Michael J. Cuellar
Abstract
Niemimaa (2016) argues that agential realism (Barad 2003) represents a radical form of sociomateriality (Cecez-Kecmanovic et al. 2014a; Orlikowski and Scott 2008) and that critical realism (Bhaskar 1979; Bhaskar 1997) represents a conservative form of sociomateriality and attempts to bring to the foreground the differences in the approaches so as to avoid inappropriate "theoretical mélanges." This response argues that critical realism is not properly part of the sociomaterial stream of research as it violates the five basic notions of sociomateriality (Jones 2014). It further suggests that given the criticisms of Mutch (2013) and Leonardi (2013) as confirmed by Scott and Orlikowski (2013) of Agential Realism represent significant issues that compromise the usefulness of agential realism for IS research. Nevertheless, it is important that whatever paradigm is chosen, it is important to use it faithfully to its meta-theoretical commitments.
- Archer, M. S. 1982. "Morphogenesis Versus Structuration: On Combining Structure and Action," The British Journal of Sociology (33:4), pp. 455--483.Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- Archer, M. S. 1988. Culture and Agency, the Place of Culture in Social Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Archer, M. S. 1995. Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic Approach, (1st ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google ScholarCross Ref
- Archer, M. S. 2000. Being Human: The Problem of Agency. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar
- Archer, M. S. 2003. Structure, Agency and the Internal Conversation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google ScholarCross Ref
- Barad, K. 2003. "Posthumanist Performativity: Toward an Understanding of How Matter Comes to Matter.," Signs (28:3), pp. 801--83Google ScholarCross Ref
- Bhaskar, R. 1979. The Possibility of Naturalism, (1st ed.). Brighton, Sussex: The Harvester Press Limited.Google Scholar
- Bhaskar, R. 1997. A Realist Theory of Science, (2nd ed.). London: Verso.Google Scholar
- Bhaskar, R. 1998. "Critical Realism and Dialectic," in Critical Realism: Essential Readings, M. Archer, R. Bhaskar, A. Collier, C. Lawon and A. Norrie (eds.). London: Routledge, pp. 589--640.Google Scholar
- Cecez-Kecmanovic, D., Galliers, R. D., Henfrisson, O., Newell, S., and Vidgen, R. 2014a. "The Sociomateriality of Information Systems: Current Status, Future Directions," MIS Quarterly (38:3), pp. 809--830. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Cecez-Kecmanovic, D., Kautz, K., and Abrahall, R. 2014b. "Reframing Success and Failure of Information Systems: A Performative Perspective," Mis Quarterly (38:2), pp. 561--588. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Collier, A. 1994. "Critical Realism: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Roy Bhaskar." London: Verso.Google Scholar
- Hanseth, O. 2005. "Beyond Metaphysics and Theory Consumerism," Scandinavian Journal of Information Systems (17:1), pp. 159--166.Google Scholar
- Jones, M. 2014. "A Matter of Life and Death: Exploring Conceptualizations of Sociomateriality in the Context of Critical Care," MIS Quarterly (38:3), pp. 895--925. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Kuhn, T. S. 1996. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, (3rd ed.). Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. Google ScholarCross Ref
- Lawson, C. 2008. "An Ontology of Technology: Artefacts, Relations and Functions," in: Techne: Research in Philosophy and Technology. Blacksburg, VA: Virginia Technological University. Google ScholarCross Ref
- Leonardi, P. M. 2011. "When Flexible Routines Meet Flexible Technologies: Affordance, Constraint and the Imbrication of Human and Material Agencies," MIS Quarterly (35:1), pp. 147--167. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Leonardi, P. M. 2012. "Materiality, Sociomateriality, and Socio-Technical Systems: What Do These Terms Mean? How Are They Related? Do We Need Them?," in Materiality and Organizing: Social Interaction in a Technological World, P.M. Leonardi, B.A. Nardi and J. Kallinkos (eds.). Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 25--48.Google Scholar
- Leonardi, P. M. 2013. "Theoretical Foundations for the Study of Sociomateriality," Information and Organization (23), pp. 59--73. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Leonardi, P. M., and Barley, S. R. 2008. "Materiality and Change: Challenges to Building Better Theory About Technology and Organizing," Information and Organization (18), pp. 159--176. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Mingers, J. 2004. "Real-Izing Information Systems: Critical Realism as an Underpinning Philosophy for Information Systems," Information and Organization (14), pp. 87--103. Google ScholarCross Ref
- Mingers, J. 2006. "A Critique of Statistical Modelling in Management Science from a Critical Realist Perspective: Its Role within Multimethodology," Journal of the Operational Research Society (57:2), pp. 202--219.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Mingers, J., Mutch, A., and Willcocks, L. 2013. "Critical Realism in Information Systems Research," MIS Quarterly (37:3), pp. 795--802. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Mingers, J., and Willcocks, L. 2014. "An Integrative Semiotic Framework for Information Systems: The Social, Personal and Material Worlds," Information and Organization (24:1), pp. 48--70. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Mutch, A. 2013. "Sociomateriality - Taking the Wrong Turning?," Information and Organization (23), pp. 28--40. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Niemimaa, M. 2016. "Sociomateriality and Information Systems Research: Quantum Radicals and Cartesian Conservatives," The Data Base for the Advances in Information Systems (47:4). Google ScholarDigital Library
- Scott, S. V., and Orlikowski, W. J. 2013. "Sociomateriality -- Taking the Wrong Turning? A Response to Mutch," Information and Organization (23), pp. 77--80. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Truex, D., Holmstrom, J., and Keil, M. 2006. "Theorizing in Information Systems Research: A Reflexive Analysis of the Adaptation of Theory in Information," Journal of the Association for Information Systems (7:12), pp. 797--821.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Zachariadis, M., Scott, S., and Barrett, M. 2013. "Methodological Implications of Critical Realism for Mixed-Methods Research," MIS Quarterly (37:3). Google ScholarDigital Library
Index Terms
- Critical Realism as a Sociomaterial Stream of Research
Recommendations
Sociomateriality and Information Systems Research: Quantum Radicals and Cartesian Conservatives
This paper provides an elaboration and comparison of two main streams of "sociomateriality" research within Information Systems (IS) discipline. Through the rapid and controversial emergence of discussions around sociomateriality, IS research has become ...
Felt quality of sociomaterial relations: Introducing emotions into sociomaterial theorizing
Sociomateriality, in helping to overcome the longstanding dualism between the social and the technical, has become an increasingly popular theoretical perspective in Information Systems (IS) research. However, while recognizing the usefulness of ...
Critical realism and learning analytics research: epistemological implications of an ontological foundation
LAK '15: Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Learning Analytics And KnowledgeLearning analytics is a broad church that incorporates a range of topics and methodologies. As the field has developed some tension has emerged regarding a perceived contradiction between the implied constructivist ethos of the field and prevalent ...
Comments