Sylvie Thellier
ABSTRACT
Preventive approaches in risk management assume that the first step is risk analysis. However, an important basis for this work is the prior identification of risks. Our critical analysis of the "Failure Mode and Effects Analysis" method (FMEA) has shown that risk identification is not self-evident. Risk identification is not intuitive especially when risks are not apparent, as in Radiotherapy. We assume that the classical models are incomplete. In this way, the first step for reflection groups is the identification of the risks. We suggest changing both the composition of the classical reflection groups and the object of reflection that standard methods propose. We also suggest carrying out an experiment with multi-trade reflection groups. Participants have to share the real work or their activities from the "particular situation" of work -- defined later in the text - in order to improve the treatment safety.
- Amalberti, R. Piloter la sécurité -- théories et pratiques sur les compromis et les arbitrages nécessaires. Paris, Springer (2014).Google Scholar
- Aven, T. What is safety science? Safety Science 67 (2014), 15--17.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Beguin, P. Innovation et cadre sociocognitif des interactions concepteurs-opérateurs: une approche développementale. Le travail humain. Vol. 70 (2007), 369--390.Google Scholar
- Carroll, J., & Fahlbruch, B. "The gift of failure: New approaches to analyzing and learning from events and near-misses." Honoring the contributions of Bernhard Wilpert. Safety Science, 49(1) (2011), 1--4.Google Scholar
- Daniellou, F., Le Gal, S. & Proméé, M. Organisational simulation: anticipating the ability of an organisation to cope with daily operations and incidents. Nordic Ergonomics Society Annual Conf. (2014), 781--785.Google Scholar
- Dassens, A. & Launay, R. ÉÉtude systémique de l'analyse de risques - Présentation d'une approche globale. Techniques de l'ingénieur (2008), 215--236.Google Scholar
- De Bovis, C., Baret, C. & Ientile-Yaenios, J. Les apports du concept «« d'organisation à haute fiabilité » à l'amélioration de la sécurité et de la qualité des soins dans les services de soins aigus. Communication au 1er congrès de l'ARAMOS, Paris. (2013).Google Scholar
- Detchessahar, M. « Pour une théorie de l'espace de discussion - Quand discuter c'est produire ». Revue Française de gestion (2001a), 32--43.Google Scholar
- Detchessahar, M. Le «dire » et le «faire » : Contribution à l'étude des nouvelles formes d'organisation. Revue de gestion des ressources humaines, no.39, (2001b), 43--56.Google Scholar
- Detchessahar, M. L'avènement de l'entreprise communicationnelle. Revue française de gestion, (2003), 65--84.Google Scholar
- Dien, Y., Dechy, N., & Guillaume, E. Accident investigation: From searching direct causes to finding in-depth causes -- Problem of analysis or/and of analyst? Safety Science, 50(6) (2012), 1398--1407Google ScholarCross Ref
- Escande, J. & al. Signaux faibles : un concept pertinent? Réécents progrès en Génie des Procédés, 104 (2013). Ed. SFGP, Paris, France.Google Scholar
- Fassert, C., Faye H. Que faire de la culture de sécurité? In A. Garrigou et F. Jeffroy (Eds.). L'ergonomie à la croisée des risques. Actes du 46eme congrès de la SELF (2011), 171--177.Google Scholar
- Hollnagel, E. Barriers and accident Prevention. Aldershot, Royaume-Uni : Ashgate (2004).Google Scholar
- Hollnagel, E. Risk + barriers = safety? Safety science, 46(2) (2008), 221--229.Google Scholar
- Leplat, J. Risque et perception du risque dans l'activité. In D. R. Kouabenan, B. Cadet, D. Hermand & M. T. Munoz Sastre (Eds.), Psychologie du risque : identifier, éévaluer et prévenir (2006), 19--33).Google Scholar
- Macrae, C. Interrogation the unknown: Risk Analysis and sensemaking in airline Safety Oversight. In the centre for analysis of risk and regulation. Discussion paper no.43 (2007).Google Scholar
- Marc, J., & Rogalski, J. How do individual operators contribute to the reliability of collective activity? The case of a French medical emergency center. In C. A. Owen, P. Béguin & G. Wakers (Eds.), Risky Work Environments: Reappraising Human Work within Fallible Systems (2009), 129--147.Google Scholar
- Meyrieux, C. & al. Analyse des risques a priori du processus de prise en charge des patients en radiothéérapie : exemple d'utilisation de la méthode Amdec. Revue Cancer / Radiothérapie, 16 (2012), 613--618.Google Scholar
- Mollo, V., & Falzon, P. The development of collective reliability: a study of therapeutic decision-making. Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science, 9(3) (2008), 223--254.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Nascimento, A., & Falzon, P. Jugement difféérentiel d'acceptabilité et cultures de sécurité en radiothérapie. Le travail humain, 77(4) (2014), 325--349.Google Scholar
- Osorio, C., & Clot, Y. L'analyse collective des accidents du travail : Une mééthode d'analyse pour intégrer la dimension subjective et développer le genre professionnel. Activités, 7(2) (2010)28--41.Google Scholar
- Peretti-Watel, P. La société du risque. Paris, La découverte, Coll. Repères, no. 321 (2001).Google Scholar
- Rocha, R., Mollo, V., & Daniellou, F. Work debate spaces: A tool for developing a participatory safety management. Applied Ergonomics, 46 (2015) 107--114.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Roux-Dufort, C. Les dirigeants à l'école de l'ignorance. In P. Lagadec (dir.). Ruptures créatrices, Paris, Vuibert (2000).Google Scholar
- Schöbel, M., & Manzey, D. Subjective theories of organizing and learning from events. Safety Science, 49(1) (2011), 47--54.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Tanzi, T. J. & Delmer, F. Ingéénierie du risque. Hermes science publication (2006).Google Scholar
- Thellier, S., & Jeffroy, F. L'éétude des risques en radiothérapie : état des lieux et perspectives d'amélioration. Rapport IRSN/PSN-SRDS/SFOHR no 2014-01 (2014).Google Scholar
- Weick, K. E., Sutcliffe, K. M., Obstfeld, D. Organizing for high reliability: processes of collective mindfulness. In B. Staw and L. L. Cummings (Eds.), Research in organizational behavior, 21 (1999) 81--123.Google Scholar
Index Terms
- Construction of an "activity sharing space" to improve healthcare safety
Recommendations
Human-Factor-Based Risk Management in the Healthcare to Improve Patient Safety
'Patient Safety' tries to increase safety and transparency within healthcare systems for both patients and professionals. Within the healthcare sector, workflows become more and more complex, while time and money become scarce. As a consequence, the ...
Types and Characteristics of Safety Accidents Induced by Metro Construction
ICIII '09: Proceedings of the 2009 International Conference on Information Management, Innovation Management and Industrial Engineering - Volume 03Due to the special geological conditions and the surrounding environmental conditions, the urban metro constructions are faced with greater technical difficulty and higher safety risk, which cause many kinds of safety accidents. Taking Beijing metro as ...
Risk assessment model selection in construction industry
Construction industry faces a lot of inherent uncertainties and issues. As this industry is plagued by risk, risk management is an important part of the decision-making process of these companies. Risk assessment is the critical procedure of risk ...
Comments