Jack M. Wolfe
ABSTRACT
This paper discusses limitations of programming aptitude tests. The use of multiple-choice type questions, the testwiseness of the college graduate group, and the inclusion of questions of mathematical information tend to diminish the effectiveness of such tests as predictors of success in business programming. Timed tests favor the faster worker over the slower one who is often more accurate and of equal or better logical capability. The usual criterion of a test's validity is itself often not valid as a simulation of the true criterion but is accepted as the equivalent of the criterion because of its measurability and its appearance of plausibility. Comparative results of various occupational groups on the author's Aptitude Assessment Battery: Programming test are analyzed based on the scores of more than 11,000 persons tested, including more than 2,700 persons with work experience in programming in 317 companies, institutions, and government agencies.
- 1.Reinstedt, R. N. et al, 'Computer personnel research group programmer performance prediction study' (RM-4033-PR), The RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, Calif., March 1964, as printed in Proceedings of the Fifth Annual Computer Personnel Research Conference, June 1967Google Scholar
- 2.Cross, E. M., 'The behavioral styles of computer programmers', Computer Personnel Research Group, Annual Conference, 1970 Google ScholarDigital Library
- 3.Hall, R. S., 'The construction of a selection battery for programmers adapted to South African conditions', Computer Personnel Research Group, Annual Conference, 1970 Google ScholarDigital Library
- 4.Wolfe, J.M., 'Testing for programming aptitude', Datamation, April 1969Google Scholar
- 5.Programming Specialists, Inc., P. O. Box 160, Brooklyn, N. Y. 11234Google Scholar
- 6.Wolfe, J. M., 'A new look at programming aptitudes', Business Automation, August 1970Google Scholar
- 7.McNamara, W. J. and Hughes, J. L., 'A review of research on the selection of computer programmers', Personnel Psychology, 1961Google ScholarCross Ref
- 8.Oliver, T. C. and Willis, W. K., 'A study of the validity of the programmer aptitude test', Educational and Psychological measurement, vol. 23, no. 4, 1963Google Scholar
- 9.Palormo, J. M., Computer Programming Aptitude Battery, 1967, Science Research Associates, Inc., Chicago, IllinoisGoogle Scholar
Index Terms
- Perspectives on testing for programming aptitude
Recommendations
MasterMind©: a predictor of computer programming aptitude
For two semesters, the authors have tested CS1 introductory students on their ability to play the MasterMind© game at the beginning of the semester and compared those scores with in class programming test scores. The resulting correlations suggest that ...
Testing Programming Aptitude through Commonsense Computing
ACE '24: Proceedings of the 26th Australasian Computing Education ConferenceBackground. Programming aptitude tests are of interest since the beginning of computing education research. Many novices have no experience with programming languages before their first course. Yet they have different levels of commonsense computing.
...
Computer testing in education: emerging trends
The rapid growth of the Internet and intranets supports the infrastructure necessary for computer-based testing (CBT). The parallel growth of sophisticated computer programming and powerful computers offers new possibilities in testing, such as ...
Comments