stigma: The Case of the Technology Geek," Proceedings of the 2004 ACM SIG MIS Conference on Computer Personnel, Tucson, 103. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Myers, I.B. Introduction to Type, Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologist Press, 1976.Google Scholar
- Myers, I.B. Introduction aux types psychologiques, Consulting Psychologist Press, 2001.Google Scholar
- Niederman, F. and Sumner, M. "Decision Paths Affecting Turnover among Information Technology Professionals," Proceedings of ACM SIG MIS Computer Personnel Research Conference, Philadelphia, PA, 2003, 133--142. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Nutt, P.C. "Evaluating MIS Design Principles," MIS Quarterly, 10: 2, 1986, 139--156.Google ScholarDigital Library
- Robey, D. and Taggart, W. "Human Information Processing in Information and Decision Support Systems," MIS Quarterly, 6: 2, 1982, 62--73.Google ScholarDigital Library
- Schein, E.H. "Career Anchors Revisited: Implications for Career Development in the 21st Century," Academy of Management Executive, 10: 4, 1996, 80--88.Google Scholar
- Smith, D.C. "The Personality of the Systems Analyst: An Investigation," ACM Computer Personnel 12, 1989, 12--14. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Teague, J. "Personality Type, Career Preference and Implications for Computer Science Recruitment and Teaching", Proceedings of the 3rd Australasian Conference on Computer Science Education, 1998, 155--163. Google ScholarDigital Library
- White, K.B. "MIS Project Teams: An Investigation of Cognitive Style Implications," MIS Quarterly, 8: 2, 1984, 95--101.Google ScholarDigital Library
- White, K.B. and Leifer, R. "Information Systems Development Success: Perspectives from Project Team Participants," MIS Quarterly, 10: 3, 1985, 215--223. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Witt, L.A. & Burke, L.A. "Selecting High-performing IT Professionals." Journal of End User Computing, 14: 4, 2002. 37--50.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Woszczynski, A.B., Guthrie, T.C. and Shade, S. "Personality and Programming," Journal of Information Systems Education, 16: 3, 2005, 293--299.Google Scholar
Index Terms
- How personality type influences decision paths in the unfolding model of voluntary job turnover: an application to IS professionals
Recommendations
A necessary clarification of the unfolding model of voluntary turnover
SIGMIS CPR '09: Proceedings of the special interest group on management information system's 47th annual conference on Computer personnel researchThe unfolding model of voluntary turnover, as tested by Niederman et al. [1], surprisingly appears to only capture 12% of the job leavers in IT, whereas when applied to other occupational groups, such as accountant or nurses, this ratio is much higher (...
Career anchors and disturbances in job turnover decisions - A case study of IT professionals in Taiwan
Previous models of turnover by IT professionals consider job satisfaction as a key indicator. One common model considers whether an organization matches the internal anchors of IT employees to provisions in the work place. This pattern is often broken ...
Adapting and extending the unfolding model of voluntary job turnover to IS entrepreneurs'
SIGMIS CPR '08: Proceedings of the 2008 ACM SIGMIS CPR conference on Computer personnel doctoral consortium and researchThis proposal builds on the interaction between a dynamic construct that I call entrepreneur maturation (EM) and the shock construct from Lee et al (1996)'s Unfolding Model of Turnover. This proposal describes an exploratory study in which I seek to ...
Comments